[40K] Returning Player; Where do the armies sit currently?

I'm considering coming back to Warhammer after a rather long absence, and I was wondering how each army sat compared to each other. GW has always been horrible at balancing, so im not expecting a level playing field suddenly, but I was wondering what was the current meta in tournies and the like.

TLDR: What are the top tier armies currently, and what are the lower tier armies? [When you're talking about a tournament setting]

Posted Feb 10, 2012, 11:51 AM UTC

1161
laserplane•

♪GREEN IS BEST♪ ♪SMASH DA REST♪ STUPID HUMIES

18
Grizzly_Adams•

RED WUNZ GO FASTA!

3
Kreenshaw•

Orkses is never defeated in battle. If we win we win, if we die we die fighting so it don't count. If we runs for it we don't loose neither, cos we can come back for annuver go, see!

13
Atramentous•

This is a fantastic example of Ork logic. Thank you.

3
volpes•

Fwiw, it's a quote from the codex. A great quote, but not original writing.

5
frest•

The only armies that are really subpar right now are Tau and Craftworld Eldar. Everything else can compete. Even Tau and Eldar aren't completely helpless, they're just really showing their age.

5
whiteknight521•

Eldar subpar? My warwalker scatterlaser squad would have something to say about that... :P

1
frest•

So you agree that the codex is fine if you ignore the large majority of units that cost too much for too little, and instead only focus on the few models that remain good bargains?

Eldar have a few things that work right now, jetbike seer councils and war walkers. Every army seems to be shitting autocannons now, which puts their tanks in a bad place. Even so they're still not BAD, just have to work a lot harder than a newer army for the same results.

2
Rustymonkey•

Yeah they are pretty subpar. Like frest said, having one competitive build is not a mark of a good codex. That and the aspect warriors (barring Dragons of course), wraith units and defender guardians all range from bad to worse. That leaves with only a few good units so... yeah thats sub-par. Tau are the same with a single good build and nothing else.

1
whiteknight521•

I just played a 1750 game against Space Wolves last night and I have to say how completely right you are. My entire army was effectively crippled after turn 1, and that is with me deploying into cover as much as possible. There is not much in the entire game that can withstand 15 missile shots a turn at BS4. An entire IG mech list would be wiped out on turn 1, it is utterly ridiculous. I am going to go back to fantasy until the Eldar codex is updated - even against a nasty Skaven list High Elves can survive past turn 1.

1
acidix•

What I've heard over and over is that, tau and eldar are bad generally because they have only one viable army choice in competetive play. In beer and pretzel games, they're all the same because you arent looking at hypercompetetive tuned lists.

1
frest•

I agree with this. But if we're talking about games where you don't care if you win or lose, why do we care about about relative army strength? The whole thread is discussing

what was the current meta in tournies and the like.

1
Mr_E•

I whole-heartedly disagree with your statement that Tyranids can compete against the current Mech spam thats prevalent in almost all fields of tournament play. In fact, both your bottom-tier mentions are capable of better AT than tyranids.

1
frest•

See I don't think of Tyranids as being that bad, but I might be mistaken. No one plays them around me and they just got a new book, is it really that terrible? I thought it was just a reshuffling of which units were good and which were bad, with the Trygon and the Hive Guard being the good ones now or something.

2
Mr_E•

It is and it isn't. The problem is that a lot of our codex is now shit. Carnifexes are garbage (speaking from a comp perspective) as are warriors and every other MC we have. Our BEST unit for anti-tank is extremely over priced, and good luck trying to manage the elites slot.

There is also a ton of mediocrity in the book. Warriors, Shrikes, the Harpy, Old One Eye, Carnifexes.. someone really just screwed the pooch when pricing these things out points-wise. It's hard to justify taking any of these choices. Same with Biovores and that GOD AWFUL PYROVORE.

If you read none of this bitching but the following you'll be fine: My biggest complaint however is with the lack of living ammo and the removal of Immunity to Instant Death. A carnifex is a huge investment and will die to a powerfist. That seems passable until you think of it like it was a battle tank. Same points cost, very little firepower, and no AV. Depressing. Warriors are just depressing when you consider the amount of Strength 8 shooting involved in most armies now, and we NEED them.

Also all of our shooting is just pathetic. It's all horribly weak which was fine with living ammo, but now that we can't reroll, it's just abysmal.

Is it a bad army? Fuck no. I love them. Is it comp-worthy? Not in the current climate. In most cases you wind up spending half your points on trying to slow down other people's tanks, and if you're up against a totally mechanized opponent you're basically just standing around and waiting because good luck getting them out of their transports.

YOU CAN HOWEVER take an absolutely retarded cheap list and place giant 20+ wound units on top of objectives and laugh as Draigowing attempts to survive the literal tide of bodies to dislodge you from objectives.. though that isn't fun.

TL;DR The entire book doesn't seem to know what the fuck kind of army it wants to be, and the huge reliance on synergy that the army used to have is no more. Two big rules that helped us out (Immunity to ID and Living Ammo) were removed entirely but not replaced with anything.

3
frest•

I dunno, if we're talking about "which army will win at tournaments" then a cheap list that wins is by definition a competitive army. The old codex was just as bad, monstrous creature spam with outflanking genestealers was all I ever saw.

1
blackarmchair•

How are Tau subpar? Tau rape grey knights, necrons, and razorspam; true they fall apart when faced with certain match-ups but what army doesn't?

Tau are constantly misunderstood and underrated.

1
Mr_E•

How do tau rape grey knights when they can teleport onto an objective and dare you to try and 'come at them, bro' with their super retard amount of saves + psychic powers? Razorback spam even. You might have 5 rail guns in your army at 2k points? You kill 1 or 2 and then what? How do you push them off objectives when they deepstrike on them and keep you from doing the same with servoskulls? How do you even manage to outshoot them when they can do it.better than you? And if you aren't static gunline tau, you don't even really have a shot, no pun intended. Perhaps in your meta they're awesome. On a national level, they're crap. They don't place in tournaments because other armies do what they do better.

1
blackarmchair•

Uh....let me tell you why that's bullshit.

So, any Tau player worth his salt will not take less than 9x railguns in 2k. I realize that's not how they used to play but list comp has changed since Tau were popular. Between pathfinders, fireknives, and rail spam there's no excuse for razorspam to ever work.

Furthermore, Grey Knights play to Tau's strengths since Tau tend to have less of a torrent of fire and more high-quality, low-ap shots. A 26pt marine and a 55pt paladin means a lot more when it dies than a cheaper standard MEQ counterpart. Broadsides are such a hard counter to GK shooting it's not even funny, they outrange even dreads and with AP1 and markerlights even venerable isn't too likely to save you.

It might sound odd but we've playtested this a number of times and it most always comes out in the Tau's favor.

1
Mr_E•

I'm not saying you're wrong, but I also haven't played Tau personally in quite some time, nor played against them very recently. Can you explain how you get 9 rail guns in play? I really do want to know.

The second part of your comment I can believe. It sounds about right when you really think of it in a vacuum. Doesn't sound odd at all.

1
GreenElite87•

Eldar hoodwinking the topic, but how many units in GK come with invuln saves? My runes of warding seem like a fantastic counter to GK psychic spam when you're rolling 3d6 and periling on 12+, and double 1's.

1
alphawolf29•

I WANT FISH OF FURY BACK

1
4l4ric•

I would personally rank orks pretty low down as well, however have that may just be the local scene and how local people play with them. Do people in your area use them to much success?

0
frest•

No way, Green is best. Orks have some terrible options (tankbustas) but they're still a force to be reckoned with. Their model range is looking pretty good now, with plastic Nobs and Battlewagons.

3
4l4ric•

Ohhh not denying that their models look good. But there are only so many ways that they can be run, and against the current meta I just don't think they are that up to bar. Maybe the lower half of the mid tier if you are being friendly. How do you see people run them in your area?

1
Rustymonkey•

I'm in agreement with you about the orks being low... but maybe its just that my local ork players are pathetic lol

1
Rustymonkey•

Honestly, how I see it is that there are 3 real tiers:

Competitive Tier

  • Grey Knights
  • Dark Eldar
  • Space Wolves
  • Blood Angels
  • Codex: Space Marines
  • Imperial Guard
  • Necrons

In no particular order. As far as I see it, all these armies are well balanced and equally competitive if used correctly.

Limbo Tier

  • Tyranids
  • Sisters of Battle

Now these guys are 5th edition codecies (though "codex" may be too kind for SoB), but they have some glaring issues that keep them from being up top. Whether it be difficulty against mech for Tyranids or a lack of a cheap troop choice and unbalanced costing for the SoB. Both armies can do well, but aren't in the same league as the other 5th edition dexes.

All the Rest

  • Chaos Space Marines
  • Craftworld Eldar
  • Chaos Daemons
  • Tau
  • Orks

Now these guys have a bunch of issues in their armies that keep them from being very good. In most cases this is an issue of points costs and outdated rules. Another big issue is that while there may be a competitive build available, having only one in a book (looking at you Eldar and Tau) is a sign that the codex is bad no matter how you look at it. This makes sense because hey look, these dexes aren't 5th edition! These dexes can certainly win with the hands of a skilled player, but they will have a harder going to do so.

One thing to point out is that people will contend Orks need to be higher. I agree it is probably best of the rest, but honestly I have no idea what their capabilities are because I don't really play them. The two times I did face them ended up with huge victories in my favor, but again that's probably because of my opponents not the book itself so it probably should be in Limbo.

5
JimStyling•

Grey knights, mech guard, space wolves and blood angels seem to be the meta kings. Tyranids are seen as sub par, but with a new edition on the way this may be all different come July.

3
fredrikc•

What do you base the July prediction on?

1
cubemstr•

New edition apparently. There was a "leaked" rulebook that was met with simultaneous revulsion and excitement depending on where you felt the current problems with the game lies.

For people like me and my friends who think the problem is just poorly constructed codexs in one way or another, the "leaked rulebook" was like treating a paper cut by cutting off the arm and trying to shove a robot limb in its place.

For people who thought the main issue is the structure of the game, it was an exciting change that seemed to make the game play out more like it should. ie Acts of heroism, targets dodging shots etc.

Last I heard, the "leaked rulebook" was debunked as fake, but it sparked a lot of conversation among players about what they wanted and what "needs to change" in 6th edition.

2
Renthur•

Not totally debunked. It was the earliest draft where they told the balance/design team just go wild and make any changes you see fit.

1
fredrikc•

Yeah, I read about the leaked rulebook but I havn't read anything about July before...

1
Mr_E•

The release schedule has been speculated on. Were supposed to see books for dark angels early in the year, the new edition in the middle (july), and then CSM at the years close.

2
Mr_E•

The leak was an early experiment of the rules. GW said to their designers 'make a fantasy wishlist ruleset' as a way of drumming up new ideas. That's what we saw. There's NO chance if the new rules being close to that, but there may be some additions from those rules.

Evasion values are a big 'no go' by the way.

1
Mr_E•

Greyknights are at the top. Necrons a close second, space wolves and blood angels about that level as well. Tyranids are bottom of the barrel with Eldar and chaos occupying a space above them.

Ninja-Edit: Tau are trash too. Probably as bad as Eldar right now.

2
Jedimushroom•

I was under the impression that mech-guard was a top tier army as well. In fact before the GK release it was generally considered to be the strongest army IIRC.

1
Kreenshaw•

Not to say that you can't win with any of the armies listed below but generally IMHO:

A+: Grey knights, mech guard, space wolves, blood angels

B: Necrons, Orks, Dark Eldar, Eldar, Codex SM, Foot Guard

C: Chaos SM, Templars, Tau, Daemons of Chaos, Nids

D: Dark Angels (other than Deathwing FAQ armies they are b+) , SOB

4
LoneGamer•

You left Tyranids out.

1
Kreenshaw•

Thanks for telling me!

1
mophair•

Wouldn't a normal Dark Angels army be as good as the Codex Sm? I only have a DA codex so nothing to compare it to.

1
Kreenshaw•

Nope, In general DA got beaten with a hose. They were the prototype codex for the current SM codex. They were the testbed for the 5 or 10 no more no less format. Generic DA are actually better represented by the CSM. Actually until the FAQ, for the most part every aspect of the codex could be recreated, for fewer points/more effectively by CSM chapters.

Well unless you count Double Wing, But the Double wing army is an abomination! AKA Grumpy Old Scool DA player Rant....lol

1
sumopapisdn•

I have DoC, Nids Eldar and SOB.... GO ME!

1
Kreenshaw•

LOL please don't take that as me saying that they are unplayable. Those lists have decent builds.

1
Mr_E•

I totally forgot about Mech guard because it dropped out of my current meta, but yes. There isn't shit that can effectively take all comers and have good odds against mech guard without good rolling and a spoonful of luck.

1
cubemstr•

Let me put it this way: Tournament in the Twin Cities this weekend has 60ish players. Half of that is made up of Blood Angels and Grey Knights. Another solid 1/3 is a conglomeration of other Space Marines (vanilla, Space Wolves, Dark Angels).

2
General-Fuct•

You should play what suits your play style, the models you like or fluff that appeals to you. We really don't need anymore more long fang or purifier spam lists then there already is.

Old books just means new books coming soon!

2
s7ubby•

Grey Knights, Space Wolves, IG in no particular order are the Upper tier. Tyranids, Chaos Space Marines, and Chaos Daemons are Lower Teir.

Everything else is in between and still competitive, this is the most balanced the game has been in a while.

1
neutronicus•

The NOVA Open was won by Space Wolves, with a Grey Knights player coming in second.

Battle for Salvation was Grey Knights.

IG are generally considered also in the top tier (and a pretty good Grey Knights counter), but it costs sooooo much money to field a good IG army that not that many people do.

1
chrawley•

A. Grey Knights, Mech Guard, Space Wolves, Blood Angels

B. Necrons, Dark Eldar, C:SM, Dark Angels (Deathwing)

C. Chaos Space Marines, Templars(gunline), Tau, Nids

D. Eldar, SoB, Daemons

1
ParallelDementia•

Alot of armies are suffering from No New Codex Syndrome (NNCS) Mostly Chaos, Eldar and Nids. Tau have always been terrible so I don't count them.

Grey Knights are the most broken at the moment, along with Blood Angels.

1
Just__The__Tip•

Tau aren't terrible if you know how to play them, after losing the first 6 games or so, I tabled my roommate's DE by turn 3 yesterday in a 1250pt game.

1
ParallelDementia•

I've never considored DE much cop either, but granted I haven't read their new codex.

1
Just__The__Tip•

The new dex has added a lot of versatility

1
ParallelDementia•

I'll believe it when I stop using their spikes as toothpicks.

1
[deleted]•

The general word on the street seems to be:

1st: Grey knights, mech guard, space wolves, blood angels, dark Eldar, necrons

2: Orks, Eldar, Codex SM, Foot Guard

3: Chaos SM, Templars, SoB, Nids, Tau

4:Tau, Daemons of Chaos,

Tier 1:This tier is self explanatory, though I am adding DE and crons as: DE have several devastating all comers lists at their disposal. Crons are the same, from what I have seen in my local tournament scene.

Teir 2: good armies but limited in their "good-against-all-comers" lists. Still can face the big dogs, but armies like Orks and Eldar are starting to show their age.

Tier 3: This Teir is for armies with limited to no "good-against-all-comers" lists and are generally average. The Chaos is a very old codex which has aged poorly and recently had a hit to their only tournament list via the FAQs,Templars are just average the same can be said or sisters (although the do get a insanely good heavy support choice) .

Nids and Dark Angels only exist in this tier as I have seen really good players place decently in tournaments with them, otherwise they suck (especially nids).

Tier 4: this again is pretty self explanatory, Daemons deployment rules can make them quite hit and miss for all but the best players, while the Tau just are too fragile.

1
[deleted]•

I agree with you on most of that but Eldar. Eldar are garbage right now.

1