Interesting Hypothetical dilema

False Accusation

So your lazing at the quiet end of the pool at an all inclusive resort. Suddenly it becomes apparent that a young girl (maybe 10yo by the look of her) has come off her inflatable and is now panicking in the water, you look for the parents but everyone including resort staff seems to be at the other end of the pool where there is loud music playing. You feel that you should wade into the pool to rescue her, especially since she is now floating face down and motionless, but you hesitate. DO YOU

Rush to the other end of the pool to alert staff or find the parents which may take say additional 30 to 60 seconds, and this kid has stopped breathing. This is the safe option but you will be criticised for not doing the heroic thing.

Wade in and grab the girl who then may then start breathing, struggling and crying. But you are aware that there is a fair chance that you could be accused of molestation by the parents of the very girl you was saving, get accused of being a paedophile, subsequently arrested and FUCKED FOR LIFE!

This happened to a friend of mine and he didn't go in the water because of the above concerns and I AGREE with his decision, even if there was a small chance the girl could have drowned here.

The girl was ok in the end. But how sad is this situation, and what would you have done?

Posted Sep 11, 2021, 8:44 AM UTC · edited

4514
mild-apsy•

Not nearly as severe, but I was at a busy playground with my kids and there was a young (maybe 3 years old) girl crying at the top of a small slide. This section was off to the side of the main playground and seemed intended for smaller kids. I stopped and asked her name and where her parents were, she told me and I was shocked that they were sitting almost 100 yards away. I asked her if she wanted down and to go to her parents and she said yes, so I helped her down by picking her up and putting her on the ground. I looked off to the side to check on my oldest kid (wife had other two) and the little girl ran off to her parents.

I was like "oh shit, be careful kid!“ as she ran to her parents, but then I thought "fuck, I just put my hands on someone else's kid." Even though it was innocent and I was just helping a crying kid, it's so fucked up that my reaction was to just walk away from the situation and stay with my own kid rather than all of us walk to these absentee parents.

20

100 yards is the length of exactly 897.76 'Standard Diatonic Key of C, Blues Silver grey Harmonicas' lined up next to each other.

10
converter-bot•

100 yards is 91.44 meters

6
converter-bot•

100 yards is 91.44 meters

4
[deleted]•

What a nightmare.

9
[deleted]•

Could be nature's way of reducing the biased, Misandrist hate population.

2
Immortal2344455•

I would not jump in there , with the Knowledge that i could be accused a Pedophile . In fact would tell some of the Lifeguards there and let them save her .

7

Simple, go to her aid whilst shouting for assistance.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Speaker7•

Nah this one is easy, you start screaming for help the moment you notice something is an emergency, and continue screaming for help as you rush in to pull their head above water. No one can accuse someone of molesting a child in public that is actively trying to draw attention to it. Granted you have zero obligation to do anything but that's what I would do so I could sleep at night peacefully.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2

Yeah. It's concerning how so many people are living life so terrified of these outlandish scenarios. It's like refusing to leave the house whenever it looks like it could rain because you may be killed by lightning.

I've read hundreds of articles about men saving people in pools. Zero articles about a man jailed for being a pedophile after saving someone.

0†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
thealphateam•

There was a story of some royal princess drowning because no one was allowed to touch her.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
somirion•

10 yo child can say that she was drowning and you werent there. If you have 30-60s to go to parents, you probably have a phone to make A video how shes drowning if you are afraid. I would just help her. Why would A pedophile give A child back to parents? They would maybe tell you that you are A pedo, but just because they are afraid and they feel mad at themselves. Is story like that (with accusation of being a pedo and damage to life later) even possible, or is it something like fantasy why you dont ride horses, because it could be an unicorn?

1
Bojack35•

Always go and help' not a difficult decision.

It's instinct to help a child. Sod any potential negative reaction. Lets be honest you aren't going to jail for helping a drowning kid.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

What do you do if it’s a 10 year old boy?

0