Umbridge was right to ban Harry and the twins from playing quidditch.

They were completely out of control - the second someone said something mean about them or someone they cared about, they immediately turned to violence.

Even in circumstances where they were obviously being provoked to draw that exact reaction, they still couldn't help themselves.

Posted Sep 6, 2021, 8:25 PM UTC

36
schright_dwute•

Any opinion defending Umbridge is automatically invalid

6
Rickybobby1118•

Yea she is a total bitch! They casted her well in the movie

3
requiemofchaos•

Imelda Staunton should've gotten an award for her performance in Order of the Phoenix. Pretty much every casting decision in the Potter films was a good one, but she absolutely stole the show in that movie (and would've done so even if OotP wasn't the weakest overall film in the series).

6
Rickybobby1118•

I agree she was absolutely amazing!

3
MrsMaiselsBrisket•

She banned them for life, though. I can see a month or the next game or a semester - but life?

5
Throwaway983766•

Personally, I don't think this is THAT bad, it was a nuclear reaction to ban them for life but not totally unreasonable, I think its more because everything else she did was so fucked up, and as a result, any words defending any one of her actions would be met with backlash no matter what it is. Its more about the person than the actual action in this case, or that's how most people see it anyway

2