Can people in my chain legally convince me to stay in?

Question

Might be a silly question, but I was wondering if there were any JAGs or AFI junkies in the chat who knew if my chain can legally try and convince me to re-enlist. I’m not going to but I’d rather have a statement prepared if they ask why I’m not. Maybe I’m just paranoid but 1N anything will do that to ya ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Posted Aug 11, 2021, 11:26 PM UTC · edited

034
NotOSIsdormmoleHave you signed off your read file?•

You’re not getting out of going to informed decision, just stop

27
DomPixel2Vegetable Root Technician•

I just recently went to this as someone who is a nearly nine-year FTA, who is planning to re-enlist. It was truly miserable, and genuinely felt like an episode of scared straight for people who want to get out (of which there were many, a majority of whom were MX).

1
ExplosionTacoOPActive Duty•

I only ask because in my informed decision brief they explicitly said they weren’t trying to convince people one way or the other, just (as the brief title alludes to) inform them. I was wondering if this sentiment was just a thing for this brief or if it was codified somewhere. Thanks for the helpful response!

0
twist-17Maintenance Veteran•

Can they try to convince you to? Yes, and it’s pretty normal.

Can they make you? Of course not.

You don’t have to give them any reasons or make any statement as to why you’re not re-enlisting, even if they ask you. If you feel like you need to give them a reason just tell them you’re going to school full time or some shit.

13
ExplosionTacoOPActive Duty•

Thanks for a real answer!

0
Aspalar•

You dropped this \.

10
tylerado12•

I would be more worried if they didnt try to talk me into staying.

8
personnelservices34Active Duty•

🤦‍♀️

7
ExplosionTacoOPActive Duty•

thanks for the helpful answer!!

0
personnelservices34Active Duty•

You’re welcome.

1
wm313•

Are you seriously asking if it's ok to show you the benefits of the military; the same way a recruiter did? What would an AFI say? "Never try to retain airmen despite your best efforts to want to." What would your complaint be? That they tried to convince you that the Air Force would be a path you might want to consider further travel on? This is one of the strangest 'is it in an AFI' questions I've seen.

7
Knight_of_GalaxiaMaintainer•

If you’ve ever read the enlisted force structure, not only is it allowed, it’s highly encouraged to try to retain personnel.

5
HOGCCRetired Crew Chief•

You know the kind of person who asks this kind of question has absolutely never even glanced at the Enlisted Force Structure.

7
ExplosionTacoOPActive Duty•

:)

0
[deleted]•

"Do you plan on reenlisting?"

"No"

"Good, the Air Force will be better off without you..."

​

I actually had a friend who was a great Airmen but his supervisor said he seemed pretty unhappy in the Air Force and suggested he get out and go live the life he wanted. And he did.

5
Auritus1Enlisted Aircrew•

I'm sure they can use words discuss why they think you should, but I don't think they can formally punish you in any way. I have seen bribery attempts as commanders have offered outgoing airmen "must promote" statements, and I'm really not sure that's legal.

4
SlammerEye•

Yes, they can legally bring the subject up. Heck, TAP is an entire "please stay in" indoctrination camp.

No, they cannot legally reprimand or retaliate against you for your decision.

Yes, it is annoying. Yes, you will need to set boundaries about what subjects they can broach with you.

Alternatively, if it gets bad, say "I was thinking about reenlisting, but all of these annoying inquiries are pushing me towards a no."

3
trimarcojMaintainer•

Yes they can try

Edit it’s still your decision though they can’t force yiu into anything

2
Pstanley22Maintainer•
  • but ultimately the individual makes the final choice.
3

Most people just want to make sure you have some kind of plan. I am a SNCO and always curious to know what my Airmans intentions are upon separation. Far too often I have seen those who seperate doing their damndest to rejoin after 6 months or calling their friends saying they cannot feed their wife and kids.

2
ExplosionTacoOPActive Duty•

You’re a good SNCO. I know a lot of people would say “not my Airman, not my problem” making sure people have a plan as they get out is definitely the way to go!

2
Still-rhino•

Just tell them you promised your family that you’d achieve middle class.

2
GrumpyKitten514•

help them up or help them out.

it's basically the entire job of an NCO to help you either promote, or help you positively leave the service.

you should automatically want to help anyone either get that promotion they want, or get out of the service without ending up homeless.

i fully expect my MSgt to say "fuck yeah, i am so glad you got that job offer, you're going to do great things out there and good luck!".

​

but honestly, yes everyone and their mother will try to convince you, no it is not illegal, and your "prepared statement" can be I don't want to be in the military anymore.

if anything, I might try to convince a troop just to make sure his exit plan is rock solid and he considered all the things he is leaving behind as well as making sure he considers other things on the outside he might not have.

so you might think they are trying to convince you, when maybe they are just testing your conviction and dedication and making sure you're 100% decided and you'll be okay when you bounce.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
CMSCF•

As a supervisor I have never tried to convince someone to stay in. I don't see it as my job to be a recruiter when they've already been recruited and decided it's time to move on. I've also seen leadership bend over backwards to keep someone in. He was hot shit so he basically told them he needed a guaranteed commission and that was the only way. He is now an LT.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Tell them sure you will reenlist

But never sign the documents.

In the future for anyone reading. Never tell leadership or supervisors you don’t plan to reenlist.

Always say yes you are. But your waiting on orders, reenlistment bonus, retraining, the paperwork is being processed. Anything to get them to shut up.

Then they will forget for awhile.

Rinse and repeat till you're terminal

0†
TurnoverPretend•

I don't know why you are getting downvoted, you have some truth in there. The minute you tell them you aren't reenlisting you are tossed into the corner like a broken toy, deemed useless for the remainder of your enlisted whether years or months.

3
[deleted]•

There downvoting because either they haven’t quit yet. Or they are full on the Blue Kool-Aid.

Give them time

3
twist-17Maintenance Veteran•

This sounds nice until you realize that if the reenlistment paperwork isn’t going through they’ll start asking people why, and then eventually find out you’re lying to them. Not to mention you have to actually out process and complete the out processing checklist, which they’ll know you’re working on. You don’t just hit terminal and you’re magically out processed and done.

Honestly this just sounds stupid and immature.

The alternative? Be a fucking adult, and treat other adults like adults and tell them you aren’t reenlisting.

2
[deleted]•

Tell them your not reenlisting?

What enlightened area of the Air Force do you work in?

Somewhere they treat everybody like an Angel for serving 4 years then leave?

It sure isn’t the flight line. I’ve see guys sent to the wash rack for their last 90 days.

Never tell any supervisor you don’t plan on staying in. Unless you like to get shit on.

That’s just about the biggest mistake you could possibly make.

2
twist-17Maintenance Veteran•

I was on the flight line, read my fucking flair.

Sounds like you had shit supervision, bud.

1
RepresentativeBar793Veteran•

Sometimes they will not even submit reenlistment paperwork. (Even though it is required.) Then they might try to screw you in the aftermath...

2
ViolentHiroMX SUX <3•

The paperwork is being processed, just sage 1 of the process lol.

1
Still-rhino•

You are correct.

1