r/kelowna•
nsbound

Venice house type pizza in Kelowna?

Hey there, does anyone know of a place in Kelowna where you can get old school pizza? I am sitting with two people from Prince Albert, Saskatchewan and they keep talking about a square Venice House pizza and they want to know if anything like that here. Any info on an equivalent pizza here would be greatly appreciated.

Posted Sep 11, 2021, 3:57 AM UTC

629

Disregard all of the other answers here. None of them are what your friends are looking for. I'm actually from PA, I have a personal relationship with the food at Venice House.

Unfortunately, the only pizza in Kelowna I could honestly compare to Venice House in quality, texture, price, and spirit... was Olympia Greek Taverna (RIP)

That's what they mean by "Old School" pizza. None of this hipster bullshit.

On another note, Good Brothers in Rutland is pretty close to TJs Pizza... if they're hurting for TJs lol.

7
therealyeff•

Most accurate answer here so far. There really isn't a comparison to be found for pizza here to places like Venice House in Prince Albert / Saskatoon. I'm from Saskatoon originally, Kelowna doesn't have the ratio of Greek restaurants to non-Greek of 2.5:1 like you see there. lol

3

Yup. I miss all of those Greek family restaurants run by Persians... where every place has their own special dry ribs/Caesar combo for under $15. You just can't get that in Kelowna.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
angieOkanagan•

What about Famoso?

0
winkey98•

That's what they mean by "Old School" pizza. None of this hipster bullshit.

outta curiousity, what do you find bullshit about the pizza at places like jackknife, antico, and dunnenzies? i'm no pizza aficionado but they've all been at least okay (consistently good in the case of jackknife). not as good as olympia but still pretty good

0

oh there's nothing bullshit about those pizzas, don't get me wrong. Dunnenzies has the best pizza in Kelowna by far.

I just knew exactly what OP was looking for... something a little less pretentious than those places.

1
whAtitisWhatitis21•

We all stopped listening to your opinion on pizza at “dunnenzies is the best pizza in Kelowna”

-1
j4lj4lj4l•

Jackknife brewing for the best square pies in Kelowna. Trust me.

5
jim_the_anvil•

Squares only on Sunday though.

2
UKtwo•

The neopolitan at Antico is probably about as close as you'd get. Its pretty good imo.

5
jason2k•

My Italian friend’s comments about that place:

  1. They serve some weird stuff she’s never seen in Italy, like gallina (chicken) pizza.
  2. Pizzas do look Italian, but their food is more like 1950s Sicilian style.

Also the owner is Greek. That said I think their pizzas are damn tasty and the service is great.

1
sudokoupe•

I would say your best bet is to visit Valoroso and ask Elisa about the style you’re looking for. she is the owner’s wife, and a phenomenal cook, and obviously born and raised in Italy. Otherwise, I would try Antico for something close, but not square.

2
WizardofFrost•

Years ago Peachland Pizza made a pizza similar to a Saskatchewan style one. Other than that, I'm sorry to tell you that I think you are out of luck. Greetings from another former P.A. resident.

2
Dalai-Lambo•

Jackknife

2
bikepacker67•

As an East Coaster, originally, I have just one question...

Who the heck thought it was a good idea to put toppings UNDER the cheese???

They're called toppings for a reason. I never saw that until I moved to BC.

Yechhhh.... slimy pepperoni, instead of curled at the edges, crispy circles of delight.

2
OpenSector•

I'm pretty sure I know what kind of pizza you're referring to, and I've been looking for it for years in Kelowna. Basically going down the list of every pizza place I can find.

I know it as "New England / Greek style" pizza, usually found in Greek restaurants. I wasn't lucky enough to try Olympia Greek Taverna pizza before it burned down, but hopefully they will be back up and running soon.

The closest I've come is Hansen's pizza. I'm yet to try Good Brothers or Jackknife.

2
BustermanZero•

Maybe Antico? Not entirely sure what style you mean.

1
Frshmon•

Poor question! Papito’s or Hansen’s probably your best bet.

3
1337xyx•

Antico is delicious

1
nsboundOP•

I have never had the pizza in Prince Albert and I am just using the wording that they are using. Sorry if it is vague

0
felderosa•

Papitos hella good, also there's the classic dunnenzies

0†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Ryan_PVP•

I dont know about square, but good brothers and k-town both have next level pizza

1
Time_Trade_8774•

Unlikely. Hard to find good pizza in Kelowna.

-4
felderosa•

What is wrong with your head

Dunnenzies, papitos.... Gawdamn

-4
Time_Trade_8774•

I didn’t like Dunn enzies. No Better than Dominoez. Haven’t tried the other one

-1†
felderosa•

What pizza do you like, Kelowna or elsewhere?

2
DaKloose•

Go to antico, it’s the best tasting pizza I have ever had

1
whAtitisWhatitis21•

Exactly lol. Papitos is 10 times better then dunnenzies hype pies

1