The second half of the 1996 13-9 win over Ohio State. Objectively speaking, that was the best Ohio State team in my lifetime (even better than the 2002 team), which makes this win all the more satisfying.

Posted Aug 30, 2021, 5:47 PM UTC

1413
rondonjon•

Oh yeah, the golden years (of my lifetime). Seems so far far away.

7
refreshroomOP•

And the best part is it set the stage for the 1997 season, one we haven't seen anything like since.

2
[deleted]•

The 90’s where Osu had great teams that just choked to frankly worse Michigan teams

Statistically I think the 2019 Osu team was the best Osu team since the 70’s

6
DP8414•

As fantastic as that second half was, what with Tai Streets 68 yard slant and go TD, I disagree that the 1996 team was the best OSU team of our lifetime (I was born in 1989).

There’s this handy stat on Sports Reference called the SRS rating, which rewards you for beating good teams, and rewards you even more when you blow them out. Sometimes it can overrate certain teams and underrate others, but on the whole, its a useful stat, as it heavily coorelates with the actual top 25, and more specifically, how good those teams “felt” when we watched them.

By that measure, the 2019 Buckeyes team was one of the best college football teams of the last 30 years. Their SRS rating was 27.39, with almost an exacting balance between offense and defense. The 1996 Buckeyes had an SRS rating of 22.45, and it was heavily favored towards defense.

To put that in perspective, most years in college football, not a single team has an SRS rating over 25, and usually only two to four teams per year have an SRS rating over 20. The 2019 Buckeyes were next level dominant. In hindsight, Clemson beating them was a legit upset, especially after being down 16-0 (could have been 28-0 if Ryan Day didnt settle for field goals deep in the red zone).

IMO, the 1996 Buckeyes are remembered mostly because of Orlando Pace, who popularized the term “pancake.” Not to say they didn’t have other great players, but not like the 2019 Buckeyes, who spit out superstars all over the roster (Fields, Dobbins, Olave, Davis, Young, Arnett, Okudah).

2
joeh4384•

I would say OSU had more talent in 96,98,15,19 then when they won championships in 02 and 14.

3
DP8414•

I agree. Their 2002 team was like 2010 Auburn with how many close wins they had, and their 2014 team peaked at just the right time. (Also no one took them seriously, not even Alabama)

1
[deleted]•

Yea the 2019 buckeyes were insane and I think beat Clemson 2019 more than Clemson would have beat them

Actually looking at srs ratings harbaughs Michigan teams were better than most of carrs Michigan teams post 2000

Adding on best team since 1997 by srs was the 2016 Michigan team with a srs of around 17. 2006 barely edged out the 2018 Michigan team

There’s something to be said that most of harbaughs teams rank very well using advanced analytics

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/schools/michigan/index.html

2
DP8414•

Dude, that surprised me too when I combed through the SRS ratings last January (I’m nerdy enough that I typed them all down on a Word document. lol). Harbaugh’s teams are consistently good. They just rarely win the games that matter, whether thats Ohio State, Bowl games, or upper echelon B1G road games.

With the exception of last year and the 2017 team, which had a really good defense but shitty QB play, all of Harbaugh’s teams have had SRS ratings over 15, which is universally a good number. The only team I question there is our 2019 team, which I think is distorted by our 45-17 curb stomping of an 11-2, top 15 ranked Notre Dame team. We looked like shit for a good portion of that year.

But honestly, even with the soul crushing losses (blocked punt, 4th and 1, 62-39), I think the SRS ratings reflect how good our 15, 16, and 18 teams actually were. The Revenge Tour was some of the best fun of the Harbaugh era. The 9-0 start in 2016 was 1997 tier. Jake Rudock’s blow up made the second half of 2015 fun.

I want to believe Harbaugh can figure it out and get us on the level of the elite. But after the last two years, it sure seems like his program has a hard ceiling that is good but not great.

2
[deleted]•

Yea I still believe in harbaugh to get us back to 2015-2019 level pretty quickly. Michigan did play really good football for the most part from 2015-2019 but really good football isn’t good enough to beat the buckeyes or win a big ten title. There’s a good argument to be made that Michigan was almost a top ten team nationally by advanced metrics from 2015-2019 but that’s still not good enough to beat Osu most years.

I am losing faith that he can get us a big ten championship but never say never right

1
FastidiousFalcon•

Starting his 7th year... and I’m more excited about Basketball!! 😳

1
MilkBarPatron•

I don't quite understand your title. Ohio State has definitely had several better teams this since then.

1

I think you mean "subjectively speaking." I don't think you know what "objectively" means in this context?

1†