Doesn't Apple scanning/reporting iPhones for illegal activity violate the 4th Amendment?

Current Events

Let me start with my two starting assumptions:

  1. Apple is going to scan the phones of users in search of CSAM with the sole intent being to report results to law enforcement.
  2. The 4th Amendment states basically that search and/or seizure by the government require probable cause.

I'm not talking about iCloud or any Apple services, I'm specifically asking about iPhones which have been purchased by users.

If Apple is searching all (or really any) iPhones for illegal material without having probable cause with the sole purpose being to report crimes to law enforcement, it would seem that Apple is working as de facto law enforcement/government, but searching without probable cause. This violates the 4th Amendment.

This seems very "1984"

Am I wrong somewhere with my logic?

edit: What I was missing is that Apple will include permission to do this with their updated Terms of Service agreement for iOS 15.

Posted Aug 24, 2021, 2:27 PM UTC · edited

2676
Loading comments…