r/DMAcademy•
corbeth

How do you handle lying to your players?

Need Advice

Like the title says. My crew is in with a few unsavory characters that they don’t know are unsavory. They have received some bad intel but every time they get conflicting info they keep going back to the original price of information as “truth” instead of questioning the source. There have been multiple instances of this and usually it ends up frustrating the players as they don’t know what to believe. So how do you handle this kind of situation in your games? Or should I just cut out those kinds of things?

Posted Aug 24, 2021, 3:25 AM UTC

513

This is an issue I don't think is solvable in-game. The players tend to think that the DM is a reliable narrator, even when speaking through NPCs, and you just need to reinforce that sometimes NPCs lie to the players. But then again, if the players have two pieces of information and one turns out false, then it's kind of 50/50 which one they'll think is lying unless you make it stupidly obvious.

You could try giving the person with the highest wisdom/intelligence a hint with stuff like "When you think how the info you get from this person keeps getting contradicted, something gnaws at the back of your mind and makes you uncomfortable"

13
poorbred•

The players tend to think that the DM is a reliable narrator, even when speaking through NPCs, and you just need to reinforce that sometimes NPCs lie to the players.

Oh man. When one of my new players figured this out, it wasn't like a kid discovering Santa isn't real. It was like discovering Santa was real, but is now laying face-first in a pool of his own blood as I laughed maniacally over his rapidly cooling corpse with the candy cane dagger still clutched in my hand. They took it hard.

"You lied to us."

"No, the NPC lied to you."

"But you were the one who was talking."

"Well, it's not like he could."

16
zero_squad•

Exactly, the DM gives life to the universe. And it isn't make of exclusively honest people.

3
DatDamnZotzz•

And it is the best thing EVER

1
MadMojoMonkey•

That's what insight checks and even passive insight are for.

2
MadMojoMonkey•

If you're not taking the PC's passive Insight into account, then you can start doing that. The more blatant a lie is or /should/ be to figure out, the lower the DC on an insight check to realize that. If you have any characters with high enough passive Insight to pass the check, then you can tell them... "Your passive insight is high enough to suggest something seems off about this NPC. Would you like to roll for an insight check?"

​

If they're not calling for insight checks, then they're playing a naive PC that trusts everything anyone tells them, and that's fine for their RP. If they're only doing that because they don't understand that they're expected to ask you for an insight check whenever they want to get a read on an NPC, then let them know to ask for those checks.

2
ProfessorCymru•

Personally, my players are quite skeptical so I usually have at least 1 who is doing insight checks. Maybe take a note of the passive wisdom of your players and, if one player has a notciaebly high stat, maybe tell them that they feel that something is off.

I would say that healthy skepticism may come after getting betrayed or being fed flase information but I don't know how many times this sort of situation has happened. Perhaps the character they recieve information can be described as skethcy by others or by you in your description. I think that once they realise they can take the initiative on these things your players may adapt or maybe they are just too trusting. Hope this helps!

1
Kimimotoo•

Make a different source of information clear? Is there a library? Have the players witness a fight right outside of it, so you can mention:

IN FRONT OF THE LIBRARY!

OUTSIDE THE DIVINERS CARRIAGE!

JAMES MCKNOWITALL FELL DOWN A WELL!

1
rocktamus•

I think some role playing groundwork goes a long way for this. I can speak as a narrator, and then speak in a funny voice as the NPC. The narrator can comment on what the NPC said, and the NPC can ham it up to seem unreliable.

1
nokomarie3•

Well, if they are really frustrated, I think you should take a vacation from lying to them for a little bit until things have settled down. Then see to it that you kind of semi-narrate and voice act the NPC encounters that matter. The NPCs telling the truth can show emotion that is appropriate to the situation and be consistent. The liars either are described as sketchy, have a sketchy voice, say the lies with inappropriate asides, or have trustworthy types that point out that they are known to be liars. Sometimes, you have to deliver to your players the verbal equivalent of a lie buzzer to help them catch on. Say, know which player rolled the highest in intelligence and wisdom and tell them to do a perception check. That should be a nice, big fat "This NPC is probably lying to you." for them to go on even if they don't pass the check.

1
grafikal•

I think this is fine for how you have it setup, but it's more your responsibility to drop hints for the party to pickup. If they're not picking up the hints, you might need to invent something obvious for them to find.

Players tend to want to believe the DM because you're the narrator of the story. If you say something is true, they'll believe that.

You could make it so that maybe an NPC who's telling lies says it in a way that might imply Insight checks against him to determine that he's lying. Do you players know they can do that?

In any case, I think it's fine that in-game, NPCs lie to the players. It's up to the players to determine that they're being lied to ASSUMING you've done your job and granted them the ability to determine that they're being lied to. Maybe they find journals or notes, over hear something from those unsavory characters, or something else - but the players need to be able to find out that they're being lied to. It just depends how obvious you want it to be. If you want them to find out, then start small then work your way up to more and more obvious.

1
ilolvu•

I think that lying to my players is the best thing about mastering. 😂

Unfortunately my players know this and are very sceptical...

Keep on piling that bad intel. Eventually they'll realise what's going on. And then there's hell to pay... (for you or for the npcs. )

Dropping subtle hints might do the trick. Maybe there's another npc that doesn't trust the liar, and says so?

1
KrunKm4yn•

I'm of the opinion if they talk to an npc they've never met before or is notable a un-savory character and either don't insight or roll crappy on it and go off that knowledge as the truth then thats on them. Plus by not atleast trying to lie to your PC's then your robbing them of potential adventure

1