Speed of the earth through the universe

Shouldnt we be able to measure the speed of the earth through the universe by using the speed of light as a constant? Not taking orbits into account. If so what is this speed?

Posted Feb 5, 2012, 6:20 AM UTC

18
TaslemGuy•

Light is always measured at the same speed. You and a bullet you fired would both measure it to be moving at the same speed.

So relative to what?

2
MechaWizardOP•

Hmm i may have overlooked that. I was thinkinh if you measured the speed of light along three axis the difference would give some measure of speed.

1
TaslemGuy•

Light is always measured to be the same speed, regardless of your velocity.

3
[deleted]•

It's not clear what you mean. How would you propose doing this?

1
MagicNine•

Well, here's the problem: The velocity of something can only be measured in relation to something else. We define a point at rest, and from that we describe the velocity of everything else.

But there is no fixed point in the universe. There is no center, no definite point to move in relation to.

The milky way galaxy does have a center. It has a black hole in the middle, and has a spiral formation. Our solar system is in one of these spiral arms. Relative to the middle of the galaxy, our sun (and by extention our solar system) orbits at a speed of about 240 km/sec. That may give you a little closure for your question.

1
55555•

Well, if the big bang happened from a single location, that should be the center of the universe, even if matter was distributed asymmetrically afterwards. Do we simply not know where that location is, or is there some other reason we can't measure our velocity relative to that?

1
MagicNine•

Because there are others who can explain it better than me.

http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/fv6gf/do_we_know_where_the_center_of_the_universe_place/

And big bang happened everywhere in the universe, when the universe was small. Why? Because what we call the big bang is not a point or thing, but the process of creation at the start of the universe. The big bang was a state of the universe, not really an object or anything.

2
travis373Quantum Mechanics | Nanoelectronics•

The big bang didn't happen in a single "location" as a location wouldn't have existed, all dimensions and time were birthed in the big bang. So it didn't explode out of a point, it happened everywhere at once. It's kind of a hard concept to get across, you have to realise that principles like position and "before" don't apply to the big bang. In truth, we don't really no anything about the very beginning of the big bang, only the fractions of seconds after it.

1