Antivaxxers are parasites to our movement.

Philosophy

Vaccines have been an endless swirling stream of disconnected talking points. I want to clearly outline the situation, so that confusion and cognitive dissonance can no longer be used as tools to blind us.

On the one hand, we have to make a point of defending their personal liberty. They are correct that bodily autonomy is worth defending no matter the circumstance.

On the other hand, they are severely and willfully damaging our movements public perception and traction. Someone who won’t take a single dose of medication, one time, to minimize their chances of infecting people with a respiratory disease? That is the most convincing argument against libertarianism that exists.

Whenever you’re talking to a normie about libertarianism, at some point you must inevitably say: “Sure, some people might use it to get away with being selfish assholes, but most people can do the right thing without daddy government.” Antivaxxers are those selfish assholes whose existence we must justify in defense of our ideology. Nothing less, nothing more.

Posted Aug 29, 2021, 4:15 PM UTC · edited

12120
livinlavidal0ca•

It’s like that with the westboro Baptist church or the KKK and speech, but it’s part of how it goes. You either believe in free speech or you don’t. You either believe in bodily autonomy or you don’t.

13
crabsinmyass69•

Is giving someone covid against their will bodily autonomy?

2
rolltherick1985I Voted•

Is an std, a cold, or every other disease,?

3
crabsinmyass69•

Yes, that's why it's illegal to have sex without telling someone you have an std. Because it permanently effects their lives like covid has for nearly a million people.

2
rolltherick1985I Voted•

That is incorrect. It is illegal to knowingly infect someone with an std. Same with covid. The problem is it is nearly impossible to determine who gave it to you.

3
[deleted]•

This post not v libertarian

12
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

This post is undeniably libertarian, because it acknowledges their bodily autonomy. It is simply correct in ways you would rather we didn’t acknowledge.

7†

Don't let this one poster throw you off, the post is solid and very libertarian. Libertarianism is all about personal responsibility and non-agression, both of which anti vaxxers heavily lack. It is an issue we should be looking for every market solution possible to attempt to solve, such as private business vax mandates, higher insurance premiums for unvaccinated, and ICU right of refusal for wilfully unvaxxed patients when capacity is dangerously low.

4

It is. You can not have a libertarian society if people don't accept much larger personal responsibility than they do under a heavily governed society. If a large portion of society won't even get a well studied jab endorsed by tens of thousands of the most educated scientific leaders in society, then how likely is it that society would actually have enough personal responsibility to succeed without strong leadership? People who want to push the libertarian movement should be heavily encouraging those around them to get vaccinated and eridicated this virus before it can mutate into something worse, because it's their personal responsibility to protect themselves and to not agress on those around them by spreading the virus.

At the very least, libertarians should support free market compromises, such as allowing hospitals to deny Covid care to any wilfully unvaccinated person in situations where ICU capacity is low, which would succeed in freeing up our health care system to care for those with actual preventive conditions. We should also be pushing for insurance companies to charge extremely high premiums for anti-vaxxers (and I wouldn't stop there, I'd also charge higher premiums for obese people and people with other behaviorally chosen medical conditions that expose the collective to higher costs).

Point is that the anti vaccine movement is a major externality that poses a great threat to society, and while libertarians should support the right of people to not get it, we should also push heavily for financial and social pressures for people to get the vaccine so we can internalize this externality without need for government intervention to protect ICU capacities.

7
hardsoft•

The vaccines are not stopping the Delta variant. At least one recent study has shown vaccine effectiveness drop from just over 90% to in the 60s as Delta has picked up in the US. Vaccinated may now just represent more asymptomatic spreaders.

Highly vaccinated areas, such as in Israel and Canada are still seeing accelerating case numbers. Most of those are unvaccinated but as the CDC has said, there's bias in those numbers given vaccinated with little to no symptoms are less likely to get tested. Only recently has the CDC recommended vaccinated who have been exposed to a positive case get tested.

Vaccinated individuals who have had breakthrough infections are found to carry viral loads similar to unvaccinated. And so may be just as contagious.

Those who have already been infected by covid look to have better resistance to the Delta variant than vaccinated who weren't previously infected.

There aren't zero risks with the vaccine. And even in normal situations may be side effects, require the use of PTO, etc.

All this is to say if you've been infected previously and chose not to be vaccinated you aren't a social scrooge by any reason based measure.

The last real social argument is to prevent overwhelming our hospitals, as the vaccine is very effective at reducing the severity of symptoms.

And for that reason if you can, I think you should get the vaccine. But I also think the shamers need to stop acting like more people getting vaccinated would stop the spread of Delta. Not going to happen. Herd immunity is not possible with mandates or anything else barring a new more effective vaccine against the Delta variant.

11
zig_anon•

The vaccines are still helping the individuals who are vaccinated

It’s true the Delta variant likely can rip through a 1/2 vaccinated population faster than the original variant could an unvaccinated one

Thank goodness for science and these vaccines

12
DrippiTrippyRight Libertarian•

Thank goodness “science” says there’s essentially zero reason for my 32yo healthy self to be worried about something like Covid. Therefore making a vaccine for it pointless in my and 99% of cases.

  • Edit for the one letter missing in the comment that had you confused….
-10
Coca-karlcustom red•

says there’s essentially zero reason for my 32yo healthy self to be worried about something like Covid.

This is wrong. The science says that you should be less concerned about a relatively quick death but very concerned about the long term debilitating effects. We don't know the exact rates they occur but even people with asymptomatic cases have suffered permanent organ damage. If you're unlucky enough to be hospitalized (which happens practically randomly) you have a 30-50% chance of symptoms linger for an undetermined period of time possibly for your entire life.

9
zig_anon•

Even if that is not true who wants to get knocked on their ass with Covid, loss their sense of smell etc even if for two weeks

4
DrippiTrippyRight Libertarian•

How does the “science” say this about a virus that has exist for 1.5yrs?

Answer? It doesn’t, you’re talking out of the side of your mouth about a hot button term that is rare in nature but blasted all over MSM, to create fear where there should be none. Long lasting effects of taste and smell, oh my.

-4
zig_anon•

Don’t understand the quote on the word science or much of what you want to say

4
DrippiTrippyRight Libertarian•

The word “science” is in quotes because it’s being used incorrectly consistently at this point to fall back on when you have no idea what ones talking about.

Science is a process. Not to be confused with “fact” or “law”.

And I edited my first comment for you. 👍🏻

-4
chalbersmaFlairitarian•

The only thing I'm worried about with vaccines is the number of people the FDA carelessly killed with it's regulatory environment that prevented vaccines from being rolled out.

On the other hand, they are severely and willfully damaging our movements public perception and traction. Someone who won’t take a single dose of medication, one time, to minimize their chances of infecting people with a respiratory disease? That is the most convincing argument against libertarianism that exists.

This is absolutely true. The anti-vax movement is an authoritarian's wet dream. Proof positive that when a free society needs it's people the most they're more than willing to let it down.

6
zig_anon•

There is no chance vaccines would have rolled out any sooner. They were being manufactured as they were being tested. The trial end points were set by the companies themselves met in Nov and vaccines were being dosed in December

This is libertarian fantasy land stuff

7
chalbersmaFlairitarian•

Vaccines are safe today for people under 12, can't give it to them. The FDA delayed a month between initial EUA request and approval right at the beginning of last year's fall spike. And without the FDA people at super high risk could have gotten vaxed in the fall of last year (think COVID ward nurses & doctors and nursing home residents). We really could have cut down the spread if people were allowed to take the vaccine pre-EUA approval.

-1
zig_anon•

In a world without the FDA there is zero chance Pfizer is taking all the liability for vaccines that hadn’t even met their end point in a clinical trial. The vaccines were tested in a double blind study

3
chalbersmaFlairitarian•

In a free society, you'd be able to waive your right to sue in order to get early access to the vaccine, they're be independent, non-governmental bodies that would insure and verify the efficacy of medice; they'd sometimes disagree or have differing risk tolerance levels. And as an individual you'd have the right to weigh the cost/benefit of vaccination vs. infection.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

If “you” and “I” vote for a libertarian candidate then we better hope, sorry, “you” and “I” better hope the other candidates get less than two votes.

Individual rights are paramount, but just because you have a horse doesn’t mean you have to be a cowboy. There is nothing wrong with voluntary association, and in fact, that is the only way for meaningful large scale change to happen.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

A libertarian candidate does not have to be a member of the USA Libertarian Party, they just have to uphold the principles. And considering that libertarianism is a governmental philosophy, this movement really has no point if it doesn’t sway the governance.

4
othergabe•

This isn't remotely libertarian and you don't speak for any of us.

4†
ThorConstableCustom Yellow•

We have to make a point to defend their personal. They are correct that we must defend bodily autonomy at all cost

You think that's not remotely libertarian? Really?

2
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

I acknowledge that we must defend their right to make selfish decisions. That is exactly as much libertarianism as these people are owed.

I speak for plenty of people here who actually care about the movement, and don’t just want a place to bitch about the government online.

0†
othergabe•

You speak only for yourself.

6
ThorConstableCustom Yellow•

We have to make a point to defend their personal. They are correct that we must defend bodily autonomy at all cost.

So you don't agree with that part?

1
DeamonetteClassical Liberterian•

I'm just tired of people whining about not wanting the jab.

STFU and get the shot, i wanna get this pandemic over with

4†
6oudreau•

But I don't like the gOvErMeNt telling me what to do.... literal hundreds of times posted in every lib-right political compass meme.

2†

If the government told you to jump off a tall building to your death would you?

1†
6oudreau•

Is that what a vaccine is to you?

Dramatic coward.

3

So you would jump then, that figures.

A vaccine to me is an attenuated virus. Is RNA an attenuated virus to you? Personal attacks.. how cringe. Thanks.

-2†

It never was a pandemic. We only needed to protect the vulnerable and everyone else could have had their lives go on as normal in a bad flu season. The western world has gone mad.

2
kdpope85•

Apparently you haven’t looked at what’s happening in India……….

2

Ivermectin? Tuberculosis?

3
kdpope85•

You said the entire western world has gone mad, as if Covid is only a problem here, Covid numbers in India were skyrocketing, in a county that tests and reports significantly less than the west. They are vaccinating at a much faster rate and their infection rates are dropping significantly. Your idea that if we just protected the vulnerable and this would have gone away is ludicrous.

2
Clock-Full•

I'm not going to try and convince someone that they should get the jab or shouldn't get the jab. However, I am interested in your statement about how you " wanna get this pandemic over with". Do you believe that when a certain percentage of people are vaccinated that the government (or science) will declare the pandemic over with? Honestly, I think this will drag out even if most of the population gets vaccinated.

2
DrippiTrippyRight Libertarian•

Stop calling people not getting a Covid vaccine “anti-vaxxer”. It’s fucking moronic. I also don’t get a flu shot. But had my normal childhood vaccinations. As did my child, minus the flu shot.

The parasites to “our platform” are those who try to use emotion and fear to sway a crowd instead of thinking for yourself.

Let’s try thinking. Healthy, young, no medical hx persons, need vaccinated? No. Geriatric and/or holding onto one or most likely multiple co-morbidities? Sure, would be in your best interest to do so.

Not sure what’s so hard to grasp here if you just turn off the tv.

3†
NickyDL•

Thank you, I'm tired of hearing people being called antivaxxer just because they don't want this one vaccine. There are many people that have all of the traditional vaccines, they vaccinated their children, but they are against this one particular vaccine at this particular point in time. Yet they are being labeled as crazy antivaxxer that wants the old people of society to die.

Many people are aware that these vaccines are still being studied and would like to wait until the final data is in, what is wrong with that? Here is an example of one study, which isn't scheduled to be completed until May 2,2023

Study to Describe the Safety, Tolerability, Immunogenicity, and Efficacy of RNA Vaccine Candidates Against COVID-19 in Healthy Individuals

https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04368728

2
DrippiTrippyRight Libertarian•

Even beyond that. Some people are healthy enough to use their head and realize they don’t need such a vaccine. Much like some choose to get a flu shot, I do not. I’m happy they are able to do so, but I have no need at this point in my life.

4
Jaboonka•

Not anti vax also not getting the vaccine.

3
ThorConstableCustom Yellow•

This comment section is gonna get saucy!

2
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Just how I like it! A net of one upvote but 78 comments, now that’s how you know you started a real discussion.

3
runninwoof•

bodily autonomy but only the way i like it

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Andras89Bannitarian•

You forgot your shitpost flair.

1
lemme-explain•

Whenever you’re talking to a normie about libertarianism, at some point you must inevitably say: “Sure, some people might use it to get away with being selfish assholes, but most people can do the right thing without daddy government.” Antivaxxers are those selfish assholes whose existence we must justify in defense of our ideology. Nothing less, nothing more.

That’s fine, as long as there’s few enough of them that we can still achieve here immunity. But if there’s too man of them, the virus will continue to mutate until it beats the vaccine. The lesson: Libertarianism can only survive up to some numerical threshold of selfish assholes.

1

Calling people anti-vaxxer is hate speech.

1
BigRed323•

Well said.

1
DeBigBamboocustom green•

98% survival rate. Downvote if you agree.

-1†
lastpork•

Did I just read this on a libertarian Reddit? Come on. Please.

-1†
Av8tr1•

Libertarian, You Keep Using That Word, I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means.

-2†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

This post is undeniably libertarian, as it outlines the right of antivaxxers to make their own choice. It just happens to also outline the ways in which this choice reflects on our movement, in ways that you would prefer we didn’t acknowledge.

Edit: FYI, further down this guy took the mask off and referred to the vaccine as "dangerous and potentially life threatening chemicals". If his reasonable statements seem irrelevant to the discussion, it's because he's hiding behind them.

0†
Av8tr1•

Yeah, no. You can expect to be downvoted to hell. Antivaxxers as nutty as they may be are the very definition of the movement.

They chose to make their own choice to manage their lives and not have their lives be dictated by daddy government. That is the core concept of the Libertarian movement. In fact that you are so far off the mark of what it means to be libertarian I suspect you are a troll.

It is you who are spouting anti libertarian ideas and do not belong.

-1†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

I very clearly said that we must defend their right to bodily autonomy. You ignore this because it isn’t the real problem you have with my post.

The real problem you have with my post is that you also see libertarianism as a chance to be selfish with no consequence, and even being a recognized as selfish is more of a consequence than you can stomach.

6
Av8tr1•

Nope, I recognize that Libertarian means the right to self govern and the pursuit of happiness. Those words should sound familiar. You can't talk out of both sides of your mouth. You either defend their right to bodily autonomy or you don't. And clearly by your post you do not and seek to ostracize people for not agreeing with you. How very authoritarian of you. That is the exact opposite of the core belief of the Libertarian movement. You'll make a great stormtrooper when you grow up.

As to the rest of your drivel. I never said I supported someone being selfish. Someone can be antivax and not put others lives in danger. There are many ways someone can avoid the vaccine and take steps to avoid infecting others. Additionally getting the vaccine is not in any way a guarantee of not gaining the virus as has been proven time and time again. Heck even the Covid testing isn't reliable.

We have had the flu for 100s of years. We have a new vaccine every year for it. Yet the flu comes back around every year (and ironically kills more people than Covid) yet no one is demanding vaccines for the Flu as a condition of being part of society. So what is the difference here?

You have a serious lack of understanding of what it means to be Libertarian.

Add to that you seem to have a complete lack of understand of what a vaccine is and does. Or seemingly any knowledge of medical science at all.

3
chalbersmaFlairitarian•

Upvote from me. He's right on all points. Anti-vaxxers are idiots who couldn't possibly make a better argument for government authority over your health.

2†
Av8tr1•

Posting from your other account troll?

No he isn't right in any way at all. His post is nothing but an authoritarian demand for someone to bend to his will and if they don't they should be ostracized and punished.

That isn't in any way Libertarian.

2†
thatsnotwaitam I a real libertarian?•

Did you read the post?

1
ThorConstableCustom Yellow•

We have to make a point to defend their personal. They are correct that we must defend bodily autonomy at all cost

Is the the anti-libertarian ideas you're mad at him for? Or is it just that he called antivaxxers selfish?

0†
Av8tr1•

Definitely the anti-libertarian ideas. And I am not mad at him, I just think he is stupid and needs to educate himself before coming here and spouting off about things he has not clue about.

I work in the medical field. We have a nurse who is an antivaxer. She is an absolute nut who should know better, but she makes a good argument over the right to chose.

I think, as most Libertarian's, that being vaccinated should be a choice. But with choices come consequences. Don't want to be vaccinated, you can't go to school, or the theater, etc.

But being forced to put chemicals in your body by the government is not freedom and is not in any way something the Libertarian movement should ever support.

Anyone who claims to be Libertarian and agrees with forced vaccinations is in the wrong reddit (and the wrong side of history). I think you are looking for r/nazi

2
Av8tr1•

Nope, I’ve been willingly vaccinated for lots of things. All vaccines are potentially dangerous and life threatening to certain people. Those people should have the choice. I am not in any way anti vaccine.

Nice try duchebag but your argument still doesn’t hold any water. It doesn’t matter if it’s vaccines or color of your skin. Any demands the government puts on our personal way of life that we don’t agree to is against the Libertarian way.

-1
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

All I did is post what you said. If you want to put the mask back on, so be it.

But keep in mind that one of the main arguments for vaccines, and even authoritarian vaccine mandates, is herd immunity to protect people with medical conditions who cannot take it safely. So that's still a bullshit qualifier to you referring the the vaccine as "dangerous and potentially deadly chemicals."

2
Av8tr1•

All you are doing is trying to twist my words and doing it poorly.

Do you even listen to what you are saying? You are in favor of forcing people to do something they don’t want to do. And you support government being the ones forcing. That is as anti libertarian as it comes.

-1
mmagers1•

First and foremost vaccines don’t work. The respiratory disease came from animals, like the flue will be here the rest of our lives. There will always be some variant for the rest of our lives and each variant will be less deadly because it doesn’t make sense to kill its host.

People who have covid have a stronger immunity than those that have taken all the shots plus the booster and those immunity last a lot longer. Also ivermectin has been proven to treat symptoms of covid per 100,000 and only 2 died from it. Compared to 29.6 per 100,000 to untreated with ivermectin.

This vaccine is just a way to take away rights, liberty’s and freedoms, and 99.96 survival rate.

Also if the vaccine works then why are you worried about the unvaccinated. If you truly believe they will die let them die and leave them alone with their choices. But you will find out that most of the hospitals are from the people who are vaccinated not the un vaccinated like the media wants to tell everyone.

Look at Israel where over 80 percent of the population is vaccinated and have the most cases in all the world

-8
thatsnotwaitam I a real libertarian?•

First and foremost vaccines don’t work.

Yeah I just got smallpox this morning. Sad.

10
mmagers1•

You are twisting my words, I am was talking about sars covid 19 virus vaccines not all vaccines. Since this post was about that particular virus

-4
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Vaccines don’t work, horse dewormer does…

Thank you for posting, you are a good example of the sort of dead weight which our principles burden us to carry.

9
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mmagers1•

Ivermectin is used to treat parasitic diseases in humans. Yes they do have a ivermectin that is meant for horses. Yes people have suggested getting ivermectin through a vet because the one that doctors prescribed are being suppressed and doctors are being threatened with their loss of license. However I didn’t suggest that I just posted the facts

-9
Bsdave103•

I wish I could downvote you twice your ignorance is astonishing.

6
theshoeshiner84•

But wait, didn't you read all his sources!?!?

5