Trying to get back in by running 6th, what should I know before I begin?

6e

6th seems alright to me, although it seems hated online. What am I missing? Should I just abandon it and go back to 5th?

Posted Aug 17, 2021, 2:05 PM UTC

2146
StimulusResponse•

6e is great if you want to run that Anarchy style where everything is fast and you just stack modifiers. However, it cuts away all the fun crunch that Shadowrun has been about. If you and your players don't like gear, etc. and are just about fast-paced story, you can make it work.

However, if you have ran any other edition, 6e disappoints. If you like spells, gear, etc. to have actual meaning, then stick with complete 5e. I've been running published 6e missions using 5e, so I've only stuck to the new story stuff. Kind of nice to know I've got all the rules I need while still absorbing some content.

11
JoshThePosh13•

Question. If you want that, isn’t it better to just play Anarchy and ignore the rules for swapping DM? I found that 6e has just as much crunch, isn’t just very very badly balanced.

I found between 6e and 5e the only real thing done to simplify is less skills. It may be faster paced if you already know the rules from earlier editions, but the amount of times you’ll be totally unable to find something in the rule book will be high.

7
MercilessMing_Double Trouble•

Question. If you want that, isn’t it better to just play Anarchy and ignore the rules for swapping DM? I found that 6e has just as much crunch, isn’t just very very badly balanced.

Anarchy is a light rule set. I wouldn't call it a narrative rule set even though it was marketed like one, but it's a light rule set. Some people are looking for a game with depth, room for mastery, but find Shadowrun to be too complex. That's what I'm looking for, that's what I had hoped we'd get with 6e, but they only got about halfway there imo. Anyway the point is that plenty of people feel Anarchy is too light as well as 5e being too heavy.

3
StimulusResponse•

I accept your experience. I haven't played 6e after the first run at Gencon when it was released, so my impressions are largely from there. Actually playing Anarchy is a step farther, but I personally really felt the design drift towards that ideology in my experience with 6. It may actually not synch well with people who love the anarchy ruleset. YMMV.

2
MercilessMing_Double Trouble•

Oh boy more edition war. This sub hates 6th.

If you have a library of 5th ed stuff already, may as well stick to it. However, here are some things to know about getting into 6th edition, this coming from a person that's both played it and GM'd it for the last 18 mos:

6th edition is like 5th with a haircut. It hasn't been radically changed and if you're familiar with 5th you'll learn it very easily. Mechanically, a lot of bookkeeping has been reduced, but a little has been added in other ways.

In classic Catalyst fashion, the rulebook is not well written or laid out.

Edge is the biggest change. It's now a meta currency system you earn and spend. Unless you're a combat monster, it's probably less powerful than it was in previous editions.

6th relies more on GM fiat than 5th.

Combat scenes move faster. The multiple initiative pass system is gone, replaced by fast people getting more actions.

People on this sub misunderstand or misrepresent 6th often, like claiming invisibility barely does anything, snipers in a blizzard shoot at no penalty, or getting spotted while driving makes your car explode.

Don't get the hardcopy version of the core rulebook right now. Two significant errata docs have come out for it since it was published, and a third is expected around Gencon time (September 2021). A second printing has been announced, which they "hope" to have ready at Gencon as well, and we're expecting it to have all three errata included. Either get the PDF which has errata included already, or wait for the second printing.

11
DarkSithMstr•

agreed, I ran several 6e sessions, it is solid, although I had to consult Shadowrun forums and internet to make clear some rules. I found it enjoyable, with definite logic flaws(hate armor is mainly for defense rating). I found the crunch annoying, just too much and not everything added together right with missing pieces in book. I love the lore and the universe, but I settled into Cyberpunk instead. Here is hoping 7th edition is more cohesive.

3
Altar_Quest_Fan•

A second printing has been announced

Do you have a link or something for this? I'm genuinely curious. I checked Catalyst's website but didn't see anything about it.

1
MercilessMing_Double Trouble•

The only place it's been announced afaik is in the recent interview Hardy did, it's the "Seattle Edition" he talked about. It's on YouTube on the All Ones channel and was featured on this sub a couple weeks ago.

3
Altar_Quest_Fan•

Oh okay cool. Kinda miffed because I bit the bullet and bought a hard copy of 6E roughly 7-8 weeks ago and now they’re coming out w/ a new one lol 😂 Guess that’s what I get :P

1
tekmogod•

Jason Hardy announced on Facebook that they are bring a special Seattle Edition to Gencon and that errata will be included.

2
Altar_Quest_Fan•

:POG: lol nice

-1
adzling6th World Nostradamus •

This sub hates 6th. most of the shadowrun community hates 6th.

​

6th relies more on GM fiat than 5th the rules in 6th don't work/ are poorly defined so the gm has to make more stuff up on the fly (i.e. the rules don't do their core job of defining game play effectively).

fixed that for you

-4†
Ixaro•

Shadowrun community on this sub hates 6th, not most of the community. Unless you know all the SR players and GM, you can't say that...

5th was trashed all day long when it came out, this 6th hate is typical internet behavior.

5†
Sceptically•

5th was trashed all day long when it came out

For good reason. It's not exactly great, mechanically speaking. And the book layout is terrible, too.

But 6e just sounds like a move from bad to worse.

3
Ixaro•

I know that, but back in the days, people were just saying : Play 4th, 5th sucks. Now it's : Play 5th, 6th sucks.

That's why I say it's a typical internet bullshit. Most of the people trashing it didn't even really tried the new edition. It was the same for the 5th, now people mostly say to play 5th when a new GM/player wants to try SR...

I love 5th, GMed more than 1000h on it, now I'm on 6th and I won't come back to 5th unless someone asks me to with a nice project. All I'd like, it's that people try to play 6th with erratas with an open mind, not asking it to be a 5.1th. And if you still don't like it, that's fine!

2
adzling6th World Nostradamus •

nope, i don't need to know all the srun players in the world, that's clearly nuts.

Most of the community on the official shadowrun forums left because of 5e.

Between the official forums and this sub you have the majority of dedicated shadowrun players.

also my stop at gencon during the release of 6e mirrored this assessment.

also sale of 6e are pretty terrible.

this is NOT an edition war, srun needed a new revised edition that improved on 5e's shortcomings. 6e ain't that, it's an horrific edition with horrific underlying mechanics that were no where near sufficiently playtested.

it's not anywhere near close to typical behaviour.

2†
Ixaro•

If you say so. Here in France, 6th and Anarchy are selling way more than 5th ever did. German 6th is selling really well too.
Official forums and this sub are mostly for american folks or for people playing the CGL version of the game, french and german players have their own sub and forums to talk about THEIR 6th.

7
Boltgun•

6th seems alright to me

And that's all you need to mind about. Don't switch because we told you it's bad.

9
hoodwinkler75•

It’s whatever works best for the gm and the group. My crew like 4th edition best.

9
Altar_Quest_Fan•

what should I know before I begin?

Hoo boy, there's quite a few things to cover in just that question alone. In a word, I would say that no, you shouldn't just abandon SR6, at least not without giving it the old "college try". Yes SR6 has its issues, but the game can be loads of fun IF you're willing to put in the effort to incorporate the official errata plus use your noggin as the GM. First things first, you're gonna want to read both the SR6 core rulebook + official errata. Sounds like a no-brainer, but there are quite a few things that are different from SR5. Once you've got a good feel for how SR6 works, you'll just have to fill the rest in with experience (as in actually running the game). There's a bit more to contend with, however, which I'll outline below.

Book layout & editing

This right here is a big issue. See, when Catalyst made SR6, they decided to just copy pasta SR5 for huge swathes of the book. Some sections of the book read word-for-word to their equivalent sections in the SR5 core book. Not only was this just downright lazy, but because of all the heavy copy pasta'ing and limited proofreading, there's places in the book that actually make zero damn sense. Take for example medkits; they have a rating of 1-6 but when you read the description in the 6E book there's no talk of how the ratings actually work. When you read up on medkits in the SR5 book though, you'll not only get an explanation of how medkit ratings work, but you'll see that they just lazily copied the description word-for-word in 6E and called it a day. This isn't the only time you'll see stuff like that either, there's plenty of other places in the book where they talk about things that just aren't referenced elsewhere or else are poorly described. Catalyst rushed 6E's development in order to have a product for Gencon 2019 and it really shows.

Nu-Edge

We call it "nu" because SR6 radically changes how Edge works. In the previous two editions, Edge was a very limited resource that had big effects when you used it. In SR6, Edge is actually a meta-currency that you constantly gain & spend, and in theory is meant to reward players for doing heroic things or punish them for taking foolhardy risks. In practice...Nu-Edge is very inconsistent at best and at worst tends to break immersion. For example, if you shot a weak corpsec guard earlier and got a point of Edge, you can use it later to help you negotiate a better payout from Mr. Johnson at the end of the run. That's...just weird for some people. Also, in my table's experience, there are plenty of times when entire fights pass and nobody gains any Edge because of how the AR vs DR mechanics work (if an enemy's AR is 4 or more points greater than the defender's DR then the attacker gets a point of Edge and vice versa, however if neither side has that 4-point gap in either AR or DR then nobody gets an Edge). Now, this issue can be overcome, however it's going to require an imaginative GM that's willing to make liberal use of GM fiat. For example, let's say that Sammy the Street Sam is engaged in a fistfight w/ an ork that he managed to piss off at a bar. And let's further say that both sides have AR & DR that's within 3 points of each other, so nobody really gets any Edge. Suddenly, the ork decides to play dirty and unsheathes some cyberspurs in an effort to cut Sammy the Street Sam down to size. The GM could choose to award the ork w/ a point of Edge on each attack because Sammy is using only his fists and everyone knows that blades > fists. However, if Sammy decides to draw his trusty katana to even the odds, the GM could award Sammy w/ Edge on every attack and the ork with none because the katana has a greater reach & cuts deeper than cyberspurs would. You'll need to be prepared to give your players plenty of other ways to gain Edge using GM fiat beyond the standard "AR vs DR" because if you rely exclusively on that then you'll find that Nu-Edge just wobbles and doesn't really stand on its own two legs.

Combat

Combat in SR6 is actually smoother and flows quite nicely, even with the Nu-Edge mechanics. Something to keep in mind is that SR6 has two different ways to simulate attempting an action in suboptimal conditions: Edge and Statuses. You normally award a point of Edge to a character that's got a clear advantage in a given situation, such as having nightvision in a pitch black room while the enemy does not, or having the right equipment for the task at hand (i.e. having climbing gear and you're attempting to climb an icy rock formation). The reverse is true however, so withholding Edge for being at a disadvantage or being unprepared is one way the game tries to show players that they're doing something wrong. Then there's Statuses. This represents stuff like being caught on fire (Burning), being sprayed with caustic chemicals (Corroded), or even being knocked off your feet by a skilled martial artist (Prone). The game expects you the GM to apply these status effects to players & NPCs alike as applicable, because with the statuses comes actual mechanical modifiers. For example, let's say the team is battling outside in the middle of a heavy blizzard with high winds and punishing cold. As the GM you should be giving everyone the blinded 1 or even blinded 2 status (depending on just how severe the blizzard is), unless a player has some way to mitigate the piss poor conditions (such as having thermal vision or something). Also, nobody should be gaining any Edge either unless they possess specialized arctic gear and smartlinks in their guns to compensate for the blizzard. As long as you remember to use Statuses and give/withhold Edge to help simulate environmental conditions, you'll find that SR6 actually works brilliantly. One other thing worth mentioning is the fact that Armor no longer directly reduces damage, instead it's used to help calculate who gets Edge. I personally think that RAW is fine because players can wear armor that actually fits their character concept instead of worrying about if they'll get one-shot by an enemy because they didn't bring heavy armor. If you & your group absolutely HATE that idea and think body armor should help with damage reduction, you can use the following house rule: body armor reduces damage based on the armor's Defense Rating per the following guidelines.

  • DR 1-3: no damage reduction
  • DR 4-6: reduce incoming damage by 1P
  • DR 7+: reduce incoming damage by 2P

When you determine how much damage reduction a set of armor provides, only look at just the armor's base DR and ignore any cumulative bonuses to DR that come from wearing helmets, riot shields, etc. Naturally, when you determine Edge in combat the player gets to add the DR from their armor + helmet + riot shield (if applicable) as normal.

Also, do be aware that in the Firing Squad supplement there are armor mods that provide damage reduction (ex. Tough Weave). You should NOT allow these to stack, because otherwise players will end up being able to tank everything short of grenades/rockets. Either ban those armor mods completely or only allow the HIGHER rating to apply.

continued below...

7
Altar_Quest_Fan•

Matrix

I personally felt they did a good job on the Matrix in 6E, they scaled down a lot of the complexity and made things move much faster. The unfortunate side is that some concepts aren't clearly explained and it might take you a few attempts before you really "grok" it. Also, I'm a bit salty over the fact that they nerfed the hell out of commlinks to the point where even a midrange commlink is incredibly vulnerable to getting hacked. The person that wrote the entire Matrix chapter actually proposed some changes and wrote up this document in order to help clarify how some things work, which I HIGHLY recommend you read as well. It also gives some updated stats for commlinks too, which I've been using at my table and can confirm work wonderfully.

Rigging

For the most part, rigging is pretty straight forward, and overall I feel it does an adequate job. Not an amazing job, not a great job, merely adequate. There are some oddities though, for example if your vehicle is moving too fast you start taking dice pool penalties on attempts to control the craft/vehicle. Now, you only need to make such rolls while doing something dangerous/tricky, so Bob the Wageslave will certainly be just fine during his daily commute to Evil'R'Us Inc. (unless the players somehow make his commute dangerous, in which case poor Bob will likely fail his piloting rolls and die a painful death). While that sounds like it emulates real life, the fact of the matter is that sometimes the penalties can get quite high. Every vehicle has a Speed Interval, which determines how big a dice penalty you take on your piloting rolls for each full "interval" that you're going. For example, the GMC Bulldog (which has been a rigger favorite since SR 1E) has a top speed of 140 and a speed interval of 10. This means that a rigger driving at the top speed of 140 (roughly 105 MPH or 168 KPH) will suffer a -14 dice penalty (140/10 = 14) to all their piloting rolls!! Now, for the most part there's zero reason to drive that recklessly fast, however during a high speed chase scene the rigger is going to have their dice pool practically neutered before they even get to roll. Worse, the threshold for driving tests is equal to the vehicle's Handling stat, which ranges from 3 to as high as 7. In order to maintain control of a vehicle, the operator MUST score that many hits on their Handling test. So in the previous example, if Riggy McRiggerson normally has 18 dice and decides to floor it in their GMC Bulldog, they're only going to have 4 dice (18 - 14 = 4) against a threshold of 4 (Bulldog's handling = 4 in urban areas/on the road). That player had better seriously consider spending Edge (or even permanently burning a point of Edge for a guaranteed success) if they don't want to get into an accident and suffer massive amounts of crash damage. Your best bet here is to reduce the Handling stat on all vehicles by 1 or 2 points or only give 1/2 the normal dice penalty (i.e. Riggy McRiggerson flooring it in his GMC Bulldog would only take a -7 penalty rather than a -14 penalty). One other thing to keep in mind is that as long as a vehicle has a Sensor rating of at least 1, it's capable of autopilot. I checked and can confirm that the only vehicle in the core book that has a Sensor rating of 0 is the Dodge Scooter, so don't even think about attempting autopilot unless you literally want Jesus to take the wheel lol.

Magic

For the most part, magic has been streamlined quite nicely, at least when it comes to spellcasting. No more Force ratings for spells, you instead just choose a spell to cast, decide if you're going to amp up the spell (i.e. increase damage, area of effect, etc), make the sorcery test, and finally resist drain. Summoned spirits do have a rather nasty buff; when they materialize on the physical plane they gain Immunity to Normal Weapons, which in a nutshell makes them damn near invulnerable to any non-magical attack that doesn't deal more damage than their Force rating. People scream about how OP summoned spirits can be, however I don't think it's an issue. Nobody cares when a decker is able to brick an enemy's gun or spank a Matrix spider so hard for having the audacity to actually do their job and oppose cyber intruders, so why shouldn't it be the mage's job to deal w/ magical threats? Summoned elemental spirits are weak to non-magical attacks that oppose their nature (i.e. spraying a fire spirit w/ a water hose), not to mention they can be dismissed by any mage worth their salt, or they can also be pummeled with spells. Oh, did I mention that spirits are also susceptible to being punched in the face by a physical adept? So yeah, gun bunnies & street sammies might cry because their tricked out guns will do f*ck all in the face of even a "lowly" Force 3 or Force 4 spirit, however a mage or physical adept will be able to deal with the threat themselves. Which is EXACTLY why every team needs a runner able to sling mojo or at least banish pesky enemy spirits.

Other Tips/Thoughts

I've been working on this post for hours so I'm trying to wrap things up lol. I did write up a nice post the other week here that talks about some of my tips & tricks for Shadowrun GMs, which I would also recommend you check out as well. Once again I want to emphasize that SR 6E isn't a horrible edition at all, in fact I've been running a campaign since January and we've all enjoyed ourselves immensely. There's some rough edges for sure, but if you can work around them you'll find SR6 can be enjoyable and loads of fun. Cheers chummer!

6
Lord_Smogg•

Just a note. In SR6 you can use medkit rating instead of biotech skill

2
Altar_Quest_Fan•

Really? I didn't see that in the last couple rounds of errata. Did I miss it, or is it somewhere else? That's cool though, I like the idea.

1
Lord_Smogg•

Page 120 in the updated pdf. (from the Feb 2020 Errata) :)

1
Altar_Quest_Fan•

So the PDF copy I have must not have been updated because the medkit description on pg. 120 doesn't talk about medkit ratings at all. I also looked at my copy of the Feb 2020 errata and it says:

Alter the paragraph to read as follows:
Make a Biotech + Logic test or medkit rating + Logic test against a threshold of 5 – target’s Essence. If the target is one-hundred-percent natural, the healer actually gets an automatic hit added to their roll. Again, Like First Aid, this fixes biological material, not machinery.

There's nothing in there about medkit ratings. What am I missing?

1
Burritomage1•

Well the book layout is terrible, like really terrible. If you check the pinned messages on the sub you will find a 6th ed section with links to faqs and errata.

6
ReditXenonFar Cite•

what?

The book layout is far better than SR5 where rules are scattered all over the place

For example Glare from a Flash Pak.

In SR5 you would probably read environmental Glare rules from p. 173-176 (including complicated category stacking) to find out if it give you a negative dice pool modifier of 1, 3 6 or 10 dice and where flare compensation reduce the category by 1 rank. Just to discover that Glare from Flash Pak uses its own rules found on p. 435 where it give a negative dice pool modifier of -4 dice or -2 dice if you have flare compensation or even just -1 if flare compensation is an augmentation.

In SR6 almost all situational modifiers (that used to be scattered all over the book) are converted into status effects and all status effects can be found in one place in the book. While using a fash pak the target get Blinded I, II or III depending on how close to the source they are. Low light increase the rank by 1. Flare compensation reduce the rank by 1. Smooth.

Having said that, it still also inherit some of the bad layout we had in SR5. Materialization -> Immunity To Normal Weapons -> Hardened Armor is a great example of bad layout that the book suffer from previous editions.

 

What is bad when it comes to the editing of SR6 is that it have spelling mistakes and many of the clarifying examples and clarifying [but perhaps redundant] rules we had in SR5 are missing (which make several rules ambiguous and hard to understand unless you know the intent from previous editions or forum posts by the author).

Not so much the layout though.

4†
JoshThePosh13•

Slight disagree.

I’d say 6e is a lot less readable than 5e from a format perspective because it lacks the clear sub-headers 5e had. (Probably to save space)

I also found that 6e page references always led to the heading, even if the actual rules content is on another page.

Also 6e is missing a lot of rules, which I don’t know if that goes under a layout problem… but creates similar feelings of frustration.

7
Lord_Smogg•

6e is a great edition. I switched from 5e to 6e at launch and have GMed it since. There is no way we would go back to 5e. There is a few things to unlearn when coming from 5e, and it takes a couple of sessions.

The Edge system moves focus from crunch to story and helps resolve scenes and combat in a more modern way where you can build up some momentum.

The Initiative system is a lot easier to keep track of.

Mages now have rules for designing spells.

The pdf rulebook is updated with all errata, and a new seattle edition is about to be released also updated.

It is clear that Catalyst is commited to supporting 6e with missions, campaigns fiction and expansions so dont miss out where it happens :)

For the record, I don't recognize all the negative comments about 6e at all. Playing 6e is a very different experience than reading all the dont-play-6e-posts.

6
JoshThePosh13•

I didn’t feel like the edge system helped all that much.

In SR5 you had to worry about two types of modifiers, dice pool bonuses/penalties that affected you, and bonuses/penalties that affected your opponent.

In SR6 you have to worry about 3 types of modifiers. Edge modifiers, situational edge modifiers, and the existing bonuses/penalties.

Also with edge gain being capped so low, I’m not sure what you mean by momentum?

9
Lord_Smogg•

Heh, I got downvoted on my first reply, so I gather I have not answered everything. So with regards to your first point on types of modifiers...

​

It comes down to how it plays out at the table and less about counting how many "types" of modifiers the system uses depending on how you choose to define your types and what you choose to include in your comparison. (like ignoring limits and inventing edge modifiers?)

​

At the table I find it more smooth to deal with 0-2 edge awards and a set of conditions than advanced rules and tables for dice pool and threshold modifiers and limits which many players often forget. Of course that will be a personal preference.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Lord_Smogg•

My point of momentum is this: Because one side tend to build up edge because of equipment and/or situation, it opens for more powerful edge actions to come into play. This pushes the combat towards a turn or climatic conclusion rather than a slow fade-out. I consider that a more modern and fun mechanic.

4 edge per 2 rounds - That pretty much correspond to spending 1 edge every second round in 5e. Is that low?

1†
MercilessMing_Double Trouble•

Playing 6e is a very different experience than reading all the dont-play-6e-posts.

Very very true.

4
ReditXenonFar Cite•

SR6 fixes many things that didn't really work well in SR5 (such as Initiative Score bookkeeping, Matrix, Progressive Recoil, 30+ Soak pools, 10+ different repair and piloting skills, Limits, etc...)

Combat in Shadowrun always had a level of abstraction (for example bullet proof vest still applies even if the attacker call a shot to the head) in order to speed up combat (at the expanse of 'realism'). SR6 take this a step further by merging many [perhaps less important but quite time consuming] rules such as Recoil rules, Recoil Compensation rules, Progressive Recoil rules, Armor Penetration rules, Adjusted Armor Rating rules, etc into a single Attack Rating that you just compare with the targets Defense Rating which then ties into the new Edge mechanic - which together with really good changes to the initiative system speed up combat quite a lot (but at the expanse of even more 'realism'). Many veteran players don't like this and will tell you that the edition is a burning train wreck because of this (but for a new player I think this is probably a Good Thing).

Editing in SR5 sucked (rules scattered all over the place, situational modifiers scattered all over the place) and some of this was actually fixed in SR6 (status effects replace most situational modifiers and are all found at one single location), but the edition introduced new editing mistakes. There are some simple typos but what is worse is that in an effort to reduce word count they also cut many clarifying examples and clarifying (but perhaps redundant) rules. Making many rules ambiguous and harder to understand, not easier. If you played earlier editions then the intent is often already known and this is less of an issue, but it kinda sucks for a new player. If it wasn't for this then I would say that this edition would hands down be the best edition for a new player to get engaged with. Earlier editions of Shadowrun (and also the revisited 20th anniversary version of the 4th edition) had far higher editing quality than both the two last editions together.

A quick rundown of some of the most significant changes (according to the book itself);

• Expanded Edge. Gaining and spending Edge happen more frequently than in previous editions, and some other functions have been rolled into Edge. Knowing how to gain and spend Edge is an important part of your tactics as a runner.

• Simplified weapons stats. Armor penetration and recoil compensation were combined into a more abstract stat called Attack Rating that is used to help players gain Edge.

• Simplified skills. It’s not a perfect correlation, but the current skills list is essentially the same A skill groups of previous editions.

• Armor is not rolled as part of the Damage Resistance test. Armor boosts your Defense Rating, which can help you gain Edge or prevent your opponent from gaining Edge, but it is not used in the Damage Resistance roll. Only Body is used for that roll.

• Eliminated limits. Limits were a balancing stat for a more complicated system, but with somewhat fewer moving parts in this system (combined with more of an emphasis on speed) they did not have as strong a role to play, and so were removed.

• Simplified action structure. There are two levels of actions, Minor and Major, and together with a simpler Initiative system, they focus on keeping combat moving while flattening the difference somewhat between fast characters and others.

• Spells don’t use Force. The power and effect of spells can still be amplified, but they don’t have to be, so you can just use spells as a basic package if you want, without having to declare Force.

• Changed functions of Matrix attributes. Since there are no more limits, the functions of Matrix attributes are changed. They help determine Attack Ratings and Defense Ratings in the Matrix, and they also help determine the approach you’ll take to hacking.

6
plassteel01•

honestly i have no idea about the edition war. 6th ed is the one i started with. so far so good

6
Atherakhia1988Corpse Disposal•

Should I just abandon it and go back to 5th?

TL;DR: Yes.

Long Version: 6th Edition is a mess, mechanically speaking. Yes, there might be groups enjoying it, as you can enjoy any game with a good GM. RAW thoug, 6E is a complete mess. Why? They wanted to go for a single gimmick (Edge replacing Modifiers) and ran with it - but it doesn't work.
It makes some things absolutely pointless (Invisibility, for example, makes you barely harder to hit. As in, imagine a -1 modifier in 5th).
Balancing is completely out of the window (a pistol doin 2-3 damage, an unarmed Troll doing 10).
Mages did not get the Memo about there being no modifiers to dice pools anymore, so they can easily get like 6 or 8 dice more than anybody else. Spirits didn't get the memo either, so anything you can summon right out of chargen is immune to any mundane attack (except for big, unarmed trolls of course) while doing about as much damage as an Assault Cannon.
All target numbers for vehicle tests are so absurd, drones cannot succeed on any tests unless you are jumped in. Joe Wageslave would die on his commute to work.
The core rule book alone has so many errate that it took the German publisher a few additional weeks to squeeze them into the print version.
Playing humans is entirely pointless. They have one more point max Edge, which is cool, but since Trolls could also raise all their mental attributes to 6 but can super easy compensate for that by being able to raise their Body sky-high makes humans truly useless.
The only real way to get more than one point of Edge (which, remember, you need all the time!) is combat. So, before a hard negotiation or first aid check, better beat up a homeless guy for that sweet sweet Edge.
I got... so many more problems with the system but those are a bit of a starter. It is the worst game that I ever touched that had been published on such a level. I played it, RAW, with my group as a meme. We had a good laugh but that's about it. Sure, you can houserule everything, but if you got to houserule half the book, that thing is nothing but a literal paper-weight.

If you got any chance to do so, stick with 5th or 4th.

5†
Ouroboron•

Joe Wageslave would die on his commute to work.

Well, that's why you just live in the arcology, chummer. No commute to die on.

5
taranion•

Hm, I would say that is totally up to you. I've played 4h, 5th and 6th editions and I enjoyed all of them.
The 6th suffers the similar problems the 5th did. The new edge mechanic is hard-wired into the 6th edition, changes balancing (damage codes, meaning of armor) and requires you to unlearn some rules - but during play I liked it a lot. Aside from existing editing problems in the CRB, there are some balancing problems with new new rules and I hope that the coming 2nd printing will improve this situation.

So, I guess it is: stay with 5e for now, if you are satisfied with it - but give 6e a try if you a open for new ideas (and can wait for the 2nd printing)

4
adzling6th World Nostradamus •

in a word, yes.

it's hated online because that's where the people who know about this stuff gather to kibitz about it.

any earlier edition is far superior, i prefer 5e.

gluck!

3†
BitRunrDesigner Drugs•

what should I know before I begin?

There are many good reasons to not 'go back' to previous editions.

There are many good reasons to not purchase 6th edition.

There are many good reasons to look up homebrew projects that adapt other systems (ie; blades in the dark) to the sixth world setting. If you're not here for the gear porn of earlier editions, that would be my recommendation.

2

Run 5th instead.

1†
GM_Pax•

You should know that 6E is a hot mess, and you'll need to do quit a bit of work to make it coherent.

1