r/DnD•
Delann

What would you like to see in a DM workshop?

DMing

So I'm gonna participate in a little get-together at a local game store aimed at teaching more people how to be a DM, share experiences and tips, the sort. Won't be anything super formal and right now the whole thing is almost a blank slate beyond some general topics so I was curious, if you were to participate, what would you like to see at this kind of event. I'm particularly interested in how you'd like the topic of "Plot hooks, railroading and free roam" to be addressed but any suggestions are welcome.

Posted Aug 1, 2021, 4:03 PM UTC

13
its_pony•

I've been to a few and found a lot of them focused almost exclusively on mechanics and rules and seemed very book/module heavy instead of talking about what makes a good DM, knowing when and how to say no, being assertive without being aggressive. Forcing the players into a situation but not ever limiting their choices is a huge thing for DMs that I have rarely seen covered in DM workshops/introductions.

I've also found a lot of newer DMs who use these tools tend to be very rules dependant and it becomes more about the letter of the rule. It's like people expect the rule of cool to cover all of this without fully explaining it. You need to teach balance and improv as well imo

3
crazy_cat_lord•

If I had to boil down to one topic that I think is the most important thing for a DM, I would talk about how the DM is responsible for curating the experience of a group through selecting the right players. This covers everything from player attitudes and respect for each other and the game, to specifics like preferred styles of play or genres.

Each player is unique, having individual preferences, experience, and personalities. Each player has a different internal image of what DnD is, and what they want out of it. Outside of the game, each player has lived a different life and has different opinions. All of that includes you by the way, not just your players. And while these things aren't static, people can change, it's important to know that as a DM, you can't control anyone else or make them change. All you can really do is show people good behavior to model, and talk to them when they aren't behaving the way you like, but they're the only one who decides what they do. You can't "fix" someone's behavior directly. You can't "change" what someone wants out of the game.

Not to say that you need a group of identical players to have a good game, variety being the spice of life and all. But, your game needs to have all compatible players, both with each other and you as a DM. Having "similar" players can help with this, though similar groups can end up incompatible, and very diverse groups may be totally compatible if they are all open to compromise and having a wide palate so each player can get what they want. But if you have players who actively want what another player doesn't, or don't want what another player does, you can't make everyone happy.

The point is that lots of DMs think that a good DM can make any group work, and that's flat out not true. Some groups will be doomed to fail from the beginning just due to the specific players within the group. Some groups start fine until someone turns into a bad egg later. I think the biggest responsibility of the DM is to try and continually strive to get and keep that compatibility within the group. Both when originally deciding on players to include in your game, and even after as the game is played from session to session.

Before you play, you pick players who you think will work well together and with you. And after that, just because you have a group doesn't mean you stop thinking about curating the list of people at your table. You have to pay attention for red flags, and certainly work to ease any out-of-game tension between players that comes up. Depending on the severity of the incompatibility you see, you might talk to the group to make sure they agree that something is a problem, you might talk to offending players to see if they're willing to change, but none of that is required for legitimately bad problems.

And you can't be squeamish about cutting out the problems once you've defined them. A player who plays in bad faith or is enough of a poor fit for your group will almost always lead to problems down the line, and it's not unthinkable that when the fuse finally runs dry, the entire group might suffer and maybe collapse entirely. The group looks to you for leadership, and if someone isn't working out, it's on you to uninvite them for the sake of the rest of the group's enjoyment, and for the longevity and integrity of your game.

The other factor is that it's often not a simple case of "This player good, that player bad." The freedom inherent in DnD means that even someone that I'd consider the most vile, gross, bad faith asshole might be a perfect fit for a different group regardless of how much I can't imagine anyone wanting to play with them. DnD isn't a genre, it's a medium, and specific examples are not objectively good or bad, but up to opinion.

Most people probably think The Human Centipede is a terrible film, but I'm sure some people genuinely like it. Those people would have a good time watching it together, but I would not want to be a part of that watch party. And a group full of players who all want their game to be the DnD equivalent to The Human Centipede probably have a great time! If I tried to come in and change their group, I'd be the incompatible one, I'd be in the wrong. But I don't like that, so I choose players who also don't want that. And someone who comes in and tries to turn my game into that is a bad fit for my group. Not a bad player, a bad fit.

1
crazy_cat_lord•

Crazy cat lord, pt. 2.

Virtually every aspect of the game that has a hive mind "right answer" really drills back down to "There's no single right way to play DnD."

It's easy to say "railroading bad," but some groups want a guided experience on rails. Hoard of the Dragon Queen wouldn't exist if nobody wanted that.

It's easy to say "metagaming bad," but it's literally a part of your brain you can't turn off. If I know a troll is weak to fire and acid, I can't un-know that. If my character doesn't know, I now have to deal with a paradox that has no right answer. If I didn't know that weakness, I could look at my list of spells and cast fireball on my first turn for literally any reason and it wouldn't be metagaming. But because I know, I'm not allowed to exploit it right away. Every turn I get to ask myself, "Has it been long enough that it's realistic for me to use what I already know will work?" And every turn that I don't cast fireball, I'm actively impeding my group's chance of success. Personally, I only view metagaming as bad when the knowledge of information is kept from the DM. Don't read the adventure in advance just to know where everything is. And if you already read it in advance for a different reason, tell the DM so they can run something else or adjust it if they want. But again, that's my take on it.

It's easy to say "fudging" is good or bad, and come up with reasons for either. It's easy to say "chance of PC death" is good or bad, and come up with reasons for either. There are points in favor of using XP, there are points in favor of using milestones. Points for or against multiclassing, flanking, literally anything in the game. I can't imagine playing DnD without combat at all, I think there's better tabletop games to play if you're going to throw out half the rulebook. But I can't sit here and say that a group that plays DnD without combat is "doing it wrong" if they all like that and have fun with it.

It all boils back down to knowing what you think, what your players think, and doing the right thing for your group. It's great to talk about options, to talk about opinions, to share rationales and perspectives, and I think "New DM" programs can do that to provide new DMs with a leg to stand on. So yes, talk about railroading, metagaming, whatever, but it's important to explain that anyone's take on this is their own personal opinion on it, and even a new DM could have a different perspective.

1