[Advice] For Law School Consolidation & Refinancing

Hi All.

Law School debt via graduated repayment plan. Serviced by NelNet.

I have 7 loans that vary from 3.86% to 7.6%. I am looking for advice on what to do next including payment priority, consolidation, and refinance options. All are currently in COVID Forebearance and my next payments are due on 5/1/2022.

​

The loans are Direct Grad Unsubsidized and Direct Unsubsidized.

Current Total Balance:$137,080.05

Outstanding Principal:$129,272.97

Accrued Interest:$7,807.08

​

  1. 7.6% - Principal Balance: $9,987.00
  2. 7.6% Principal Balance: $5,500.00 (Accrued Interest: $492.11)
  3. 7% Outstanding Balance:$19,560.10 - Principal :$17,000.00 ( Accrued Interest $2,560.10)
  4. 6.6% - Principal Balance:$21,787.08
  5. 6.3% Outstanding Balance:$28,283.97 (Accrued Interest: $4,646.97)
  6. 6% - Outstanding Balance:$22,911.46
  7. 5.3% - Outstanding Balance:$23,661.19
  8. 4.6% - Outstanding Balance: $2,181.41
  9. 3.86% - Outstanding Balance: $2,655.50

Please advise- what would you do if you were me? Killing self has been considered but not currently an option.

I make $130-170k annual salary so public interest/loan forgiveness is not an option.

Thank you everyone and godspeed.

Posted Sep 10, 2021, 8:04 PM UTC · edited

424
alh9h•

Assuming your salary and savings are correct I'd pay off the five highest interest loans on Monday. That leaves you with about $15k for an emergency fund (assuming the $100k is all your savings). Then just pay off the rest as fast as possible - conservatively you could knock this out in like 2 years. You're not in a bad position at all.

5
The_Barnstormer•

Agree. Also keeping the loans in the Federal loan system gives you access to their loan protections like COVID interest relief.

The bigger reason to stay is that a consolidation would lower the interest rate but would leave you with a single flat fee for a long time. You have tha ability here to create more cash flow overtime by gradually paying off loans in a stepwise manner

So you do get to gradually reduce you pain prior to full pay off

With salary you posted you could pay this off quickly if your aggressive.

1
JackTheRascalOP•

Thanks for the insight. I’ve felt weird about just dropping all of my saved up $ on the loans. But that sounds like a good idea. What about refinancing? Is it not worth it for me at this point, since I’ll presumably be able to knock them out in 2yrs if aggressively paying down?

0
alh9h•

It wouldn't hurt. It would save you a few hundred dollars a year

2

Salary? If it's below 50k, you might want to consider going the PSLF route. Otherwise, myou've got to start making that degree work and make what I used to think all lawyers made. (cocaine and hookers).

3
JackTheRascalOP•

Let’s assume I make between 130-170k and have ~100k saved up

0

Holy shit. Ok. Avalanche method. Pay minimum on everything and throw extra cash at highest interest loan. Get rid of that and use the old payment plus extra cash in the next highest interest loan.

I would do this until maybe getting it down to 50-60 k while also maxing out all of my retirement funds. Then I would pay minimums for a few months and just splurge (hookers, coke, or whatever you like). All the while still maxing out retirement. After a few months, get back to the avelanche method until you get to the 5.3% and below. Pay minimums untili get tired of seeing the loans. Maybe a year or two.

Anyway, I really hope you make that much now or at some point and even more. Good luck, man!

Edit: oh yeah. Look to refinance along the way. Hopefully your credit looks great after a few years.

5
JackTheRascalOP•

Thanks. I just left a job at 170 and had a 135k offer last week that I denied and hopefully won't regret. We'll see what happens. Credit is 800+ rn. Should I consolidate or refi anything right now?

1
girl_of_squirrelshuman suit full of squirrels•

First off, you are more than you're debt. You can handle this situation

Basically it is typically a bad idea to refinance federal loans into private student loans since you lose the flexible deferment, forbearance, income-driven repayment, and forgiveness (PSLF/TEPSLF, TLF, BD, TPD, etc) options that only federal loans have. Just comparing interest rates doesn't do federal loans justice.

You can always put your federal loans on one of the income-driven repayment plans (IBR, PAYE, REPAYE, ICR) in which you pay 10%/15%/20% of your discretionary income (aka your AGI from your taxes minus 150% of the Federal Poverty Guideline) and by doing so for 20/25 years anything left at the end will be forgiven. You can always use an IDR plan to keep your federal loans in good standing, and the payment can be $0/month.

I don't know where you're working or what your salary is, but PSLF may be an option if you're in the public sector and you would put your loans on an IDR plan to pursue that.

2
JackTheRascalOP•

Thanks- I don't do public interest and income is/will be too high for forgiveness/IRAP. I appreciate you advice & empathy. Debt sucks.

1
Kimmybabe•

Never make jokes about suicide!!!!

$140,000 of debt with income of $130,000 plus and $100,000 cash gives you lots of options way better than suicide.

Live like a poor student for five years and keep the $100,000 in a broad based stock market fund is a good option.

Or, apply the $100,000 to the debt and your finished in one year.

Or, something in the middle of those two options.

Congratulations on graduating with somewhat reasonable debt and all the best to you in law and life!!!!

2
JackTheRascalOP•

It wasn’t a joke, but thanks for all of the advice & reassurance.

Cash is in stocks rn so I’ll have to liquidate if paying down aggressively. Have about $20k liquid. Thanks for responding.

1
Kimmybabe•

Thank you for your reply.

Don't ever do something like suicide!

I know people with painful and terminal cancer that would not wish what they have on anyone else, but they would LOVE to have your debt, no stock, income of $40,000 or less. Your problem is curable!!!

A decade ago, a third cousin of our two daughters was a gifted athlete, student body president, being courted by Harvard and MIT, when he removed himself from further consideration with suicide. He left many people hurting, especially me. I recall bouncing him on my knee, like I was bouncing my grandsons when I got the news. Few weeks pass that I don't think about him and wonder what could and should have been done to avoid that. Grandparents, parents, siblings still dealing with the aftermath.

Get help!!!!! Life was never meant to be done alone!!!! Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt, both lawyers, had depression to the point that friends moved in to keep them from harming themselves. Let those around you do the same for you!

2
FieldNew2233•

Hi,

I have helped a few hundred law students navigate pretty much exactly the situation you are in. It’s not uncommon (though classmates don’t talk about it enough). Here are a few of my thoughts that probably go in a different direction that what I’m seeing other folks discuss.

The main difference is that other folks want to minimize their debt as quickly as possible. I try to optimize for highest net worth while keeping a comfortable cash flow for daily living.

FYI, very similar situation to you in my personal life as well just a few months ago. Graduated with $150k in debt, $120k in income and was fortunate to receive around $200k in savings (we will just call it a gift).

Firstly, Liquidating stocks is a bad idea If your stock portfolio is like everyone else’s at the moment, your portfolio is probably profitable. If you liquidate, you are going to trigger a taxable event and pay capital gains (either long term or short term, depending on when you bought the stocks). That’s not worth it when you consider the comprehensive impact. You are losing a substantial amount of your base for compounding growth (which on average over any long term period historically is higher than even your highest interest rate loan), you are paying taxes now vs. deferring them, you’ll look less attractive to lenders in the future with the minimal asset base etc.

Secondly, Federal loans aren’t for you People with 800+ credit score (or really 720+, mine was 740) and high incomes compared to their debt (which is your case even though you may not feel like it) and relatively stable careers, can qualify for really low refinancing rates. I refinanced my loans to 2.8%.

The federal benefits don’t really work for you. Pretty much the only benefit you’d have is IBR if you lost your job for an extended duration of time. To clarify, IBR helps you manage your cash flow during a tough time but it doesn’t reduce your interest rate. Therefore, you actually end up paying more in the long run if you were to utilize that option. Instead, you can manage that situation with relatively small withdrawals from your stock portfolio (or a phone call to your lender, they do actually put loans on forbearance if you ask, many people don’t believe the lender can be flexible (private or federal). Federal loans have flexibility built in and private is case by case but worth the call.

So what should you do: I’d recommend doing a soft credit check with a few places for private student loan refinancing and seeing what refinance rates they will offer you. This shouldn’t take more than 20 minutes of your time. Let me know if you don’t get an interest rate that’s lower than 4% and I should be able to help. Ideally, you get below 3.8% and you refinance all your loans or you get slightly higher and you just refinance the loans that have a higher interest rate than what you’ve been quoted.

When you refinance, you’ll have a few options ranging from 5 to 20 years for your loan.

Your instinct, based on your income etc. would probably guide you to like a 7 year loan. That’s okay, but personally I’d pay the slightly higher interest to get the 15 or 20 year option. The reason is, I want to pay as little as possible towards debt at 3% so I can put that cash flow to work in the stock market, real estate or any other faster growing asset sooner than later.

Ofcourse, be disciplined to ensure that extra cash flow doesn’t end up being spent on things you can’t actually afford. I like to setup an automatic monthly transfer into my savings account (from where I move it into some other asset like stocks or real estate).

I hope this helps. Don’t be afraid of debt. It’s actually an amazing way to create wealth and your financial situation is one that has a very high potential for expanding your net worth quickly assuming you focus on that instead of trying to payoff your debt only.

If you don’t have income at this instant, wait until you get your next jobs offer letter before applying for refinancing. Some places will ask for an offer letter or two pay stubs.

2
JackTheRascalOP•

Wow. This is 10/10. You read my mind in many places. Thank you for taking the time to type this out and guide. You’re right about refi rates, too. I think SoFi was suggesting 2.8% variable or 3.5% fixed.

The next job/salary I get (and with it, job location) will determine my approach. I hope you don’t mind if I DM in the future. Thanks again

1
your-suggestion•

Sending you a DM with my contact information. I don't check reddit DMs too often. (also realizing now that I replied from my wife's account initially, this is my account)

2
JackTheRascalOP•

Got it. Well, this has been a lifesaver, regardless. Thanks for taking the time

1
mcasw•

I feel you. I don’t know how helpful this will be but I’ll share what I’ve learned the hard way.

When I graduated law school, I had about $175k and was making barely 80k living in nyc. My interest rates (set by the government) were 6.8 and 8.5 on federal, i had a few private loans at 5.5, and I had a few low undergrad loans for 2.5. I put them into forbearance for a bit because I was really struggling because 80k after tax and really shitty insurance doesn’t leave much for a paycheck (I don’t even recall how I afforded food at that time). I eventually got on IBR and when I got to the point years later where I was making a good income, and then got married, all those loans had really ballooned to almost $375k, and ibr wasn’t really helpful at that point. I ended up refinancing a few times and they’re all at 5.0 now (minus the small ones), which I still think is crazy high for a loan I’m clearly going to pay back. I still owe about $200k, which is more than what i started with, but my payments go further now than they used to due to lower interest. I’ve been out of school ten years and make okay income but would be screwed if my husband wasn’t loan free. I guess my point is, be very careful with income based repayment options that capitalize the interest, and if you can refi, the sooner the better. I used sofi. Also do whatever you can to get into a good paying job. I graduated in 2010 and the market was crap so I took what I could. I had to make a couple job changes to finally get decent pay, but it was rough for a while. Fwiw, i also considered suicide or leaving the country and never coming back. It sucks but had it not been for the loans I would have never escaped my hometown. Good luck, it feels overwhelming at times but you’ll get through it.

ETA: until a few years ago there weren’t a lot of refi options. So I was stuck for many years at high interest. There should be a few options for lenders other than sofi at this point so you may want to explore getting quotes from a few and going with the lowest interest. Even 1 percent can be meaningful to getting these paid off faster. And obviously which ever ones have the highest interest, prioritize paying those off first.

1
JackTheRascalOP•

Thanks for the info. I appreciate your advice & if anyone has more info about how I may want to refi, I’m all ears

2
mcasw•

In re another comment, the reason i'm suggesting refi is because unless you make a really low income for 20/25 years, when you're finally eligible for forgiveness, this just means you'll end up paying more in the long run. By five years out of school, I was making so much that IBR didn't make sense anymore and I really needed to get them paid off (but by then having them on IBR had actually made them worse). If you know you're going to be in a low income job, that is not a bad idea, and I know people who have done this as their long term strategy, or worked in a sector that offered forgiveness. Also note that forgiveness isn't free...you will pay income taxes on that forgiven amount which can be quite significant.

1
ghostmode342•

you making 170k? so you paying this off in couple years, right?

1
JackTheRascalOP•

I recently left a job at $170 and anticipate a job between $130-170 by year’s end. So yes, I’d think I could/should pay it within the next 2-4 years. I don’t have many expenses but may need to relocate soon so housing could go up. Aside from that I lead a Spartan lifestyle so a good deal of salary could go straight to loans

1
ghostmode342•

nice!!

1
JackTheRascalOP•

I was hoping for advice haha. Not nice at all. It’s incredibly depressing, to be honest.

1