r/cars•
floatnspace

My budget is $4-6k. Reddit, help me find the best used car!

My wife and I are looking for a used car in the $4k-6k range. You may have seen my other post about our Hyundai Elantra getting torched. Sucks, but we have to move on and find something else.

Our parameters:

  • We don't do a ton of long commuting. Lots of short in-city (Berkeley, CA) trips and around the SF Bay Area. I doubt we would exceed 12-14k/miles per year.
  • Prefer a sedan or hatchback with good MPG.
  • Prefer a vehicle with low cost maintenance and repairs.
  • We aren't car-savvy people, so we want something in clean, solid condition. No beaters or fixer-uppers.
  • We would like the vehicle to last us 4-5 years. I figure we want a car with no more than 120k miles on it?
  • Cosmetically, we prefer clean, simple looks. Nothing too sporty. A nice sedan (Jetta, Elantra, Corolla, etc) is perfect for us.

We've mainly been perusing the SF Bay Area Craigslist. If you have any tips for buying from CL, that would be appreciated, too. I assume we should go with a Carfax no matter what, and we're using KBB for price checking.

Thanks!

Posted Jan 27, 2012, 5:26 AM UTC · edited

19
LittleStallin•

Maybe you could try going to autotrader and search for cars the match your criteria, then take that list of possibilities to CL to find a good deal.

3
Nucleonic•

It should go without saying that if you do buy from a private seller that you should get the vehicle inspected by a competent shop before any transaction takes place. There are plenty of people who hock used cars on places like Craigslist that have non-visible damage, serious powertrain issues, and other costly problems. Experienced con artists can easily cover it up just well enough that it drives fine on the test drive; don't be deceived if it "runs and drives fine" at first.

Also in many jurisdictions it is mandatory for dealers to accept returns if you aren't satisfied with the vehicle. Try to buy from a dealer if you're not "car savvy."

2
floatnspaceOP•

Yeah, we were planning on doing this if we buy from a private seller. I'm pretty sure we can find a shop that will do a free inspection.

We're trying to avoid dealers just because the markup seems so steep. Our finances are tight right now, so we'd rather look for a deal.

1
Nucleonic•

There are usually a few dealers out there that specialize in older "not quite a beater but not a certified used" type vehicle. I know of at least one in my city that's run by honest people, they were very up front about what is and could go wrong with the older vehicles on their lot. A friend of mine bought an ancient (but well cared for) '84 Buick for $500 and was able to fix it up into a reliable and safe car with a bit of help from yours truly.

Remember, we're in a recession and it's a lot easier to learn how to haggle than to learn auto mechanics.

2
RugerRedhawk260z•

cars.com has a great interface for searching for this. Plug in the minimum year, max mileage, and max price. Give yourself a wide geographic range.

2
floatnspaceOP•

Okay, thanks, I'll check it out.

1
glidej2015 GTI, 1965 Mustang•

it sounds like a civic would be the prudent choice.

1
floatnspaceOP•

I did some searches for Civics. They seem a bit pricey compared to other vehicles in the same class. The Toyota, Hyundai, and Mazda models seem to be a better deal with lower mileage for the dollar (miles driven that is, not MPG).

1
bluerex2004 WRX Wagon•

The civic will save you money in the long run (well maybe not over the toyota) but the Civic is all around a better car.

1