Tried to work a bit more with cast shadows. Any critique is appreciated!

Posted Aug 11, 2021, 3:06 PM UTC

Posted Aug 11, 2021, 3:06 PM UTC
Great study! Besides what the previous comment said, I think you've underestimating how much bounce light these areas would receive. They're very close to their surroundings, meaning the light from the environment would reflect and brighten them up. The middle one is the farthest from any nearby surface so it should be the darkest of the three. Also, the plane direction matters here as well, the planes on the shadow side shouldn't all be the same value. The light from the cylinder is bouncing on the bottom plane more than the top plane, so the bottom plane should be lighter.
If you were to paint this light source object floating in the night sky, you could make the areas I mentioned this dark or even darker. I know it looks cooler and more visiually interesting, but you can't break the laws of physics to achieve that effect. Rather, think of a scenario in which it would be possible.
[deleted]
Thank you<3
Some critiques:
Unless you made the piece directly below the light source bigger, there should be gaps of light between the shadows on the floor. Or at least there would if not for a more important issue…
The glowing ball light source is so big that it would not cast sharp shadows. All shadow edges would be very blurred.
The second pillar from the right (assuming it’s cylindrical) has too sharp of a gradation from light to dark even if the light source were a precise point. There should be a more gradual gradient of halftones from illuminated to shadowed.
I see! Thank you very much:)