English is nothing more than a medium of communication

https://np.reddit.com/r/india/comments/pldwvs

This thread is about Jay shah being trolled for not knowing English. Now Jay shah is a corrupt son of a bitch and a product of corruption and nepotism but the fact that he is instead trolled for not knowing English is concerning. Knowing English doesn't make one competent, the fact that randians can't get this tiny thing into their head and keep acting like English should be a prerequisite for getting respect is very classist in simple words. One highly upvoted comment literally says that English makes you competent and worthy of respect.

Add to that, the people librandus claim to fight for, Dalits, muslims or the other oppressed groups are those he have been systematically kept away from education. By looking down on vernacular languages and acting like they are not worthy of respect is messed up and ignores history and effectively nullifies the voice of those proficient at vernacular languages. If anything the linguistic diversity of India should be promoted. BJP pushing hindi doesn't mean combating it by pushing for an even lesser spoken language like English. English should purely be a medium of communication and nothing more, it should not be used to deprive people of respect.

One of the more irritating things about randia for me is the unironic classism that's portrayed when it comes to the English language. English is considered refined, and you are a man of quality when you can speak english. This is pervasive across the country and is frankly a matter of concern. 90% of our population can't speak english, why is it considered something that makes you polished? It's only a language and a medium of communication.

Practically every other country doesn't shame their own countrymen for not knowing a particular language. If anything the vast multilingual population is something that I personally am pretty fascinated by, not many other countries can claim to have a vast majority of the population in such huge numbers speaking different languages. Indian multilingualism is not limited to knowing English and some vernacular language. It's everything in between. Migrants are the most fascinating, more than the classist middle and upper middle classes who migrate within for white collar jobs and don't often face a need for learning a new language, migrants often learn the local language and you will often see bihari migrants knowing telugu or kannada. Or the random Mallu knowing hindi. Language serves a need but is also identity and pushing a foreign identity on ourselves destroys the history that our beautiful languages have. Let's use English just as a mode of communication and stop putting it on a pedestal. Let's encourage literature in local languages as well.

Thats the end of the rant.

Posted Sep 10, 2021, 8:41 AM UTC · edited

2820
unotrackmind🗑🚩🧹•

Actually I'd say english Is a sign of competency when you're overseeing a pan India organization that has to work with foreign delegations

23
Pontokyo•

English is the best tool for upward social mobility we have in this country bar none. It is much more than just a "medium of instruction".

Fuck all Chodes who shit on English while working in MNCs and sending their kids to English medium schools. They're just trying to kick down the poor.

20
LittleOneInANutshellOP•

It's a tool of soci mobility because of how the English class has made sure English is the language of "class and sophistication". No other country makes it impossible for its citizenry to grow without knowing a minorly spoken language

4
Crpton_2•

Well, is there any alternative to English? Every state in India has a different language. According to the 2011 census, only 44 percent Indians speak Hindi.

There are 5 states which have native Hindi speakers and even in those states, the dialects of Hindi are very different. A man from UP, a man from Bihar and a man from Chattisgarh all speak Hindi but even they would have a hard time understanding each other.

There was a time when South Indian states threatened to leave the Union of India, should Hindi be "forcibly imposed" on them. There is a reason that only English is used in courts.

I agree with you, when you say that English is linked to beeing "elite" and "sophisticated", while someone not beeing able to speak English properly is thought of as "backward" or "dumb", which is stupid but keep in mind that India was a British colony for nearly 200 years and this sense of inferiority towards someone who knows English has deveoped because the Britishers were thought of as "superior".

In my opinion, making fun of someone for not beeing able to converse in English is wrong. But Amit Shah's son, who is the secretary of BCCI, studied from an English Medium school and is a BTech, kinda deserved it for his poor communication skills

11
plowman_digearth•

Heh nobody cares about Jay Shah's English. It's just a sign of his obvious incompetence and having the job only on basis of nepotism. But chodes, who pretended like nepotism was the biggest threat to our country, will never call out how blatant this is. Because kallu mama "le trolls" the muzz muzz.

16
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
plowman_digearth•

I think we all in South Asia, use English to mock people when it's convenient. Ex Chodes with Pakistani cricketers, or libz with Modiji.

5
Mullamandri•

English as a subject is taught 12 years in school and only requires some effort to gain proficiency. If someone, privileged, struggles to demonstrate a bare minimum learned at school, there's nothing wrong in calling that out.

And English is not just a mode of communication, that's how we acquire knowledge. In fact most vernacular languages did not have the vocabulary through which modern knowledge systems could be explained to vernacular speakers.

12
WhiteBreadToast•

Add to that, the people librandus claim to fight for, Dalits, muslims or the other oppressed groups are those he have been systematically kept away from education. By looking down on vernacular languages and acting like they are not worthy of respect is messed up and ignores history and effectively nullifies the voice of those proficient at vernacular languages.

Bullshit. While yes, nobody should be looking down on anyone for not being able to speak in English, English has been and continues to be used as a language of emancipation for many lower caste (including me) people. Do not infantilize us. I would not have attained half the social mobility that I have if it weren't for English.

From my experience, the only ones who continue to deprive English medium education to lower class and caste people are those who have a warped sense of preserving their "heritage". They will tell you how local languages are dying while simultaneously sending their children to convents that teach in english but rant on whatsapp groups about the importance of Sanskrit or whatever the fuck.

The demand for english education is only rising among our communities and there's no point in going back.

8
soda-pop-lover🍪🦴🥩•

English skills are often linked up with your social power. Under British rule, only the previlaged and brahmins had access to English-medium education. If you go through old records, you would note this too. There were very few Dalits who could speak good English like Babasaheb. And it didn't really matter back then since the world was completely different.

Sadly people's mentality are still stuck in those days. And this on randia isn't a wonder since most posters there are again NRIs and Urban life relatively previlaged people.

Here good English speaking skills are often associated with your intelligence for some reason.

7
Crpton_2•

Almost all countries that were once former British colonies have devoloped this sense of inferiority.

Though, in a multi-lingual country like India, English has played a very important role in holding the country together.

3

yes and no, when the matter comes to jay shah given his position and importance he should be better at english that is what is expected from him atleast.

6
LittleOneInANutshellOP•

He is a chutiya but you don't need to be good at English to be a good administrator. Tell me again, does Japan, or France, or Germany have horrible administrators because they don't speak english?

3
tetrarkanoid•

You’re being naive. This is multilingual India where like it or not English is the language that connects different regions speaking different local languages. The problem is his failing at one of his basic professional responsibilities - communication.

6

they didn't have british rule for about a century where the whole administration worked on english, they also don't have second highest english speaking population. My man is at probably the most important position in India's biggest sport, which is played by again english speaking countries (except the indian subcontinent). And the most important he completed and btech degree in english.

Japan, France Germany AFAIK don't have such diverse amount of languages, their languages have made way into world culture while ours have stayed to our subcontinent, you don't need to be good at english to be a good administrator but for a case such as india it is to be expected for such a top official.

2
Traditional-Bar-665:kiss3::kiss4:•

Hanji kya bol diye aap

3
ms_09_00•

For a country which has been under British colonial rule for 200 years, so had the most educated and well off people among them as ones who spoke and were educated in english and in which the biggest bragging point for most people in recent years has been achievements of their Indian-Americans family members rather than indians themselves superiority on the basis of English knowledge seems very natural. Basically I feel like most people in India idealise english speaking people of their own origin much more than actual english or American people.

2
Hot_Garage701•

Jay sah isnt being trolled for not knowing enlish but the way he spoke at the teleprompeyer. Are bhai hindi me hi dete par robot ki tarah bolne ka kya zaroorat tha. I know how you becane chairman atleast try to appear you are good at your job.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

#DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THE LINKED THREAD.

Do not participate in the linked thread, unless you are a regular participant in the linked Subreddit. We cannot and will not help you if your account is actioned upon for brigading.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

hindi use karni thi

-1