Devout Mormon couple insist they're happily married despite husband confessing he's gay
dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-9968951/Devout...Posted Sep 8, 2021, 2:01 PM UTC
Posted Sep 8, 2021, 2:01 PM UTC
Woah. I served my mission with him. We sang together all the time.
He was one of my favorite missionaries to spend time with. It makes me so sad that people really believe the churches false narrative that you can't be happy outside of the church and its rules. I hope he can be himself one day.
Edit: I added my thoughts about how I feel about this after processing for a little bit.
He’ll either be happy outside or miserable inside. Those are really the only two possibilities. Other than more grim options.
[deleted]
I’m sure that’s how he sees it. But that is typically a subordinate satisfaction to one’s sexuality in the long term.
I’m not trying to pick a fight with any of you but I wonder if you’re being as intolerant and narrow-minded as the TBMs that you’re criticizing. Maybe for him, this is, in truth, his best chance at happiness. You ended your post with “I hope he can be himself one day.” Maybe this is him being himself. He’s out in the open about being gay after all. It’s not a closeted-this woman is my beard-sort of thing. You’re doing what you can’t stand in TBMs. You’re projecting your beliefs and standards onto somebody else and dismissing their preferences.
I mean yes they are jumping to conclusions, but realistically you have to question the likelihood of a self professed gay man's happiest state being when he suppresses his sexuality completely and stays married to a person he's not attracted to his entire life. It's reasonable doubt.
I think people are assuming, based on our own personal experiences being faithful members at one point, that the church can and will convince you to deny many core elements of your self. There is no question that he is denying himself being with someone for whom he can be sexually attacted. Can he be totally fulfilled without a healthy sexual aspect in his marriage? Maybe. But it is not at all weird to doubt it.
I agree that we should not judge. There are, however, so many stories of gay men who married women because of their religious beliefs and many men in this situation eventually decide they are not happy being married to a woman.
So I have a brother that is basically this guy. After two decades of marriage, yeah, he's still devoted to his wife and tacc, but he is not happy. There are times he really struggles. You'd have to when every day you are trying to fit yourself in a hole you don't fit it. Your nature wants something different than you have ans God doesn't automatic zap the gay out just because you've entered a straight marriage. As a gay woman and former tbm, I have some experience here.
The church is responsible for this. I wish them the best, it's gonna be a tough road.
I hope their exit is as smooth as possible, but this won't end well.
It can work, though it is unlikely. Maybe she is more asexaul and he is more demisexual. He can be attracted to her mind more than her body and she may not even be that interested in sex. Again, unlikely but it may not end in disaster
I doubt they're that sophisticated.
I'll bet it's as simple as "being gay is a sin, so I'm not going to be gay, even though I only get boners from guys!"
It is that.
I guess someone can say, they only get boners from children too. Doesn't make it right
He says he is gay. There's no need to play "what if" and assign either of them different identities. Gay men are not attracted to women's minds or bodies, and being married to someone you are not sexually compatible with does not end happily.
Just speaking from experience. Mormons have a very juvenile understanding of sexuality. I know many exmo's who have figured out their true sexuality long after they left the church. There is a good chance that these two have never even considered sexualities beyond the very binary gay or straight.
But the main point of my comment was not pretending that the people in question were these things but instead creating a unique scenario where this kind of marriage could work. I think there is a possibility, given the right conditions, that both people could be satisfied in this kind of relationship.
I dont know why you are being downvoted for this; I think it is inappropriate to speculate about other people's identities, especially if they have already clearly given themselves a label.
I know this person. He's my wife's cousin's husband. He is one of the nicest people I've ever met. He's just deep in the mormon paint right now.
In other news, people who are delusional about one thing are often delusional about other things.
I did that. I'm divorced now.
For reasons that will forever remain a mystery. Humanity will never know why marriages involving at least one partner who isn't attracted to the other end poorly. It's probably because gay people are evil and should be pushed out of the community to stop them from causing these problems. That would be good for everyone who matters.
I think I did extremely well at helping to sculpt someone into husband material. Hopefully his future wife appreciates the effort!
I can accept that they are happy if they've been friends a long time and feel comfortable together. I don't accept that they have a "normal marriage". It isn't healthy or normal to not be sexually attracted to the person you are being sexually intimate with.
Agreed. I'm not about to jump at someone who says, "I'm happy" with "NO YOU'RE NOT." It's the same thing the church says about people who leave. We're happy outside the church. We know we are. Those who say otherwise are full of it.
That said, the quotes in the article give a lot of r/deadbedrooms vibes. There's the focus on non-sexual things, like what makes a good companion or room mate, not what makes a good sexual partner. So despite their claim of happiness, which I'm going to accept, I'm still going to say that they'd probably both be much more sexually satisfied with other partners.
Actually I'm pretty sure plenty of long time married people do not find their spouse to be sexually attractive to them... just saying.
I remember being three weeks into my marriage and my wife insisting to her family that she and I would never fight. I remember this vividly because I was mad at her about something the moment the words were coming out of her mouth.
So naive.
Just a couple years back, wasn’t there a family named WEED that the church was promoting with a similar story. They ran a blog page. As I recall, that didn’t end well for Mormon apologetics.
Josh was my therapist for a few months some time back. I chose him because of the combination of being gay but married to a woman. He was an amazing therapist and actually led me to honestly evaluate my faith which is why I'm free now. I stopped meeting with him (no real reason, it just happened), before his divorce and I had some mixed feelings back when that happened. But now I'm really glad for him.
Josh elicits a mix-bag of emotions from many exmos. I personally feel like the guy was a victim of his own religion/community, in that he toed the Mormon line and put this persona out there that you can be happy as a gay man in a mixed orientation marriage. I mean, being Mormon was all the guy knew how to be. Then he has to come out as a total hypocrite. We see a lot of people use the phrase, "I'm sorry for what I said when I was Mormon," but I don't think most people can afford Josh that same privilege of saying that, because Josh fucked-up a lot of peoples' lives. There are many sad tales of LGTBQ being negatively impacted by Josh's example. Far too many got hit with, "He can do it! Why can't ?!?!? You just want to sin!"
I can see how that would be the case for people who saw him through the blog or other public stuff, especially if he was used as an anecdote by randos. I was lucky to be in private professional counseling, and I don't think he ever said anything about his personal life.
What I got out of our sessions was a strength to stand up for myself against the voices in my head representing the church, my parents, society, etc. He didn't tell me to question my faith, but it's because of the self-honesty I got from him that I started on that path and was able to make so much positive progress. I kept forgetting to schedule sessions, and more time would pass between them. Then his divorce happened, and at the time I was still active and maybe-believing, so it was a kind of shock. It had been a while, but I wasn't sure I wanted to go back because what would I say, knowing that detail of his personal life? But eventually enough time passed that I just decided to move on. He had already given me so much, it was okay to close that chapter.
So I'll defend him on an individual level, but accept the damage his story may have caused indirectly. It's a useful distinction to make, I think.
Yeah, I hear you. It's a difficult situation. I always gave the guy the benefit of the doubt that he was a guy just trying to be a good person and help others, but he allowed a system to manage a major aspect of his life and it negatively impacted others. Or rather.....maybe his decision to make his life so public in that aspect, was not the best thing to do. And I say that as a guy who has made a lot of bad choices. Fortunately for me, those choices only effected me - not others. Interestingly, I think the guy probably has A LOT of interesting and insightful things to say since his divorce and I think he's now involved with a man. But the experience has effectively silenced his public voice. A great many don't care to hear what he has to say and I'm sure he himself doesn't want to be "that guy" again. It's a pretty sad situation.
Totally, but at least the Weeds were like “we support everyone’s right to make their own decision, this is not an easy path and it works for us but may not work for others.” These clowns are claiming that this is the right choice for everyone.
the Weeds were like “we support everyone’s right to make their own decision"
Well, maybe eventually. But Josh worked at a reparative therapy practice early in his career. So, I'm not inclined to give him a single benefit of a doubt. He may have walked away from that evil later, but that doesn't help anyone he treated with destructive quackery early on.
Oh, definitely not letting the Weeds off the hook, just saying that they arguably did less harm than these bozos with their “we support Elder Holland xoxo” bullshit.
...are they? I read the article, and I didn't see that claim...
I didn’t read the article but in their Facebook post they explicitly state “we stand with the church and with BYU in regards to their stance on same-sex relationships.” So yeah, I guess they didn’t say every gay person should get into a mixed orientation marriage, but standing with the church means no relationships outside of straight ones, ie celibacy unless you want to get straight-married. They say that they believe people should marry whoever they want, but “I do know God’s law is true and same-sex marriage is not ordained of him.”
*ETA: by “this is the right choice for everybody,” I meant a Mormon-approved path (that is to say, celibacy or a straight marriage). They did not say that every gay person should just get straight married.
He is quoted as saying, "...when they found out that I'm gay, they were mainly impressed at the sacrifice I'm making." As if she isn't ( or will not be) making a sacrifice here. I only feel sadness for them.
Let's have a follow-up in five years
I have a feeling that kid will be getting 2 Christmases..
So lucky, right? /s
Josh and Lolly Weed did this, until they couldn’t keep up the facade anymore.
i always feel so bad for the people who are so trapped in this toxic belief that they convince themselves that they can’t be happy, or that being their true authentic self won’t make them happy.
I am sure that they both entered the relationship with a lot of experience dating and being in relationships so they definitely know what it feels like to be in a normal, intimate, romantic partnership. Having a child right away will make everything better...
Seriously though, Mormons are so unprepared to know what a good partnership should look and feel like.
Yep, talk to me when you turn 49, Bro. Applegate.
Thanks.
Sincerely, The Gay Grandpa.
This is one of my best friends and I just can’t get behind their relationship as much as I want to be happy for her. I just don’t see it working out.
I know someone from my time at Utah State that is gay and married to a woman. We had an early class together and both show up even earlier to practice ahead of time. We got talking and I told him about being queer and he said he was also gay ... But knew he had to marry a woman because god and the church were more important. Broke my heart. Now I see all he posts on Facebook are CONSTANT religious memes about "god's love" etc.
It's kind of telling that this is what members consider "happily" married.
I don't want to get too judgmental of people but I wonder if your typical Mormon truly understands the meaning of "happy" in this sense. I know too many people who literally married the first person they ever dated and all they can talk about is how "happy" they are in spite of the struggles that you see them go through. They convince themselves that God somehow arranged things to ensure they didn't have to do any dating or anything that the rest of the world bothers with. Instead it's all about chastity and purity and waiting until you've signed on to a putatively eternal commitment before you get to know someone on an intimate level, so it's all big forced smiles and photographs of you and your happy spouse and your 5 kids all wearing the same goddamned outfit that you post on FB to show how happy you all are.
I hope she’s aro/ace, otherwise that poor woman. I can’t imagine living knowing your husband has no attraction to you.
Ace here. If she's like me, she's not gonna figure out she's ace for another 5 years, then things will start making sense.
Source: "falling in love" with closeted gay men on 2 separate occasions
Every guy I've dated has ended up coming out as gay either a couple months or a couple years after we broke up. Never understood how that kept happening until I realized I was ace and it all started to come together. I'm still friends with most of them luckily.
I truly hope this couple finds happiness and peace.
I just hate how TBMs use these type of stories to continue their homophobia and discrimination.
You know what fucked up belief I held when I was a TBM? “He’s not gay, he just hasn’t met the right woman yet”
WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK!
(Sorry for what i said when I was Mormon)
My folks kept saying that to me until one day I said, "Right. She needs to have a dick."
They never said it again.
Moments I wish I was a fly on the wall. That is an amazing comeback. Bravo!
Bravo!
Alternatively, "Well, if you are so convinced, let's go on a family trip to Amsterdam and spend a weekend in the red light district. Maybe we can find the right prostitute to fuck me straight? Ooh! And while we are at it, did you know they sell more than just coffee in their coffee shops?"
Usually takes at least a dozen to find the right one.
To be fair, a MtF person could fit the bill.
I guess I didn't mention the hairy chest and beard...
Details
[removed]
A trans woman is a woman regardless of her genitalia.
🤣
I am straight. But not because I saw the right woman. Just because I'm straight.
When did you chose to be straight? /s
Teusday
I’m not Mormon and never have been but my Protestant Mom said that about my brother who is gay or is a trans woman, I don’t know because we aren’t close and he presents himself as just our gay son and brother. She said that before he came out and married his husband. I think he may actually be deeply confused as opposed to the many true trans and gay people. But I could never put that on him because he is his own entity and I could be wrong about that. He had a rough child hood as all 3 of me and my brothers. I was a wild kid with adhd and to my shame I said some horrible stuff to my brother when I was just five years old. He was 8. He was a very sensitive boy and turns out so was I but this is about him.
When I was five my fam was at a Dave and busters type place and there was this photo booth thing that shows you what your kids will look like. My parents wanted to see what their daughter might look like. You can also pair one person with sample people. My brother wanted to do it and he chose this gorgeous woman. I think I may have laughed but I definitely said something like there’s no way he’d ever end up with a woman like that. He was crushed and I carry this horrible guilt.
I don’t know why I said it. I may have not meant it so maliciously. I don’t remember very well, I was 5. Maybe I was inherently awful. Maybe not, I have historically been deeply misunderstood by people not really catching my meaning or that I was substituting not having a point with a fake point and so weirdly throwing people off about where I’m at, or even just almost like turrets and just like compulsively saying the wrong thing at the wrong time because I was a confused young kid and so ending up being really misunderstood so. . I don’t know. Anyways my Mom told me she talked with him about girls before he came out and she said he cried and said what girl will ever going to want me. It breaks my heart. He had intense body dysmorphia. I also think he has some kind of autism.
Anyways he’s happy with his best friend and husband so as long as he’s living how he wants I can’t complain. My brother or sibling is still alive and enjoys his lifeand that’s enough for me at this point he doesn’t need to be “cured” of psychosis, he definitely lives in his own world and narrative thats for sure though. They are like Disney super fans. His husband works at a disney park and all that. Still it makes them happy its all good. I like Disney stuff too so do a lot of people. I’m by no means a super fan but I get it.
Also I’m pretty sure she says that about me too regarding settling down though I am straight, I choose to be celibate and not get married in this lifetime but I kind of agree with it, if the right girl comes along, and the timing is right, I may just go for it, otherwise I’m pretty sure I want to spend my life dedicated to yoga and meditation related things.
You were 5. You're brother should have some understanding for you saying that at that age. I don't know if it's something that bothers you a lot but it could help to reach out to him and talk about it? Could be healing for the both of you. ❤️
I agree. Many 5 year olds say stupid things without thinking. Things that can be really hurtful. It does make you a bad person and I doubt it greatly affected your older brother.
I'm lds, and I'm so sorry people feel they need to tell other people how they feel towards someone. You don't need to apologize for something you said when you were Mormon lmao
Yeah who said restitution was part of the repentance anyway?
Or not Mormon and 5 years old.