Nerfs & Fixes I'd Like To See In The New World Open Beta - Life Staff, Hatchet, Great Axe, Stamina & more!

Video

Posted Sep 2, 2021, 12:44 AM UTC

053
Ok_Coyote_4309•

Honestly, I don't want any bs animation cancelling. It gives players that know the trick, aka exploit, way too much of an advantage.

11
BoomerQuest•

This is nonsense, players who know more will always have a massive advantage over players who know less. You can't protect bad players from good players. Bad players are supposed to lose to good players.

3†
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

I obviously agree with the general notion of that, but the question of how far you want to take obscure mechanics is still worth debating. Looking at combat-intense games like for example Chivalry or Mordhau, they had different approaches to solve these types of mechanical outliers. While neither of them is perfect, high level combat on the highest level in one of them still requires you to face and swing in the direction of your enemy, while the other requires you to swing your camera in obscure patterns instead. I think mechanical knowledge should give you a very significant advantage, but I personally am not a big fan of entirely hands-off approaches to niche mechanics balance. Especially since it often makes combat look stupid to newcomers and spectators.

2
Ok_Coyote_4309•

total bs. Good players are better than bad players so we should leave in unintuitive tricks that give them an overwhelming advantage?

Also, what you know should be derived from playing with the game. It should not be unintuitive tricks, aka exploits, learned on a messaging board

If you're actually a good player you won't need such a handicap against the "bad" players.

-2†
BoomerQuest•

The game is full of things that people 99.9% of players won't learn from playing the game.

How long is the invul on my roll?

How much damage mitigation does armor provide?

How do diminishing returns work with my stat allocation?

I bet you can't answer any of these. Informed players will always have an advantage over uninformed players and the most informed players get their information from better sources than just playing.

4
itsmysecondday•

Knowing the stats and timings of game mechanics is very different than know how to exploit an animation glitch. That bug must be fix, it was very very very obviously unintended behavior and bugged, using it is the same as using a glitch/exploit to gain an advantage.

5
Ok_Coyote_4309•

The game is full of things that people 99.9% of players won't learn from playing the game.

ok kiddo... lol

still not a valid argument btw

-1
Comrade_Witchhunt•

Heya Sloth, I disagree about the hatchet since I like the build variety even if it is strong.

Graxe needs fixed and nerfed, both, I suspect.

Con scaling at low levels should be more predictable, but it won't really matter long term I don't think.

Syndicate needs the better gear, they're poop. In seriousness, I think they'll fix it properly.

Covenant IS the best faction.

Consumables are a choice. If you farm em, you should be able to use them. If you can't catch someone when eating, that's a weakness of your build imo. In pve, idgaf personally, it's not competitive so idc.

I suspect the immortality DR is fixed, cuz that's a huge fuckup. I also agree with the armor weight criticism, because they have all these light armor sets that no one will ever see if they're playing optimally.

If you sheathe your weapon, you lose the ability to use light and heavies until you unsheathe or use a spell. I don't mind that cost, and it's bitten me in the ass before personally.

I could see tuning the dodge to be different, but I feel like a lot of the complaints come from melee who can't catch ranged with bad weapon combos and general "new player" problems. Maybe I'm wrong, idk.

Fix life staff. Please. We need more sources of disease and Lifestaff shouldn't purge debuffs on heavies, which is dumb as hell. Why let a weapon freely remove the one thing that is designed to counter it??

Copied from YT cuz I'm lazy but I want others to see as well.

5
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Agreed with most points!

The Core Gaming had the suggestion to only make Berserk heal while dealing damage, that could also be a potential solution. But I honestly I think it'll probably at least need a flat modifier in there somewhere if it doesn't have one yet, like the health pots also have a % and a flat healing. Tank Berserk felt like playing the game on easy mode, especially in PvE.

The sheathe preventing you from attacking isn't really an issue since usually it's used to create a lot of distance very quickly anyways and then you have enough time to get your weapon back out. I don't think having it overwrite an intended post-animation every time it's used is a good idea.

The high level PvPers I've talked to so far also seem to think that especially stam regen at 0 stam is an issue. Anecdotal of course, maybe some others don't. Between that and the dodge animation cancel, infinite kiting is just a bit too easy with some builds.

1
Comrade_Witchhunt•

Tank Berserk felt like playing the game on easy mode, especially in PvE.

Yeah, I felt that way about tank anything tbh.

I like the idea of just giving them massive lifesteal during berserk, eliminates the "berserk as a way to run away and heal" strat.

stam regen at 0 stam is an issue.

It's definitely a design choice, idk if it's the right one or not. Right now, it benefits me so I like it.

infinite kiting is just a bit too easy with some builds

Fire Ice light reporting in

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

I was gonna give you a pass if you at least ran bow, so you'd have a reason to need to all that :P

2
Comrade_Witchhunt•

I know, I'm a dirty, dirty WIZARD

2
Snydenthur•

the dodge animation cancel

This is the actual problem, not the stamina regen. When they fix it, the game will become a lot better (except for it slowing down the general running around).

At the same time, though, they need to buff light weight or everyone will be running 4 medium 1 heavy with the exception of tanks who need to run all heavy.

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

I think both play a role. To me, it's not intuitive that intentionally draining your stamina is being rewarded while carefully managing is punished. It could also solve the triple roll spam if you were rewarded for keeping a bit of your stam.

2
Snydenthur•

Well technically it doesn't reward you. If you fully empty your stamina, you do have a brief time when you can't dodge/block at all, while having some left means you can always dodge/block.

I just feel that if stamina gets nerfed, fights become pretty boring. Once they fix the dodge animation cancel, you can't use dodge as mobility which just fixes the main problem of dodging.

1
Ok_Coyote_4309•

Also a huge buff to dex. And huge nerf to light armor, which is already crap.

1
Teohtime•

The Core Gaming had the suggestion to only make Berserk heal while dealing damage

That's a pretty fuzzy condition that doesn't translate well into game mechanics. The way I'd do it is to have the Berserk heal only heal when below 50% life, and stop healing once you reach 50% life. This would mean a player relying only on Berserk healing is running around at half health all the time and would fit with the Berserk tree theme of taking risks on low life for high payoff, along with the cheat death mechanic.

Stamina, rolling and sprinting changes since the preview are a real mess and leave us with a game where melee can't realistically fight anybody who is running or kiting, unless you have Greataxe tier tracking and chasing. The melee mechanics weren't designed for a game with perma-sprint, infinite stamina and no roll recovery. So the sheathe/weapswap cancel at the end of a roll causes gameplay issues because it prevents melee from punishing a roll. Even if you're fully aware that the other player is about to roll and you aren't stuck in an animation, you still can't catch it with anything shy of GA Reap. Then after rolling themselves out of stamina the escaping player still gets to sprint at full speed while "Exhausted" and recovers all of their stamina immediately. It's a disaster of a design that removes any notion of stamina management and breaks the balance of melee vs ranged.

There are lots of different ways you could approach that problem and in an ideal world we'd just go all the way back to Preview mechanics, but if you asked me for the most obvious low effort change you could make to address those issues I would say: Disable sprint while exhausted and for a half to one second period after rolling so that players walk during the weapswap cancel.

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

That's a pretty fuzzy condition that doesn't translate well into game mechanics.

Why? You could literally make it very high onhit lifesteal.

Agreed on your stam/rolling take.

0
KarstXT•

I'm concerned about them adjusting armor weights because atm, despite being 'odd', the system works really well. The game is fun and interesting and has a variety of builds. Furthermore, we don't necessarily want an actual full heavy armor in the game because its kind of a lower skill build (dodging takes skill whereas heavy armor granting more mit does not) as we can see with similar builds in souls games.

If they want to adjust armor weights, they'd need to buff the armor values on light & medium without buffing heavy, otherwise we will see a meta where everyone just goes full heavy anyways. Currently the value proposition for lower armor values just isn't there. Full light for example simply cannot be an option because you will get 1-shot to things like powder burn. It just isn't an option and I don't think full medium would be either.

1
Ok_Coyote_4309•

the system works really well.

lol no

light armor is nigh worthless

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Hm, my reason for different armor weights was the same as your reason against. I basically only saw 3 types of loadouts among level 60s: A bunch of medium armor that keeps you right below medium cap or a bunch of heavy armor that keeps you right under heavy cap. And then the occasional very heavy life staff user. Actual light armor seemed very neglected overall.

I can't see everyone going full heavy when the light dodge would allow mages to create so much distance and spam attacks. Getting oneshot is probably better solved through speccing into some Con, which PvPers will likely inevitably do.

0
KarstXT•

In the current system they would have to buff the light armor for it to be usable though. Changing weights wouldn't be enough, light armor is simply far too squishy to be a viable option.

I can't see everyone going full heavy when the light dodge would allow mages to create so much distance and spam attacks. Getting oneshot is probably better solved through speccing into some Con, which PvPers will likely inevitably do.

I don't think you realize how squishy you are with full light, even with con. One or two heavy guys with muskets would invalidate all the light users. Musket damage being essentially unavoidable creates a minimum tankiness players much achieve which is not met with full light.

1
Ok_Coyote_4309•

Id rather it be buffed than worthless

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Ok_Coyote_4309•

For example Dead by Daylight dev team balances for mid skill people so low skill survivors won't quit the game. But at the highest level survivor players are the strongest. It's hard to balance for casuals and high skill players.

y is this bad? mmos are inherently unbalanced. this isn't a competitive pvp game

1
whitebandit•

this isn't a competitive pvp game

you are saying a game where factions are warring in pvp battles for territory control... isnt competitive? are you mental?

2
Ok_Coyote_4309•

no, it's more like playing basketball with your friends and not keeping score.

This isn't a serious competition because it's inherently unbalanced.

1
Nathyiel:blue: New Worldian but in blue•

good point. I'm ok with most of it.

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thank you!

0
nanosam•

Games that have everything perfectly balanced are boring as shit.

That's the downside, I'd rather play a fun game that is not balanced 100% - but that's just me.

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

I don't disagree with that, at all. But I also don't think a meta where everyone and their mother runs life staff is fun.

1
nanosam•

There should be alternatives to life staff, I agree with that 100%.

2
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Then we are in full agreement, haha! I've seen imbalanced games and balanced games have their ups and downs and especially from a content creator perspective, there's a lot more fun stuff to make (and break) than when everything is perfectly balanced.

1
jetfaceRPx•

I'd be happy if youtubers stayed on the tube and left reddit alone. But that's not going to happen. Much like this wish list. I didn't watch it but I assume its a bunch of opinions from someone who starts off with, "hey guys".

-3†
Fara_ven•

I'd be happy if youtubers stayed on the tube and left reddit alone.

You might aswell lock yourself in a room with no computer if you like echo chambers this much

4
jetfaceRPx•

Am I allowed to talk to other people in real life or are reddit and youtube the only acceptable forms of communication?

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

The day I unironically start a video with "hey guys" is the day I voluntarily stick my neck in guillotine. Bold of you to state that this wish list isn't going to happen when you don't know what's on it though. I'm fairly confident that multiple of these things will be addressed, since some of them have been brought up by the New World devs already.

1
BoomerQuest•

The proper way to start a YouTube video: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0O2aH4XLbto

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Haha, I dig it!

1
jetfaceRPx•

Best of luck and please stay away from unirony. The San Francisco treat.

-1