Seeking advice for senior EC that is so done with the artificial stresses of the policy back office

Career Development / Développement de carrière

Not sure how to position this so I'll be honest and blunt. I'm a millennial that entered public service to have meaningful work, meaningful connections, and move the needle on issues of importance to Canadians.

In the decade+ that I've worked in government (I have rich pregovernment work experience working in customer service) I have jad the fortune of working with amazing people and the nightmare of working with toxic, dysfunctional offices that were lead by misogynistic narcissists - that has left psychological scars.

I've always been "busy" but most of the work has been focused on outputs rather than outcomes. Many times, juggling egos means the work goes nowhere. Most times heavy bureaucratic processes have gotten in the way of intelligent, innovative or practical work. And because I get invested in the work I do, these conditions as well as the whole "hurry up and wait", the micromanagement of some and the disengagement of others has brought me close to burn out multiple times. Balancing that with little kids, in the uncertainty of the covid context, is even more challenging for me.

I am coming to the difficult conclusion that while I have the skills and aptitude to do the work, and to do it well, I do not fit in and it is slowly crushing my spirit. I am an extrovert who loves to collaborate and to think big and execute bigger. I haven't found that in my time here but I've heard of these magical unicorn offices that, at least for a time, are really worthwhile.

I'm not ready to jump ship - it's not for nothing that we have golden handcuffs - but I can't keep doing what I've been doing and expect different results (that's the definition of madness).

So here's my plea for help: are there fields or jobs or offices or departments you would recommend for someone on the verge of losing hope? Anyone left policy and using those transferable skills to great effect? I

I've also heard the the PSC might have career counselling services but not sure if these are exclusively for EXs. Any ideas about this, or tried and tested private services for that?

Sorry for the downer message - I just really feel stuck and I could use the help of a community that has seen it all.

Posted Sep 10, 2021, 2:45 PM UTC

3232
HandcuffsOfGoldmod 🤖🧑🇨🇦 / Probably a bot•

Your experience isn't uncommon. From the subreddit's Frank FAQ:

And once you're inside the tent... well, a lot of young, ambitious people are often disappointed.

They're disappointed that government work is years out-of-date: that the tools available to us, the work structure, and the language and corporate culture are behind the times. It's improving, but it's not there yet.

They're disappointed that virtually all government employees at all levels are just used to a crushing degree of bureaucracy: to everything taking six months longer than it should; having to climb a mountain in order to make seemingly-trivial changes; relying upon a Swiss-cheese intranet where half the links are dead and the other half go to documents which haven't been updated since the Martin government; to an endless barrage of people practically queueing up to quash your best-laid plans with what amounts to "computer says 'no'."

They're disappointed that people and units and even departments get territorial and weird about the strangest things, out of a not-entirely-misguided fear that, should they take their eye off the ball for a second (or allow changes to be made, or share control of a resource, or review a process, or whatever else), this puts them on a slippery slope to having it ripped away entirely.

And they're disappointed that government jobs are... jobs. We don't spend our days solving the world's problems: most of us spend them sitting in our cubicles trying to get Excel to do as it's told. True, the public service can get you some very exciting and important jobs: ambassadors, negotiators, adjudicators, inspectors, judges, public advocates and deputy ministers all get recruited out of the public service. But most public servants have job titles like "Associate Senior Program Systems Analyst (Rail Transport Division [Western Subdivision])". And, yes: she works in a cubicle.

In answer to your questions: No, the PSC does not have career counselling services for non-EX employees (some departments used to offer some level of career counselling, but that's increasingly rare).

If you're fed up in your current job, you can always find another one. There are pockets of amazing work within the public service, but it takes time and effort to seek them out. Sometimes that means bouncing through many unfulfilling positions until you find something that you enjoy. You shouldn't limit yourself to "policy" jobs - maybe your skills would be helpful in some form of internal service or in program delivery. There are literally tens of thousands of career tracks within the public service, so there is bound to be something that you will like better than where you are now.

40
addictedtosoonjung•

I hear you. You’re not alone in feeling this. Some of what you’re saying is unavoidable, BUT I will say that when I switched from being an EC to a PM that a significant amount of the bureaucratic BS went away. I still deal with some of it, as it is still government after all, but having your own programming budget and files where you actually HAVE to meticulously evaluate for outcome has been a good shift for my psyche.

Not saying every PM job is like mine, but I do find that being responsible for actual programming and the results of that programming is refreshing and motivating in comparison to dealing with constant policy churn that used to occupy my full work day as an analyst.

15
oshkoshb-josh•

I feel this a lot. I left the military for the public service about two years ago, thinking that the relatively senior position I took would be similarly challenging. I’ve been sadly mistaken.

There’s an incredible amount of ego among senior leaders, who don’t trust the working level with anything beyond what is essentially simple administration. This leads them to focus primarily on micromanaging daily churn when they should be focusing on strategizing, identifying clear goals/objectives/priorities, and better managing resources.

In my experience, many managers are barely competent and possess zero leadership skills. No effort is made to determine what employees need to be motivated or satisfied. I think this relates to the emphasis the public service places on output over outcome, as you so aptly put it. Make work projects seem to be their bread and butter. The only measure of success is whether work, no matter how unimportant or meaningless, was assigned and completed, with no analysis or evaluation.

Personally, for the last five months, I’ve been assigned almost zero meaningful work. I’d say I maybe do about 30 minutes of actual work in a day, which is soul destroying for me. It’s completely ruined my motivation. I’m currently learning to trade stocks during the day to try and fill the time.

I hope things get better for you, OP. Our public service needs a lot of improvement.

14
CharacterHugeOP•

I'm really sorry to hear that. I think we need a support group and then we need to pull ourselves from our bootstraps and build something together

3
[deleted]•

Damn. Are you saying that you are paid 37.5 hours yet you work about 4.5 a week?

1
oshkoshb-josh•

If that. Believe me, it’s not something I enjoy.

9
[deleted]•

Holyshit. Speak to your manager. In fact, your manager is a fucking idiot, assuming s(he) knows that you are working a few hours a week only yet paid for 37.5.

3
sunz00mspark•

Have you looked into the Free Agent program?

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
msat16•

Second the 2nd para.

6
bagelzzzzzzzzz•

"Challenge function positions might be really interesting for you to try - some areas of PCO are fast paced and extremely busy (to a point I’ve never see before in the PS). TBS also has some really interesting work (and great people) as well."

No denying that (many parts of) the central agencies are extremely busy and fast-paced. But a whole lot of this work is just a higher-profile version of the stuff OP is complaining about: micromanaging other peoples' files, output focused work (your cabinet bullets are for the PM but they're still just summarizing someone else's hard work), managing the biggest of big egos.

I don't say this to pick on this suggestion, just to flag for OP and others to be honest about why CA work is appealing to some. It can flatter your ego, its pace and volume feel exciting and like you're doing something big even if its just briefing notes and editing other peoples (Cabinet) docs. I think its biggest endorsement is those shops tend to attract serious and smart people, and working with good people can make even a crappy job much more bearable.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
NatureValleyDipps•

I felt similarly going from a very operational position and team to a team that’s mostly policy. I feel like I’m not accomplishing anything. I’m busy, yes, but I definitely don’t have the same feeling of satisfaction I had previously.

I agree with the other comment that those fulfilling positions do exist but they’re not easy to find. You have to go through a few crappy ones to find the good ones.

7
zeromussc•

Well for what its worth, the focus on outputs rather than outcomes is the result of the way work and thinking about program delivery has been organized in the policy space for a very long time.

If you want to think about outcomes, and push for change, maybe you can work in a Performance Measurement or Evaluation type role? At least in these areas the focus is on outcomes and assessing them more than outputs. Well, in theory anyway. There might be pockets where the focus is outputs still but the two fields do push for outcome and results based thinking and management.

So that could be a fun little break. If you're in a central service role like a PM centre of excellence kind of thing (hate that term but it is what it is) or evaluation you won't be super hands on in designing programs but you would be contributing to the outcome thinking and assessment you seem to prefer.

And if you end up in a specific program or branch of program's performance measurement team then you'd be tracking and researching and identifying indicators for program performance outside of just outputs. Cautionary note though is that I've found people can sometimes really push back on outcome thinking a lot but at least if you're designing something to fit into the results policy requirements you have a TBS out related to wanting to satisfy them to try and move the needle.

As with everything else in government though it will depend on management. If the management up and down the chain doesn't want to be accountable to anything but their outputs and products in the policy space, then there is little you can really do without support. But that's not the direction the government is headed so rolling the dice you'll have decent odds of finding an outcome focused job of some sort in PM and you certainly would get it in evaluation. Each with different flavours.

Micromanagement has no solution - thats just how a manager manages and you're stuck. Same with egos and power trips and all that - people are people and they come with baggage and sometimes there's more sometimes there's less. And when there's more it can be very frustrating to work through but that will never go away I think. Relationships matter and people's sense of ownership will always be there so inevitably you'll need to deal with that delicate balance and figure that out. It only gets worse the more senior you get I hear and is one reason I don't ever want to be an exec :P

7
keltorak•

I go through this every year or so. Generally when I'm not currently working on a big file that will have a positive impact.

I get out of my funk by looking at what I've accomplished results-wise since joining 7+ years ago after working in the private sector. Since I always pushed the envelope with facts, analysis and paths forward, I've lead (positive) headline worthy files over the years.

I lucked out that I joined a team where people are encouraged to attempt to do so. And I'm really enjoying training junior staff in achieving the same.

Full disclosure: I'm currently in such a funk and typing this out is somewhat therapeutic for me. Gotta remember there's ups and downs.

Aim for more ups. Move teams if needed!

7
[deleted]•

Lower your expectations :)

At the working level we're not doing the transformational society change you seem to be expecting. In fact, very few people are at that level - think minister's offices, PMO, PCO, and a select few very senior ADMs and DMs to deliver whatever program or benefit those senior offices are discussing.

The work at more junior levels is about supporting, facilitating, researching, analyzing, and whatever other buzzwords are appropriate. It's simply not at that level to say "hey I think we should create a basic income" or "hey we should change EI" or whatever other massive idea you're thinking of.

Don't get discouraged, just change your understanding of where you fit into the grand scheme of things. If you want to create those changes, commit to becoming an ADM or DM or get a job in PCO or PMO relevant to the changes you want to see.

6†
oshkoshb-josh•

This is a toxic attitude. Whether you believe in it or not, we should be trying to break that mould instead of blindly accepting it. Lots of people at the working level, especially mid-level and senior advisors, are very well-educated and experienced. Some of the best ideas come from the working level. Relegating these people to “support” functions, which is essentially administrative work that could be done by an executive assistant, is the reason our public service continues to struggle with major issues.

13
[deleted]•

It's not an attitude, it's how a hierarchy and democratic government works. The working level simply does not have the experience or competency to literally change society in the way the OP is suggesting. Discussions like legalizing marijuana, changing the social safety net, criminalizing/decriminalizing certain behaviours, and so on, are going to come from the very top. They're not going to come from John Smith, student intern at Justice.

2†
oshkoshb-josh•

I’m not talking about the student intern, although you shouldn’t discount them either. Young employees in their late 20s and 30s tend to be highly educated, are digitally competent, switch careers more often and come from more diverse backgrounds. This means they have a wealth of experience, knowledge and valuable perspectives that can and should be incorporated into major decisions and initiatives.

You should read up more on organizational culture. Pretty much every conclusion is that empowering younger people with meaningful responsibilities leads to better outcomes for your organization.

The unquestioning belief in a top-down, I’m-more-senior-so-I-automatically-know-more-than-you attitude is a major factor in the PS’s many failings. It’s exactly what I mean when I say that PS managers are barely competent, yet have zero leadership skills.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/glennllopis/2015/02/02/6-things-wise-leaders-do-to-engage-their-employees/

11
jcamp028•

The educated working level staff see the writing on the wall and diminishing benefit the higher you go as an ex. That’s why there’s so many DM’s and other senior leaders who only have bachelor’s degrees. In part, these were the people willing to move that high.

2
[deleted]•

Lol I have a Master's in organization theory so thanks.

Maybe I can put it differently: feel free to tell your boss we should adopt a UBI, abolish EI, CPP, and OAS, and change Canada's name to Turtle Island. Just don't burn yourself out and act surprised when they laugh at you and say the adults are going to focus on other things.

-2†
CharacterHugeOP•

I wish I could say I harbored ideas of single-handedly changing society, or the world. I understand the bureaucracy and how it works, and I know how to anticipate executives' needs. I don't pretend to have their overview of the department or their experience. I just think the policy sector has experienced deep trauma and it doesn't know how to stop passing it on.

6
uhpinion11•

In theory one might be able to access career counselling through the EAP if its not available directly from the PS at your level.

6
CharacterHugeOP•

Great suggestion, thank you

2
bagelzzzzzzzzz•

Buddy I think you can see from the other comments here that a lot of what you're feeling is sadly normal. Heck, the Bot even posted a FAQ about it.

With that said, there's a couple red flags for me in your post. Like, I'm reading the above as you're 10+ years in and don't know even know where to start to find good projects and teams.

I guarantee there is no counsellor at the PSC who is going to swoop in and make this better for you.

It might be worth starting with yourself, not "settling" for a shit situation, but looking at how you look at and do your work.

Getting burned out by caring too much about your files (and that others are disengaged, that you have to push everything and carry all the weight yourself) seems very common among the kind of people who are attracted to EC work. You may want to look into Bowen Theory (Kathleen Smith is a popular author/blogger on this method of counselling) about whether you have a personality that is prone to overfunction for others. If that's too big a change, talking with a leadership coach is basically talk therapy but for work--they can help you talk through how you do your work and how to problem solve the challenges you encounter that are leading to burnout.

Driving change, the kind of interesting files that the best ECs get to do, is super challenging. Building support for new ideas, new approaches is challenging. And yeah, executives tend to attract people who think highly of their skills. But if you're feeling like everyone who doesn't see your way is the right way right away is a dummy or a barrier, and most bosses are all ego and no brains, its worth questioning whether some of this is coming from you and your approach.

(Also egos can get things done! A couple of the best projects I worked on were lead by narcisisstic dick DMs who didn't give a shit about our personal lives or how much OT we had to do, but they also didn't care about all the petty barriers and infighting that get thrown in the face of a transformational initiative. They weren't pleasant to work for, but we got big things done)

6
CharacterHugeOP•

Thanks for the insight, a lot to think about and explore here

3
Grumpyman24•

You can ask career counseling as part of your annual training plan

5
grumpytocks•

Have you looked into the Free Agent program? https://www.canada.ca/en/government/system/digital-government/living-digital/roaming-coast-to-coast-coast-life-free-agent.html

I'm not sure when the next round of applications is, but it could be an interesting opportunity that might play to your strengths. I've seen Free Agents brought in to do all kinds of different high profile/urgent work and it seems like a neat way to get a variety of work experience in high profile, high pressure situations (which might not suit everyone, but definitely suits some people).

5
dolfan1980•

Don't rule out different levels of government either. I have worked for provincial, territorial and federal governments, as well as a provincial agency and I can generally say that the work experience has largely been better at all of the others over the federal experience. Of course we have more money and more potential, but we really have a lot of trouble with execution and a lot more process as noted.

4
just_ignore_me89•

I feel you. I started my career as a business analyst at the Canadian arm of one of the big US banks. We were an afterthought but that also gave us a lot of leeway to try new things and innovate quite a bit.

I started in the public service with those same ideas and have worked my way into a similar roll. I did my time as an SME and know that, and policy work is not for me. I have no patience for the politics and the ass kissing. But in my current role I'm able to develop tools and processes to help the SMEs and policy people get the information and data they need in the fastest way possible.

In terms of implementing change, I used to swing for the fences on some big directorate-wide projects. Where I've had the most success is implementing the desired change at a smaller scale, like a division or section, and demonstrating that it works there first.

Demonstrating that it works helps to surmount senior managers' aversion to even minor changes to processes. The manager where the tool is in place becomes a champion, and managers on the outside get some FOMO. I have a project I'm wrapping up this month that's taken about two years to deploy at the directorate level after a couple smaller iterations.

3
jcamp028•

Are you me??

1
newchallenger2020•

I'll trade you a private sector job in a technical leadership role, the shot-caller, the ball breaker, and all the responsibility that goes with it. (PS, corporate can lay you off any time because profits)

For your golden handcuffs plus whatever paper-pushing bureaucracy sandwich I'd have to eat on the daily. I'd take those any day of the week. (assuming I get comparable compensation)

0†
CharacterHugeOP•

Why would I take that trade? I dont believe that those are the only two options. A whole world of entrepreneurs- either for profit or social - are out there. Perhaps if this reflection doesn't pan out, that might be might next calling. I have a brain, an education and the skills to do it, I just lack the conviction.

6