Int/Focus gems are broken in a really bad way. A summary of our findings so far.

Video

Posted Sep 3, 2021, 10:21 PM UTC

2648
Dabuxx•

Quick example with INT gem while maxing INT:

tier 2 cut flawed amethyst converts 20% of dmg, scales 200% of INT.

Lets say you have 100dmg from INT(or just say 100int with 1 dmg per 1 attribute just to make things easier to understand)

100 * 0,2(20% conversion) = 20
20 is converted, 80 is not
20 * 2 (200% scaling) = 40
20 converted with scaling = 40
80 not converted + 40 converted with scaling = 120dmg 
120>100, ez 20% dmg boost hihi.

tier 3 amethyst gem 30% convert, 133.35 % scaling:

30*1.3335 = 40.005dmg
70 + 40.005 = 110.005 -> 10% dmg boost hihi

tier 5 gem 50% conversion 80% scaling

50*0.8 = 40
50 + 40 = 90 --> losing 10% dmg

​

I didn't say anything about splitting dmg from fire to viod or some other type, cuz its not about that. This example works with fire staff and ice gauntlet.

7
Snydenthur•

Damn, if this is a real thing, I don't even know what to trust in-game anymore.

2
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

According to our findings, it's not quite that simple and there seem to be further modifiers beforehand, so it's not applied 1:1, but it's close. I didn't got deeper into the numbers because they're so shaky and I'm done twisting my brain about it until it's fixed :D

2†
Dabuxx•

Of course it's not 1:1, I just used it to to make it simple. It depends on primary weapon DMG and scaling and diminishing returns, but it's calculated like this, and numbers won't change cuz multiplying by something on each side still results in same number. Percentages should stay the same even if you use attribute scaling. Cuz you have to use same attribute scaling with gem or without gem. That's what I am saying.

4
SnooOnions7505•

THAT was simple???

2
MrPrayer•

Let's actually get full dmg formula into account (or something close to it):
BaseDamage*(1+(PlayerLevel-1)*0.025+((1-GemCoef)*PrimaryAttrScaling+GemCoef*GemScaling*ConvertedAttrScaling)/100)

This should be the damage before all other buffs, but those should be multipliers.

So lvl10 player who put all 18 available points into INT and used Abyssal I buff on a weapon with 100 base dmg will get 158.14 of full dmg vs 152.2 without 200% gem scaling, a 3.9% increase. Lvl36 player with 93 points will get 9% increase in the same scenario.

9% is a good number, but you're using a gem slot, and by lvl36 you would get to use at least tier 3 gems, which will give you 8-20% increase depending on the situation. Doesn't seem all that broken, but i don't think it's an intended usecase.

Now when it comes to using gems for attribute conversion, scaling diminishes with higher tiers, and you basically get a constant 0.4 multiplier on converted dmg scaling throughout all tiers. Now this doesn't look right to me.

Of course, all this applies if this gem scaling number is actually a multiplier and not a threshold for choice of scaling attribute (base weapon stat or conversion attr).
I haven't seen any of raw data.

2
Dabuxx•

what is base dmg and what is full dmg? Please put in numbers when you are doing examples so we know you didn't make mistake in math. Also saying "something close to it" in math is very dangerous, cuz you can just use some Bulgarian constant to get your results, meanwhile it can be far from real formula. In my example I used math according to the description of the perk, so:

Abyssal I:

20% of damage is converted to Void. Damage scales off base weapon stat or INT, whichever is higher.

Scales with Intelligence 200%

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ogzogz•

Checking out this theory in open beta - sorry for replying to 8d old msg but I wanted to clarify.

​

When the 20% is scaled with INT at 200%. Do you multiple your INT by 200%, then apply the attribute scaling factor on the new int (which diminishes as you go) or you ignore the attribute diminishing factor and just get INT * 2 as the bonus?

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Diminishing returns still apply

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Ahoy!

I know that some of you have been waiting for my gem video, so this the preliminary result of that. I hope this topic is relevant/new to some of you, since at this point I've spent a ton of time with alpha players who were already familiar with this for a while - so if you already knew about the gem scaling issues, this may not offer that many new things to you. I couldn't find any other posts about it via search bar.

I'd also like to thank the guys from NWDB for their help with my questions regarding this!

Since the theorycrafters have figured out the formulas now, the rest of the puzzle should be very easy to solve once after the beta if we end up seeing changes/fixes to this, in which case I'll make a more in-depth update.

6
StrawberryBalloons•

I checked the nwdb site ams couldn't find the info for int scaling on gems, you mentioned 200% and 80% ones on the video and I would like to know what gems values are inbetween

1
piscuj•
3
StrawberryBalloons•

Awesome thank you, I checked the fire gems earlier and couldn't see any

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Since u/piscuj already linked it, just an interesting addition from my end: As you can see, the T4 gem actually scales properly, so that's the one you can actually get expected results with at the moment.

1
olivierpo•

Ok I thought there was some weird stuff going on with gems! I'm no big theorycrafter myself, but I did do a bunch of tests in the CBT to compare gems and HOLY MOLY none of the numbers added up.

In no world should an elemental conversion gem do more damage in all scenarios than the conditional gems (max health, max stam, etc.), but that's what I was seeing! On targets that had armor and elemental resistances equaled, the conditional gems should always outdamage elemental conversion gems when their conditions are met, or there will never be a use for them.

 

That being said I love the weapon trail effects on my musket from the elemental gems... so I won't be that upset if they stay really strong.

Good video! I look forward to your update in open Beta/after release!

4
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Absolutely agree with that. The ele gems should be a way to improve your stats with non-ideal weapon combos at a cost, not outscale offensive gems - which to be fair is primarily an issue with the 20% gems.

And yeah, they do look really cool on any weapon! Especially the bows imo, where the whole weapon glows from the effects.

Thanks a lot!

4
olivierpo•

No problem! My musket's barrel also had the glow! So cool!

I also forgot to add that when I was doing my tests, I was full Dex using T4 INT scaling gems. So the damage numbers make even less sense. Not to mention that when I changed my attributes to 2:1 Dex/Int, the damage was even nuttier.

2
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Huh, that's odd. The rapier tests that I had showed slightly less damage on T5 and it scales the same as musket. The int increase I can explain though: The 50 and 150 int perk both amplify the elemental damage! The other part is probably not worth overthinking unless they don't fix it. May have been a type advantage or a target with low elemental resist, depending on what you were attacking?

1
NLP_Onyx:white: Rapier and Bow or else•

Likely because type advantage or physical resistance to thrust damage. All of my tests came back as expected when I did them against other players.

2
NLP_Onyx:white: Rapier and Bow or else•

Why wouldn't they do more damage? I would think overall they'd do more dps, not more conditional damage, which if I am understanding you right, is exactly what happened. Ele conversion gems are DEFINITELY offensive gems.

Think about the application of the gems and what they do. Converting part of your damage to elemental rather than physical is HUGE for your overall dps, in all scenarios. It has 100% up time, never reduces your actual damage output (just converts it if INT<base), and is actively spreading your damage type into 50/50 phys/ele with a T5 gem. Some monsters will have varying levels of resistance to either, and to ensure you have the ability to bypass heavy physical resistances (in most cases), using ele conversion gems is absolutely ideal.

The other conditional damage gems are adding insignificant damage in comparison because they aren't affecting your base damage scaling. Base damage scaling is MUCH more effective than an additive bonus because the remaining damage calculations happen AFTER the base damage scaling occurs.

1
olivierpo•

That's why I said damage, and not dps. The full health gem was doing less damage to a full health target than the conversion gem. Now, to be fair I was testing on a training dummy whose resistances I don't know. Theoretically however, training dummies should have no resistances unless AGS made an oversight and invalidated training dummies as an easy-to-use testing opponent.

1
NLP_Onyx:white: Rapier and Bow or else•

What was your INT when you beat up the dummies?

1
olivierpo•

Close to whatever the minimum is. I didn't have any int buffs with food and I maybe had some INT off of ring or amulet but none on my gear proper.

1
Snydenthur•

The big problem is, though, that the "normal" gems just suck. When the best gems are either damage against full health target or damage against enemy under 30% health, depending on what content you're doing, you know gems overall are so meaningless.

0
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Imo % dmg while not full stam is great for PvP

3
RIVsprk•

I tried doing some math with this. I'm no mathematician though so i probably messed up tbh.. so i looked at a video of light attacks with a low tier gem on a rapier. took the physical damage then worked out what the 20% would be if the physical was the remaining 80%. Then i multiplied it by 200%. The result was super close to the elemental damage every time but off by a small amount.. i only ran in to trouble when i tried on the mid tier 30% gem. the elemental damage came out to be twice as much as i got with my result. so sod it. i shall leave it up to folks who know what they are doing lol

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Yeah, had similar issues. You can't quite apply the modifier 1:1 from what I can tell, the calculation seems to be more complex, which is why I left it out. But the result ends up skewed either way.

1
RIVsprk•

I feel like itll be more of a tooltip/communication issue than anything else. If some of the weapon skill tooltips are any sort of example. Though I would be interested to see if the gems are indeed broken somehow.

1
Nathyiel:blue: New Worldian but in blue•

I suspect math to be a little more complicated ans the increase to not be a full +20%.

if the purpose is for those gem to provide a small damage increase, then it should do it with a biger scaling for the best game..

in fact, they don't need to change the damage ratio at all. with a 120% scaling, it will increase by 4 % for t1 gem and 10% for t5 gem

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

That's is correct, the math is more complicated and messy, but the outcome also isn't drastically different from those numbers!

I don't think the intent is for the int/Foc gems to provide a damage boost. They already give you a boost in some scenarios by changing your damage type and allow for different specs to be more effective. Any more beyond that and they easily outclass all other gems.

1
ogzogz•

Thanks, we were confused As F when trying ot test what these gems did. Now it makes more sense (although still confusing)

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Glad it brought some sense into it! But yeah, even after days with the data, it's still confusing :D

1
pojzon_poe•

Doesn't that mean that Amber 20% gems are the best dmg gems in the game due to built in resistances to elements in enemies ? (PvE)

Looking at physical resistances those are a lot lower than elemental resistances and Nature is the only element that doesnt have resistances built in enemies.

So doing pure phys + 20% focus while scaling weapon dmg and focus in ratio: 10:9 would result in best PvE dps of all possible weapon types ?

Demn if healers needed even more boost in PvE lol, I could already solo elite bosses ~45lv.

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

I only vaguely glanced at the elemental pve modifiers in the context of this tbh. I suppose it depends a lot on what targets you're going for, so I find it hard to generalize PvE dps. Averaged out, maybe. But if I'm running an expedition full of skeletons, I'd still rather have a war hammer than a great axe with an amber gem and fortunately, we have that flexibility.

Hopefully healers will see some nerfs, they need em :D

0
pojzon_poe•

Do you really think someone is going to change weapon gems to match specific dungeon monsters ? Bosses still have a mixture of few resistances.

And nature is the only element that doesn't have very resisting monsters.

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

No, I don't think they will change gems, I think they will change weapons instead of trying to balance things out via gems. I guess this is mostly referring to melee players who have that choice, but since the current multipliers for type advantage are extremely strong (apparently multiplied after everything else), I see no reason why for example anyone would run Lazarus with a Great Axe or Edengrove with a War Hammer when they could just swap without respeccing for massive damage type advantage. The type advantage makes a much bigger diff than a sightly higher gear score on one of the weapons would.

I guess ranged users that don't have that option will eventually have dungeon-specific gem weapons to maximize type advantage. So they wouldn't swap gems, but weapons instead.

Just my current speculation anyways, also depends on how strong type advantages will be on launch.

1
pojzon_poe•

My question was rather about: "Does it make sense tho?"

  • You want highest GS to always get best drops from enemies (GS influences drop you get)
  • With faction gear you are already able to do all dungeons in their current form (they are optimized for suboptimal casuals)
  • You can run them only once per day/week even if you pull the keys from everyone in the party, its tops 2-3h of runs (in suboptimal gear)

Im mostly curious whether ppl are going to optimize when there is not much difference.

1

I’m confused… can someone ELI5? Maybe actual numbers would help me?

Cuz for me, much like you guys, I underwent some extensive testing and here were my results:

Lvl 25ish? Testing hatchet: I was pretty much full focus and used a hatchet. No-Gem: i did 1 slash against 1 mob, Hit for 197. I then socketed my gem. With 20% foc gem: I did one slash against same mob, hit for 180+43 = ~220 total.

I took ~20/~200 and got a ~10% increase in actual damage, called it a day and went back to ignoring numbers.

150ish gold off of trading post for an instant 10% increase? Deal. Works for me.

*This was all based off memory. **to be clear, my “extensive testing” was doing 1 test, 1 time, with 1 weapon.

So is this bad or good? I mean, did anyone really think they were gonna get a full 20% (or whatever %) damage boost with a weapon they’re not really supposed to be using?

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

It's bad. You're not meant to get a damage increase from gems, just a damage conversion (which can already lead to an increase via type advantage or lower elemental resist). But the low tier gems currently - as you correctly found - provide an increase (exact increase depends on weapon). The 40% gem does what the gems are likely intended to do, which is simply converting your damage and scaling it with another attribute. The 50% gem actually converts damage at a decreased rate.

Edit: Hold on, that was not an ELI5, let's try again:

Little stones sometimes do more hurties than they should and sometimes less hurties, depending on the size of the stone. Normally, all stones should be doing the same hurties.

2