Constitution vs Damage, 2-Attribute-Scaling Weapon version. How to split between stats like CON, STR & DEX at the same time! Also: Why CON was so popular and when damage might be better
Posted Aug 31, 2021, 1:12 AM UTC
Posted Aug 31, 2021, 1:12 AM UTC
Nice video, I had a hard time really parsing all that info. IDK if that's just me.
What do you think the viability of musket + greataxe is? I love the great axe but I'm trying to pair it with a ranged weapon other than hatchet.
He packs his videos chock full of some of the most detailed mathematics and theorycrafting that exists in community so far. This man does his research.
I love the great axe but I'm trying to pair it with a ranged weapon other than hatchet.
If you absolutely need to use a ranged weapon I'd probably go fire staff w/ elemental gem.
But the great axe is so good at gap closing that you don't really need a ranged waepon.
Thank you and thanks a lot for the feedback as well! This particular video was a bit hard to balance in terms of easy comprehension, since I didn't want to repeat all the info from previous one. Seems like I missed the mark a bit, will try and improve that for future ones!
Musket gaxe is a really hard combo since they have no stat synergy at all and a full con musket build would also miss the mark. Sometimes you can work around it with Int gems, but neither of those weapons would benefit from the stats provided. The only way I could see it somewhat work would be by going for a str/con build and purely used the trapper tree on the musket for utility, setting up traps and using bomb slows for even better chase potential with the gaxe. But effectively, I think you'd be stunting yourself a lot. Spear musket would be a better middle ground for melee with musket. If they buff spear animations for PvP, it might become an option.
Tyvm for your help! You're doing God's work.
use great axe and ice gauntlet
Consider SnS/Musket, this is probably the best combo if not a bit gimmicky (open powder burn->bash when close->trap->shooter's x5 HS->win). I don't think musket is that great outside of this combo. Bow is better for spear than musket is for example. Unless they nerf bash I have a hard time seeing a better musket pairing than SnS.
Great tests man. However i think you are missing the fact that for anything other than 1v1 con is going to get better.
Up to a certain point, yes. You still need a balanced setup, Having 5 dudes with maxed Con won't beat a team of split stats. Difference won't be that huge and gaining more actual damage will help speed bursts up. In group play, organized synchronized damage wins but you can't forfeit defenses. Need to survive a certain amount of damage so having some Con is good.
Thank you! Multiple enemies is something you look at from different angles. Multiple enemies attacking you? Con is better. You attacking multiple enemies with AoE/cleaves? Damage is better. Because of that alone, blending stats to some degree will always be better.
Yeah the stat balance thing was what i was getting at. I wonder if there are breakpoints where getting 1 more str for example wont increase your damage but 2 would.
I think that level of minmaxing will stay on paper, since you're unlikely to get perfectly statted gear for those things and reaching 50 point intervals is way more important anyways!
At level 60 there isnt much need for going past 200 con
I will agree that for wars & particularly large XvX, con has a special role but I don't think it wildly out-values the other stats at that point, esp FULL con vs a 250 con / primary split. I think 150-250 con + primary split is hard to beat for any activity bar some niche setups like bow.
Ppl forget that being dead eq to no dmg at all..
Ps. There was another discussion about melee without stagger in wars and beta. Overall if they nerf weapons like great axe, all the top players from my server I know already declared going range. Because like you said you gonna get blown up before you even get to the enemy. Removing stagger brought a huge issue to melee vs range balance.
People also forget there are other ways to avoid taking damage besides being better at taking hits to the face.
Definitely, haha! Hm, I wonder how everyone going range would play out - especially in Wars where frontline is kinda needed.
4 team of tanks spammed with healers from afar and 6 teams of fire mages... Thats how its going to look like without proper balance.
Sure but in most activities there's solid ways to avoid damage. Dodging is really important and one of the highest-skill aspects remaining after stagger removal. I'm not for/against stagger, it had its pros/cons but I would have liked to have seen more tweaking after its removal.
I think part of the problem here with the ranged debate is skill. Ranged weapons require substantially more aim and better movement mechanics to function compared to most melee weapons. This doesn't mean melee can't tech-chase etc, they can but most won't realize it's something they aren't doing that they should be doing vs ranged. You're also forgetting that SnS blocking is omnipotent vs ranged.
I also think lighter armors are going to be naturally higher skill (this is similar in souls games too) because they provide you a better dodge and dodging takes skill to fully utilize whereaes greater mitigation from heavier armors doesn't and provides benefit even if you're sleeping.
I'm not convinced there aren't skill-based melee setups though. I think light-cat SnS/Gaxe and SnS/Hatchet are very competition. SnS is a more technical skill based weapon (if you want to get damage out of it) and blocking is a more technical mechanic in NW rather than a panic button like it is in most games, so this throws off a lot of the newer melee players expectations I think.
So yeah, its expected that Ranged will have a slight advantage in higher skill groupings because its more involved mechanically. There are good counters in the game to this though, so I don't think the gap is huge. On a side note, I'm also still holding out that high-skill spear is a thing, can't quite tell yet, need to test light-cat spear/hatchet or something more in the next beta but its not looking great.
The actual issue isn’t stagger it’s just that we all can dodge like crazy and run at full speed with no draw backs, even if they added stagger back you could just get slapped, dodge away then keep kiting.
The issue actually still existed in the preview week with stagger enabled.
What’s really letting ranged off the hook is the fact that all the animations got their movement unlocked
But wasnt stagger basically a stunlock? So if you got close and just kept light attacking you would stagger an enemy from 100 to 0. That is how I understood stagger or is that wrong information? I don't know enough to make an informed decision.
I'm already going Bow and Spear because of this, so yeah. I like having the option to range and spear is my favorite melee weapon, until they add a javelin/halberd.
stunlock was a total myth by players who didn't understand the combat.
There was a stagger immunity that prevented stunlock, so after you got staggered several times in quick succession - you could just move out of it as you had an immunity timer
False. This is so wrong it's not even wrong it's just stupid. There was never, at any point, an immunity to stagger. They gave you a free dodge roll after the preview 2 months before they removed stagger but that's it.
The preview definitely had a way out after you were punished for taking the first hit.
As a matter of fact there is a video showing that grit, roll, block and the use of several abilities could get you away from it…
So in all my PvP vs hatchet players at the end of preview - I imagined not being staggered after like 4 hits?
Come on man.
It was there - hell I was teaching my guild how to get out of hatchet spam with dodge and block after 3-4 hits.
There was no stunlock - that shit is just wrong and stupid - because people didn't know how to counter hatchet-spam
People just didn't know how to play the game. You could have blocked or dodged to get out of it.
Oh, fair enough. I never tested so can't comment but thanks for clarifying :)
Stagger was you would be interrupted whilst they do two attacks. It was only ever two. People who didn't know where the dodge button was would complain they would get 100-0
Ah, that's fair. It does not sound that bad. Its as usual people exaggerating :D
Actually what the poster above said wasn’t true, people’s standard reaction was to mash the dodge button when they’d take stagger, no one just started getting staggered and then threw their hands up in the air and went “fuck it”, they smashed their dodge button and then said fuck it.
What was actually happening was two things, the first being people not managing their stamina and just burning dodges and getting caught out and the second was people with who higher ping vs someone with low ping would get stagger locked the death
Don't listen to these people they are all very dangerously wrong and don't understand the game at all.
You are wrong. You are the weakest link. Good bye.
You could always break from stagger spam. But few ppl actually did that and preferred to complain instead.
Ppl just dont like being told „they noob”
That's fair
Almost everyone who replied to you is wrong. Stagger locks did happen in cases where you had high latency (more than 100 rtt) and could not dodge or block during the window where you were not staggered.
Claiming something isn’t working because you’re above 100 ping in an action combat game doesn’t mean it isn’t true.
Hilarious that you’re even trying to make that a valid complaint.
What competitive game with twitch combat works properly with more than 100 ping? Lmao
The difference is I'm not just claiming that but I don't care about you or your opinion enough to bother spending the hours finding enough evidence to break your preconceived notions of how latency affects the game. You are wrong. You're just not skilled enough to understand why you're wrong. So you don't even know that you're wrong.
Awww shit, my man!
Comrade! As always, thank you for your support! :)
Keep up the good work Duke. ~Adreius
Thanks a lot Adreius! Will try my best not to disappoint you! :D
I feel a nice infographic would be awesome once you have released all your videos - a form of a cheat sheet based on which attributes your weapons are using.
Yeah, already up for consideration! My current versions are still a bit messy for the public eye and I want to make sure I have the correct numbers on launch first!
Hey u/DukeSloth, if you're interested of course, I would love to see how threat will scale with damage. As a tank I do like the idea of going full con, but I'm wondering how it would affect threat generation. However, I could also just put more points into strength if my threat generation is not sufficient..
That is a really interesting question! Unfortunately it's something I couldn't look into yet, but I wrote it down for after launch. From my experience so far, it's very to hold aggro as long as you have a taunt gem. I ran full con with a medium level taunt gem and never had any issues tanking at all. Bonus point if you get a weapon with the chain damage perk so you can aoe aggro things!
But yeah, will definitely try it more in-depth after launch, super good idea - thanks for that!!
I'm watching your videos since a few days and you are doing great work. Thanks for your efforts and all the information. Keep it up like that👌🏻
Thanks a lot, really appreciate that :) And you've got the right name to go with, too, haha!
But with food and potions giving percentage based health gains, boosting CON gives soo much boosted healing from those sources- without considering the perk that increases them.
That doesn't matter as long as both have that % heal. Since it would both take equal amounts of time to get through the extra health, proportional to their damage! It makes a difference in asymmetrical scenarios though, like 2v1s
I would say that the majority of PvP scenarios in NW will be asymmetrical but I fully expect that we will see groups specializing instead of having everyone just do the same thing. Some CC/tanks/healers with high con and some high mobility high DPS builds to complement them. Our understanding of the game and tactics is pretty basic right now and high-skill high-DPS players should be able to win out in a lot of fights simply because they are very difficult to pin down and do damage to. Having those sort of players with some high con tanks to screen and CC I think will win out in a lot of scenarios, assuming the Axe + life staff build that just does everything well is nerfed.
I definitely agree. Have been talking to a few hardcore PvP companies and I've heard of a few very interesting different tactics they've come up with, so we'll see which one makes it though!
I'm excited to see the game develop! I hope we get a nice and diverse PvP landscape.
Thank you so much for this. I wanted to roll S&S/spear as my groups tank. I was struggling with the 3 stat split.
Thank you! Given your weapon choices, I'm assuming this is mainly for PvE? Because in that case, I'd recommend a much higher emphasis on con. The 250 con perk is amazing for tanking and as a main tank, you're not as concerned with the ideal ratio of health to damage as you are with surviving big hits. Those things are mainly relevant in PvP.
Hybrid pvp and pve. I know this setup might not be meta, but I really enjoyed it during closed beta. I like the spears CC and utility and obviously S&S for taking.
Ah, fingers crossed that the spear animations see some improvements before launch then!
In that case I'd definitely use a mixed distribution, I'd put a high emphasis on the 250 con perk though. Might be worth aiming for that first and then switch once you have more points from armor to distribute elsewhere. The 250 con perk (unless nerfed) makes PvE tanking way, way easier if you have a decent healer. Well, not that tanking in NW has been particularly hard so far, anyways.
Thanks for the suggestion!
[removed]
Haven't watched the video yet but how does this compare to TheeDuelist's videos especially the one where he said Con is king and everyone should go max con for PvP.
Hm, are you sure he said it like that? I actually was on Duelists stream the other day and the stat distributions he suggests at level 60 are similar to mine here, with differences mostly being focused on specific attributes. Duelist says to dump all your points in con until level 40-50 ish for max PvP advantage due to the broken low level scaling, which I agree with!
Got confused with an older stream from closed beta. I watched your video and Duelist newer vids and got an updated answer. Thanks for the content and the response. Good stuff man.
Ah no worries! Thanks a lot!
Btw, duelist also has an extensive datasheet that covers his opinion on optimal level 60 distributions which you access if you sub to him on twitch, in case you're interested.
With my experience on the beta what I found that made con so potent wasn’t as present in duels and it was more so in open world.
The moment health potions came into play and combined with passive healing from food thats where con started pulling away, the advantage they had seemed to get larger the longer the fight went on as well
If both players use them, health pots are actually in favor of the lower con player (excluding 50 point effect), since they have a flat increase component! Different story in 1vX though
Wait don’t they heal off based on a % of hp?
so wouldn’t it scale better with the more hp that you have and the same with regen?
According to nwdb.info, they currently have a % component and a flat component, the flat component being the one that increases with higher tier pots.
Not sure I'm following your idea here. Effective hp-wise, a lower max health player with higher damage benefits more from flat heals than a higher max health player with less dmg.
So I may have been misinformed but I was under the impression that potions were based on a % of your HP, if it is the case that it’s a % based heal + a flat heal then wouldn’t the higher HP pool still get some advantage out of healing pots?
Like for example if you have player A with 5k hp and player B with 10k hp and a healing point did something like a 20% heal + 1k wouldn’t it end up being something like this Player A gets 2k HP back (1k for 20% heal and 1k flat healing). Player B gets 3k HP back (2k for 20%, 1k flat heal) So overall the higher hp would have more benefit from healing potions
then i guess you’d also have base HP regen from food, if that’s like 1% hp a second or something someone with 5k hp would get like 3k back a minute but someone with 10k would get back 6k in a minute.
I’m not 100% sure on all the values though hence why I just used easy to digest numbers and I’m no math pro for sure.
Sick vids by the way, spread sheet porn
So this is what my teacher ment when she said I would need math later in life
Hahaha, I literally was talking about that to my partner the other day! :D Then again, a proper Excel class probably would've helped me more than school maths. So much about "You won't always have a calculator on you"
Reminds me of a ted talk I saw a few years ago where the guy argued that we should change the way we reach upper level math. Essentially he argued excess derivation was pointless when computers can do it for you. Instead we should teach derivation, but focus on computer solving more complex problems.
Would make a lot of sense in my eyes. If feel like I don't recall most of the advanced mathematical problem-solving from my school days either way and almost every New World theorycrafter I came across so far is either an Excel Wizard or can code.
You clearly did not play Path of Exile huh
You usually don't need much maths when you have POB.