r/Guitar•
HashPram

[Question] Microtonal guitar fretboards

OK, so here's something that just struck me as a bit odd.

​

I know that the reason the guitar has frets is historical: It evolved from instruments that also had frets.

​

Originally those frets were movable (they were gut wraps placed around the neck), over time they became fixed. Meanwhile: Over time 12-tone equal temperament tuning became the standard temperament. Result: The modern guitar.

​

I've seen quite a few videos of people experimenting with microtonality, but the one thing that always strikes me about microtonal guitars is that the fretboards look like a fucking nightmare to work with. I have, admittedly, never played one of these guitars so it may be considerably easier to work with than it looks, but, well I just think it looks like an ugly solution.

​

So here's my question.

​

Why not just take the frets off?

​

No frets = whatever microtonal inflections you like.

​

The fretboard is far less busy.

​

Sure you have to do what orchestral string players do and just learn where the notes are, but - being trained on a standard guitar - you'll have a pretty decent idea already and there's nothing to stop the manufacturer sticking a line of fret markers up the side of the neck.

​

There must be a reason why this hasn't been tried - I can't possibly be the first person that's had this idea. Or maybe it has been tried and I'm just woefully under-informed.

​

Why the choice for increasing complication in favour of simplification?

​

What are the trade-offs here?

​

I should say I'm don't hate microtonal guitars, or microtonality in general - I'm not having a go - I'm just a bit confused.

Posted Sep 3, 2021, 7:54 AM UTC

19
relentlessappleMartin•

Fretless guitars already exist

4
HashPramOP•

Sure. Just interested in the reason why one might choose to make one over the other.

1
relentlessappleMartin•

Hard to get the same sound twice and fretless would require a lot more concentration

2
Jorbseph•

The trade off is that I can't play tasty, cliche blues licks on a fretless guitar.

2

I am currently working on refretting some guitar necks and I also own a fretless guitar. The reason I am doing both is mainly for muscle memory. To a lot of people a fretless guitar has horrible intonation because it relies on one's finger instead of the frets to make the note, and it also takes a lot of practice and knowledge to get the notes accurately on a fretless. Chords are a massive problem on a fretless for the above reason.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
WolfySpiceIbanez RG2228 / .strandberg* Boden Prog 7•

They want to play in a different temperament consistently. Also, frets sound completely different to fretless.

1
bakaiser420•

It's harder to play certain chords on fretless but if you wanted to try you can buy a neck from warmoth. You can select fretless as an option when you order a custom neck.

1
stmbtspns•

It is very very difficult to accurately play full chords on a fretless guitar. It would end up being better at melody notes than chords, and music already had that in spades with the violin and cello. Those could both do anything a fretless guitar could do, but those instruments could never do chords and strum like a guitar with frets would.

1
STU_MORPHO•

Why the choice for increasing complication in favour of simplification?

I see it the opposite way, where trying to accurately play microtonal riffs on a fretless guitar would be needlessly complicated compared to having the octave division laid out perfectly with additional frets. The precision required to accurately play quarter tones, for example, would just not be reasonable

1