Friend of mine heard a loud bang after changing a head gasket

Posted Aug 17, 2021, 10:05 AM UTC

Posted Aug 17, 2021, 10:05 AM UTC
That my 10mm socket I been looking for? Lol
Have my upvote, made me chuckle already
When I was a kid we just put pennies on the railroad tracks for fun, but whatever floats your boat I guess.
I did this! I still think it's more fun than Instagram.
A prostate exam by Michael J. Fox is more fun then Instagram.
That sounds more fun than ... just about anything really
Haha well said!
Ok then. Off to pornhub I go.
Huh I'm willing to bet money that's a 1.9 Alh TDI motor. If camshaft timing is even slightly off they will run for a bit, pounding valves just slightly, and eventually one will drop onto the piston like you see here, potentially destroying the whole motor.
When the timing belt is removed on these, the camshaft and injection pump sprockets must be loosened and cam +injection pump hub must be locked at TDC with special tools. Then when belt is installed, with block at TDC, it goes on a certain direction taking all of the slack off over the loose pulleys, and then installing belt on tensioner. Its a very tedious process and those who attempt it without proper knowledge/tools are almost always bound to fail.
Thanks for taking the time to post that. It may save someone a motor.
No problem. It is the only correct way to do it. Some people mark all the pullies and belt with paint and do a "mark and pray" job, where they count the teeth between marks, mark the new belt and attempt install. But this will fail almost everytime, even if it takes a couple thousand km. The tensioner can not be set right with this method and over time it will beat itself to death eventually snapping off the setting tab of tensioner. After that, the belt skips time and you have a timing failure.
I'm actually dealing with one of these tdi's right now. Previous owner said timing kit had been done 2k km before i bought it, checked and the belt was new. I saw paint marks so I planned to replace it very soon just to be sure. Within 4k km the tensioner failed and I was left stranded, valves hit pistons and full head rebuild was needed. Also had to do a clutch in that time ffs
Out of curiosity, if marks won't do.. What is the proper way to time the belt?
Thanks for taking the time to write this up. You're totally correct in all of this, but in this specific case - according to my friend - everything was done using the proper sync tools to the millimeter and checked again... Also if the timing was off, there would have multiple marks, but there was just the one. So the valve broke somehow, this is down to terrible luck. Fascinating however, I'm no mechanic, so I'm learning a lot.
Valve keepers might get came off and dropped the valve.
but where is the turbo?
Its part of the exhaust manifold in first pic, all one piece. Its underneath out of sight
That just looks SO expensive.
I feel like at that point, it's better to just buy a new engine
Bingo
Hey, I think somethings touching.
Oh, wow, the valve broke off.
How? Interference engine setup wrong?
Circle goes in the circle hole right?
Holy shit. That engine is proper fucked. That's the worst case scenario there... Nothing at all is reusable. I've seen people get away with just new valves and valve seats before after that happens, I've seen them just need those plus a piston... That one broke both the block itself and the head.
Looks like some bad luck there hey?
Is the official diagnosis: "Shit's fucked"...?
"-Customer reports a slight knocking sound"
Oh that thing was big mad!
Ooooh, motor mushroom cap. I still waiting for mine to grow
My kids used to love those penny press machines. Had no idea we could make them at home.
we would put quarters on the rail tracks and let the train squish it
Big spender eh?
forbidden communion wafer
valve of christ .. oil is his blood
What the fuck did he do to the snap a valve off after doing a headgasket?
Fucked the timing, most likely. It's why you always, always hand crank the engine to make sure there is no interference after doing a job like this.
You double, triple, and quadruple check everything.
If you hand crank the engine and receive solid resistance, you're still in the game. You can go back and fix the problem. If you let the starter check the timing for you, and its wrong, you're most likely fucked.
The exception would be a non interference engine. You still would most likely be ok if you tried to start it when the timing is off. But that being said, you still don't risk it.
seeing this makes me so happy i dont have timing chains or belts
The system works as long as you follow the maintenance schedule. Regular oil changes are imperative to the life of the timing chain. Of course, there are some inherent engineering issues that can pop up. Manufacturers using cheap parts such as bad chain guides and such. And even cheap chains that can stretch. However, you typically receive a CEL once the timing starts to go wonky in order to alert you of a problem. With the hopes of allowing you to catch the issue before the engine grenades itself.
Belts usually need to be changed out around 100,000 miles. Most shops can do a job like this fairly easily.
The systems work pretty well as long as they are maintained. And if you decide to DIY, you better study every sing thing about the job. Some cars like first and second gen Mazda 3's as well as Ford Focus's for example, do not use keyed timing. But rather a washer that holds tension between the balancer and crank. They are notoriously difficult to time correctly. So you have to know your shit.
I enjoy that mine is a non-interference and it's all gearing
I find those type of engines to be EASIER to time correctly. You install the tools to keep them in time, and it's basically impossible to screw it up. And in the case of the Ford/Mazda engine you're talking about, you can get a set of timing tools from Amazon that are perfectly adequate for a DIYer that's only going to use them a couple times for like $20. It's literally a flat metal bar that goes into slots in the back of the cams, and a screw with a pin on it that screws into a hole in the side of the block and passes through a corresponding hole in the crank when it's at TDC. Then, you put a bolt in the balancer that goes into a slot on the front of the engine to line that up, tighten everything hand tight, back the bolts for the crank and cam gears off 1/4-1/2 turn, release the tensioner, tighten the bolts to spec, and everything will be perfectly lined up. No contorting yourself to see timing marks, no concerns about a machined head or manufacturing tolerances in the chains altering the timing. In fact, that's why they do this in the first place- it makes it possible to always perfectly time the engine, which is better for making sure variable valve timing systems work right.
Why would you even mess with the timing on a HG job? Only reason I can imagine is overhead cams. Enlighten me please?
Because of that precise reason. Many modern cars are overhead cam. So in a lot of situations, you have to remove the timing belt or chain in order to remove the head for the HG replacement.
Thanks!
You gotta remove the timing chain/belt to remove the head from the block. When it all goes back together, you have to retime the engine.
Laughs in non-interference engine
My 5VZ agrees.....But even if I were to do a timing job on my 4Runner, I'd still check every single thing before letting the starter turn the engine over.
Timed it wrong?
if he had the head decked and didn't put a thicker head gasket on
[removed]
[removed]
This is why we double check cam timing kiddos
They did check timing, unfortunately by using the starter motor.
Self Clearancing
Did he leave something in that cylinder? Like a brick?
Shave and a haircut
2 bits
Is that the new free - flow design?
It's sort of like the Koenigsegg engines. Those are freevalve, but this one is valvefree.
[deleted]
Token for the crane game?
Haha. Yeah, an engine hoist.
Hey boss, I think we need to buy a new engine.
[deleted]
Bad bot
Thank you, Nickmell, for voting on Shakespeare-Bot.
This bot wants to find the best and worst bots on Reddit. You can view results here.
^(Even if I don't reply to your comment, I'm still listening for votes. Check the webpage to see if your vote registered!)
Messed up the timing?
Now equipped with a high flow valve...
Spit that token right the fuq out
Nice spare parts include ♥️
On the upside he can go and open his own hotel
Ouch that’s going to hurt the pocket book
That is the mythical block mushroom, when you find it, you have a new block (and head) in your near future!
Beat me to the shroom joke. Take my upvote!
Boof it
[deleted]
Motor tek?