argguyOP•

Thoughts on the article? It goes into quite a bit of technical detail and jargon that may obfuscate the pure evidence presented, but I think overall it casts some doubt on the common narrative

TL;DR

The $1 trillion number that's commonly placed on the value of Afghanistan's resources may not be at all accurate, based on outdated reports, exaggerated rounding, and inaccurate measuring/calculations among other reasons.

3
DontSayTonedYee•

The Minerals meme is dumb shit, you can smell this from a mile away. Why did Afghanistan, throughout the occupation, not build a large scale mining industry? On every global ranking of ore/metals/minerals/rare earth exports, Afghanistan doesn't even register. Between say 2011 and 2021, there were 10 years of opportunity in ANA/NATO held provinces. Nothing happened.

It's absolutely the case that mineral extraction was promoted in the country. But the scale of it makes much more sense as a leg to stand on for the country itself, not as one of the driving forces of a >trillion dollar campaign by the US and its allies. According to the OEC, Afghanistans only valuable mining export, Gold, went to the UAE anyways. Valuable exports to the US, or any kind of rare earth, nowhere in sight.

If anything had happened, we wouldn't hear all these "poppy fields" stories by anti-foreign-involvement media, but they'd be overshadowed by a load of "mining equipment" stories instead. A billion dollar excavation site with tens of millions worth of equipment and inventory and droves of valuable personnel warrants much more security by soldiers / PMCs than flower fields (whether they produce opiates or not).

Your article values that one flagship mining site at $2B tops ($800M real), even Al-Jazeera reports the mining sector "contributes only between seven and 10 percent of Afghanistan’s GDP" ($1.3B-1.8B) in 2019. And most of this is gonna be domestic consumption. Just like with the Bolivia allegations in 2019, there are numerous other larger mining locations in the world with established large-scale mining ventures operating on economically viable deposits, many in secure and stable nations, for every resource in question.

This article makes a good case against the $1T figure itself (though you can routinely even read abut $3T quotes), but this isn't even necessary - just because the ground may have some worth, doesn't mean you can realize this value. You'd need these minerals to literally lay around in clumps on the ground before any mining industry will want to materialize in an utterly corrupt, war-torn, geographically inaccessible region like this.

And one thing I'd like to add to show how conspiratorial this narrative is, coming from our favourite champagne socialist: Apparently mineral giants just decided they can extract resources much better with the Taliban in control, and that's why Biden was allowed to leave. NATO was a hindrance to mineral extraction, actually. So the West went to Afghanistan to steal their resources, stayed to extract those resources but never did that to any significant degree, and now they left Afghanistan to better extract those resources. I don't buy it.

5
FatFingerHelperBot•

It seems that your comment contains 1 or more links that are hard to tap for mobile users. I will extend those so they're easier for our sausage fingers to click!

Here is link number 1 - Previous text "OEC"


^Please ^PM ^/u/eganwall ^with ^issues ^or ^feedback! ^| ^Code ^| ^Delete

2
AethonShaan•

As mad as it sounds I don't think a trillion dollars is a lot for a entire countries mineral deposits, especially one which hasn't been exploited already to my knowledge. Australia is selling over a quarter of that a year, sure it's a uniquely mineral rich country but like rocks are expensive and Afghanistan is a big country so it has to have some good rocks.

1
C-DT•

Now what we need is an in-depth article that disputes the claims of the war in Afghanistan existing to feed the military industrial complex.

1