How do you handle lying to your players?
Like the title says. My crew is in with a few unsavory characters that they don’t know are unsavory. They have received some bad intel but every time they get conflicting info they keep going back to the original price of information as “truth” instead of questioning the source. There have been multiple instances of this and usually it ends up frustrating the players as they don’t know what to believe. So how do you handle this kind of situation in your games? Or should I just cut out those kinds of things?
Posted Aug 24, 2021, 3:25 AM UTC
This is an issue I don't think is solvable in-game. The players tend to think that the DM is a reliable narrator, even when speaking through NPCs, and you just need to reinforce that sometimes NPCs lie to the players. But then again, if the players have two pieces of information and one turns out false, then it's kind of 50/50 which one they'll think is lying unless you make it stupidly obvious.
You could try giving the person with the highest wisdom/intelligence a hint with stuff like "When you think how the info you get from this person keeps getting contradicted, something gnaws at the back of your mind and makes you uncomfortable"
Oh man. When one of my new players figured this out, it wasn't like a kid discovering Santa isn't real. It was like discovering Santa was real, but is now laying face-first in a pool of his own blood as I laughed maniacally over his rapidly cooling corpse with the candy cane dagger still clutched in my hand. They took it hard.
"You lied to us."
"No, the NPC lied to you."
"But you were the one who was talking."
"Well, it's not like he could."
Exactly, the DM gives life to the universe. And it isn't make of exclusively honest people.
And it is the best thing EVER
That's what insight checks and even passive insight are for.