r/u_functor7•
functor7

On Scientific Knowledge

The climate crisis and the pandemic are times where we really need to be listening to what the experts say. But a problem with this is that, for the right price, you can find an expert that is willing to say anything that you want. The tobacco industry learned this, the fossil fuel industry took notes and expanded on this idea, and now it's not hard to find a doctor willing to take whatever stance on the pandemic that you like. If we can just find an expert to say whatever we like then this typically leads to one of two conclusions 1.) We just need to shop around for the right expert to listen to or 2.) The experts all seem to disagree so I can just come to whatever conclusion I like. Regardless, the outcome is that the directive to "listen to the experts" is meaningless.

So how do we let science inform our decision making when we can find a scientist to claim that science says whatever we want it to? How can we say that some experts are wrong and others are not wrong?

We could go by consensus, or the majority of what scientists say. But this actually doesn't help. It merely presents the dissenting scientists as another "side" do a debate. After all, there have been times in the past where the majority of the scientific community was incorrect and the dissenters were correct^(1) and so this could just be another one of those times. The problem is how we construct scientific knowledge. We are viewing science as equal to the collection of individual scientists within it. In this case, even if a majority of scientists agree, any stance is merely just the conclusion of individuals and any individual is as validated in holding a dissenting view as any within the consensus view. Scientific knowledge needs to be more robust than the conclusions of individuals.

Of course, most would say that people are either right or wrong about science, but we come to conclusions about science based off of arguments which are grounded in experiment and evidence and so if an expert comes to an opposite conclusion then there's no way we can determine who is right and who is wrong. Both are equally valid - especially to laypeople who can't make sense of an argument made by experts which would actually convincingly debunk ideas of a dissenting expert. So we are talking about knowledge not as something we can know to be true or false, but as something held by entities that has political impact.

Scientific knowledge, then, needs to be different than just what individual scientists conclude and be grounded in more than a kind of "Democracy of Experts". We need a robust way to say that a scientific claim is false.

The first thing that we should do is understand that science is much more than the collection of individual scientists who make it up. It is its own entity composed of scientists, machines, tools, papers, websites, conferences, relationships, abstracts, rules, standards, etc. We might call science a Hyperobject. As an entity it has the capability of "knowing" things in and of itself - knowledge exists in the organizational structure and relationships of its constituents. There are standards and procedure for the production of knowledge within science. For instance, the scientific paper must clearly describe the experiment, the equipment, its implementation, and the results as a kind of testimony that it, indeed, did happen as claimed^(2). New knowledge is produced through a complex web of machines, debates, and papers which combine to make more papers^(3). The knowledge is, then, not contained within the minds of individual scientist but in the relations within science.

As an example, a single scientific paper means nothing and has little-to-no scientific knowledge. The paper exists within a conversation between many other papers and in reaction to them, and it helps produce more discussion, questions, and papers. That is, the knowledge about which a scientific paper talks about is contained within the context in which it exists. You can't know why an experiment was done and why a paper was made if you do not know what preceded it, what was contemporary with it, and you can't know the conclusions to be drawn from it without knowing what came after it.

This seems daunting. And it is. Scientific knowledge is complex, robust, intricate, and not knowable to any individual. This is why a dissenting scientist is to be mistrusted. But this is also where we can understand the importance of scientific experts. They may not know everything that science knows, even within their field, but they are, in a way, native to the scientific landscape. They can navigate the people, papers, experiments, and their relationships with expertise. An individual's scientific knowledge is not a list of facts, but a knowledge of the scientific landscape. They can help contextualize an idea and they can illuminate the web of relationships needed to draw on scientific knowledge. In this way when an expert talks about science they are always talking about an already-existing knowledge held by science itself and are providing an interpretation of it. This then means that they are either right or wrong about what they claim science says.

How do we then know when to trust a claim about what science says? Are we not right back where we began with ourselves unable to determine who is right and who is wrong?

I think that we're in a new place with new tools. Take, for instance, the IPCC. It is not the opinion of any individual and it is not constructed through scientific democracy. Instead, it is a systematic analysis of the scientific landscape pertaining to climate change. It's a guidebook to navigating the web of papers, experiments, and so-forth. The conclusions are arrived at through institutional means of debate, peer review, edits, notes, etc, rather than just simple majority vote. The IPCC Assessment Reports are, themselves, major landmarks on the landscape of science which help guide navigation. The knowledge contained in these reports is much more robust and trustworthy than what any individual person or paper has to say. Due to this, we can say that the IPCC Reports are a meaningful representation of scientific knowledge . This is a strong statement, stronger than a mere appeal to consensus.

When it comes to something like the pandemic, we have additional institutions which interpret the scientific knowledge pertaining to the disease through their own non-individualistic means. This means that official stances of places like the WHO or CDC are some of the most reliable ways of understanding the pandemic. It's not about "listening to the experts" but about trusting institutional knowledge.

This may seem like an argument for a technocracy, but it isn't. If anything, it is a call to return to oracles. Rulers used to consult with oracles and mediums who would interpret complex knowledge to give them advice. This is what I am suggesting, the main difference being that we have a much more systematic and - by definition - predictable means of interpreting the whims of nature. Additionally, this does open up the door for other forms of "institutional knowledge" to become oracles for politicians. Economics, religion, and oral tradition, are all different institutions along with science that have with different forms of institutional knowledge and standards for that knowledge. Politics and ideology is then making decisions between which institutions to listen to and when. A claim might be scientifically wrong but economically correct and it would be the role of the politician to know how to take this guidance. Collaboration is the best way to use these knowledges, Robin Wall Kimmerer advocates for collaboration between science and oral tradition of indigenous people ^(4), but this has to be done tactfully in order to respect the conflicting and contradicting knowledge.

This all might seem super esoteric and unnecessary, but the question of "How can we say who is scientifically right and wrong?" is one that has helped me understand the role of something like science in politics.


^(1) At least, this is what we tell ourselves about the history of science. The "Great Man" narrative of science reinforces this. But, in reality, its much more complicated with certain people merely being at the locus of community-wide paradigm shifts that had been in the works for some time.

^(2) Leviathan and the Air Pump

^(3) Laboratory Life

^(4) Braiding Sweetgrass

Posted Aug 18, 2021, 10:04 PM UTC

30
Loading comments…