If We had sent down to them the angels, and the dead had spoken to them, and (even if) We had gathered everything before them face to face, still, they were not to believe, unless Allah would have so willed. But, most of them adopt the way of ignorance. [6:111]

Discussion

Posted Aug 25, 2021, 10:50 AM UTC

7314
thisisntreal241•

Someone in the comments make a good point about Dajjal. Also, Allah would never come to down to the world.

20
KingRay37OP•

Yea of course it’s a hypothetical scenario. Allah didn’t even reveal himself to Musa AS or Muhammad SAW. Why would he come down to earth for us. I think it’s so interesting that just as Allah said that even if we were literally to send angels to them some would still disbelieve

13
Muuda•

Wait, Isn’t the Mi’raaj the meeting with Allah where the Prophet saw Allah himself?

2
BoxMediocre•

He didn’t see Him. No one has. He only conversed with Him.

3
Muuda•

No dude you’re mistaken. It was Prophet Musa who used to converse and the Prophet Muhammad PHUH did see Allah when he ascended. https://seekersguidance.org/answers/islamic-belief/did-the-messenger-of-allah-behold-allah-with-his-eyes-2/

1
Muuda•

Those comments are honestly insane. Some people really arrogant and saying they wouldn’t wanna follow Islam even after seeing God…

6
montgomerydoc:United_States_of_America:•

Make this same point about once every two days in debatereligion

To be honest many won’t believe until the Day. And even then will likely take a few thousand years to really sink in.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

I mean like the above me said, it could be the dajjal. It isn't that God or Angels descent would instantly resolve the case. It would be the case that if we assume for a second that God had descended himself then for sure how would have an undoubtable way to conclusively prove to us that he is indeed GOD. If he hypothetically wasn't able to do that, then he isn't God. One of the hypothetical ways is for his teaching to be compatible with all of humanity, a true divine objective morality. I'm not saying Islamic morality isn't compatible, the lack of acceptance in the majority is sort of evidence for lack of conviction, for instance the problem of eternal hell fire. And of course there is a chance of him being a malevolent entity which instead of using persuasiveness and human rationality he would be using manipulation to induce the irrational as rational as in the case of Dajjal. Thus, it seems that the vote polls results are fairly reasonable.

-1
[deleted]•

lol the irony! The ayah is literally about people with these views. If god himself came down, yall would probably say he ain’t god.

2

What makes a god GOD? Obviously not any supernatural entity that "came down"(Which in itself fallacious as how can we earthly beings have the ability to see the one unbounded by anything of creation but nvm) to earth proclaiming it's a god is a God like Dajjal for instance. Even if he shows an ability. There will still be room for doubts, it isn't arrogance but "lack of conviction" which true God can resolve. Of course there will again be chances for "Manipulation of rationality from malevolent entity", what would be the resolve? Nothing. Really, nothing. That what makes the vote poll "reasonable" but IDK IDK.

1