How big were the PvP scaling changes during Open Beta really? [Spreadsheet in replies]

Video

Posted Sep 16, 2021, 3:41 PM UTC

10785
CageyT•

No matter what side of the fence you stand that video an analysis was excellent. As someone who cringes with spreadsheets, this was done in an approachable and we'll understood manner. Excellent work.

31
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thanks a lot! Been trying to make the spreadsheets bit easier to follow, glad it works!

9
XtremeLeecher•

Excellent content a subscribed really Nice way to put data in a digestible format

We PvPers seriously hope AGS comes to their senses and get something close to CBT scaling for the health of the future of PvP interaction in NW

4
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thanks a lot!

1
Tonetality•

Couldn't have said it better myself.

2
MC_Knight24•

What analysis? What data? Am I the only one he thought his video was shit and explained nothing? There is zero data from the previous closed beta to compare it to. We already knew there was pvp scaling, this didn't tell us anything new. The title says, "How big were the pvp scaling changes" Well...how big were they? They were never answered. All he did was a work up of the scaling in open beta but there is no comparison from the closed beta. Is the difference 10%, 15%, 50%? In terms of breaking down open PvP beta that information was there but there was zero information from the difference between the two.

-21
CageyT•

Ummm he was just stating fact. Higher level players during open beta hits two times harder then players at same level. He has previous videos talking about closed beta levels. Jesus man, anti-pvp scalers sound like anti-maskers. Calm down, and don't call someone's hard work shit. Good grief.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

-11
CageyT•

He did in earlier videos man you have to compare the numbers from both. He puts in a lot of work and gets a lot of data. Calling his work shit is disrespectful as shit. Do you have videos with tons of data?. If not respect the hustle and move the fuck on. Disrespectful as all hell.

5

Bro take a breath... It's just a game and the OP put in time and effort. If you didn't care for it, just move on. I'm worried about you having an aneurism!

2

Finally, a PVP scaling thread with actual information!

Looks like scaling wasn't as dramatic as some claimed here, but certainly steep enough to make fights noticeably less fair with ~10 levels' difference. I wouldn't be surprised if some of the more sensational 3-shot reports were true due to the higher level player wearing faction gear and using burst damage skills against light armored lowbies. I'm curious what the power differential would've looked like if the higher level had full faction armor.

I wonder if the devs envision faction armor as serving as a sort of equalizer between higher level, slightly less geared PVE players and lower level PVP players who have the tokens to spare?

Thanks for putting in the effort here and approaching the subject with some objectivity, this is exactly what I've been looking for. Subscribed

24
Iuslez•

The difference he shows i damage is very significant for characters only 10 level apparts. Fights will often happen with 30 or even 40 level difference, numbers will be crazy.

I'd have been interested to see what happens with bigger differences.

As for your claim about 3 shots, i was personnaly getting 2 shot on the 3rd day of OB. +45 fire mages did over 50% of my health bar per heavies. Abilities would have probably oneshot me.

I was in full faction gear, 50% con, mix of light/medium armor, level 20. Granted, level 20 is probably one of the worst spot: your level 15 faction gear gets weaker and you don't have yet amrine gear.

11
CallMeBlitzkrieg:white: Marauders on the cross•

I mean, per the video:

level 15 vs level 36 with on level gear + stat allocation was literally double damage

I would imagine low levels are significantly less likely to have level-appropriate gear also.

edit: Also also, the video was using grey hatchet light attacks, instead of reality where high level player also has a more fleshed out ability tree, which also massively increases effectiveness.

In open beta I specifically got almost 3 hit by a hatchet (not from behind) using rush + one light swing

8

I'm of the opinion that CBT scaling was better overall, but I can tolerate noticeable (dis)advantage at a 20 level differential. I agree that this is too much advantage though, and actually a bit more severe than I had expected. Hopefully Amazon makes a number of carefully considered scaling changes before launch.

6
CallMeBlitzkrieg:white: Marauders on the cross•

I really hope the devs don't listen to a lot of the people on this subreddit that constantly straw man about people asking for perfect balance.

I don't mind high level players having a pretty distinct advantage.

I was really frustrated to the point I just turned off flagging in OB eventually because this guy (and others, not as extreme) basically 3 hit me while I did ~5-10% hp/hit

9
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Just to quickly clarify, the scenario in which the 36 had double the damage isn't the one that uses the grey hatchet, in the grey hatchet case the increase was "only" 36%. The double damage scenario applies with a level-appropriate hatchet!

4
thygrief•

Yeah, people here were crying about getting 2 shot by someone 3 levels higher than them, and that it was basically impossible to win.

4
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thank you!

The last test I did for the hits to kill was full faction armor vs full faction armor - but obviously the difference would be much bigger if the lower level player didn't have faction armor!

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-12
BerserkRonin•

I have 3 shot a fire staff user with my fire staff so no.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-12
BerserkRonin•

It was 3 heavy attacks lol. Do you think other weapons aren't capable of doing similar damage??

7
itsmysecondday•

Video in other thread where he walks up and light attacks a lowbie for 900 a swing.. 3 hits him. The dmg scaling gets way worse the bigger the gap.

4
VyrilGaming•

Don't you get tired of being wrong all the time, and getting down voted into oblivion ?

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
VyrilGaming•

You care about karma? You can also see my 6 year inactive period as well.

I was just talking about the downvotes for how wrong you are when it comes to newworld, no idea where you karma farm.

1
itsmysecondday•

TLDR you will never beat someone once the gap is 15+ levels and they have level appropriate gear on. Aint no one out skilling 10+ hits (after heals prob 20+ and not enough burst).

23
ccccc_mm•

You will still clap noobs who think they are hot shit for having some levels.

Just wait 2 weeks and see a lvl 25 try fighting a lvl 60. Hopefully they are sensible and at least cap the lvl benefit to 10 levels above. 30% benefit from overleveling is pretty much as far as it can go, before ruining pvp for any new player after a month.

5†
itsmysecondday•

You would hope they redo it.. or straight revert it to CB version or something much closer to it.

12
OmNomCakes•

I mean it's balancing. Going from one extreme back to the other would be silly. They're going to look for a decent middle ground.

1
itsmysecondday•

The issue is CB wasnt at any extreme. The 'low level advantage' was purely the high levels having non-level appropriate gear while the low levels were in best gear for their level. GEAR MATTERED and that was completely ignored by the idiots saying low levels were stronger.

7
VyrilGaming•

The middle ground still isn't worth somebody to flag.

They still won't have a chance.

1
skynet119•

have we had an official response yet? concerns me with 11 days to go I can't find anything on the devs reaction to the community's concerns here

1
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1s1vDcCAewLBfCrcACgm9oeGKclRbrRqykwyax-tf94I/edit?usp=sharing

For any questions, please refer to the video first, that should hopefully answer anything that may be unclear! If not, I'll likely reply tomorrow, getting late here!

14
JRPGFan_CE_org:white: Mage For Life•

Late? It's like 2am when you posted this :P

Anyways, this is a good video.

2
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Hey, I'm trying to get back to a reasonable schedule before launch runs it again! :D Thank you :)

5

2am? So still 4 hours before bedtime?

2
JRPGFan_CE_org:white: Mage For Life•

Yeah.

3
Orefeus•

Yup I totally agree, those are in fact numbers

1
Dixa•

what so many just ignore is how pvp games shake out months after release.

the closed beta scaling was perfect. lower levels had a fighting chance if they had the skill. why is this important?

the period in which the majority of the playerbase is in levelling mode is finite. 2 maybe three months. at that point the majority of the active playerbase will be 60.

allowing level 60's easy kills of players half their level or lower will stifle new player retention. the game will slowly lose momentum and with this being amazon and not an established game company they are more likely than not to abandon ship as soon as sales start to slump.

want a recent real-world example of this in action? look no further than wow classic pvp servers and how after a couple of months nearly all of the servers were 90% one faction. no one wants to be a permanent victim or in only the victim role for an extended period of their gameplay time in a pvp game. that is going to happen here - people are going to delete their characters and reroll them to join the dominant faction.

one of the problems the average pvp player has is one that is entirely in their brains: this short term gains mentality. so few pvp players think about the long term health of the games they make frantic rushes in when they first launch. and honestly, enough so-called "pvp players" are base cowards and want easy guaranteed kills and wins that stupid decisions like what happened in open beta happen. most of those whining about the closed beta balance would not last 2 seconds in a free for all loot everything you are wearing pvp mmorpg. y'know, the real pvp games.

13
AaronWYL•

And there's a significant reason this will be even worse in and for New World - the game actively encourages max level players to go back and pvp in those low level zones. It could kill the game even more quickly than in other games we've seen. If there's 10% of the playerbase who just plows through to level 60 to farm low level zones it's going to stop open world pvp dead in it's tracks.

I've even seen some people in favor of scaling say things like "well I do think a level 20 should have no shot against a level 60." Absolutely not - not with this game design. Even Warhammer Online 13 years ago had the foresight to see that if you make pvp a huge part of your game you have to give every level player a zone to do that where you'll be roughly on equal footing.

9
olivierpo•

Very informative video!

I would be very interested in seeing how the damage would look if you equipped level appropriate gear, but had everyone spec full con instead of str. It seems to me that constitution in pvp is still the most efficient stat, so I am wondering if that holds for large level differences between players.

As always your work is super appreciated and I look forward to all your "analysis" video uploads! Keep it up brother!

9
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thanks a lot!

Con efficiency is definitely still high, but cramming that into this video along with everything else would've been a bit overkill, I think! :D I very recently made a video testing level 30 con scaling vs hybrid vs str, so that should give a very decent idea of what outcome to expect in this scenario, since it's a similar level range. Since we were both running PvP gear in the last test, we had a bunch of con anyways!

7
olivierpo•

I've seen it! The reason I ask is because of diminishing returns for con and how they factor in scaling damage to hp.

Also, do you have a link to the spreadsheet you use in this video (the con one)?

3
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Will add that to my general data sheet in a few days, just need to clean it up a bit first! :)

2
Nhymn•

anecdotal but what friends and I found was you may survive longer and possibly long enough to make it to a town or to teammates but you just couldn't output the damage needed to secure kills. With the current scaling, you essentially need to have put all your points into your primary attribute to have enough damage output to compete with higher levels, especially 10+ levels or higher. We were all on the lower end of the level scale so we couldn't test the high level vs low-level con setups.

3
hearderofsheeple•

This... is content creation. Thanks for all the work you guys put in.

7
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thank you!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

I honestly think they were just trying to test the other extreme end in a scenario where the level gap between players wouldn't be too big. So I'm expecting they'll find a middle ground between the current and previous values.

4
Silent331•

Playtesting is for chumps when you have chumps like us to do it for them.

3
Shebalied•

Nice video. I think if they lowered the scale back some there could be a sweet spot. So, if the gap from well geared level 15 would not take as much damage from a 60, that would be a good balance. Maybe have the largest gap be a 40 % increase that would be ok. You should not be attacking max level people as a fresh level 15 toon, but you can contribute in a large scale fight and not be worthless.

6
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thank you! Fully agree!

3
KarstXT•

Excellent video, thank you for testing.

This is in-line with what I suspected was going on. It seems the game calculates: your GS compared to maximum available GS, opponent's GS compared to their maximum available GS and then the absolute level different of the players and makes the scaling adjustments accordingly.

The reason I suspected this is the higher levels were getting destroyed in some cases by lower levels. This makes sense, not saying it's how it should be but let me elaborate. As you go up starting...around 40-45? Your GS compared to maximum GS starts to drop off a lot, to the point where players are 470-480 by the time they hit 60 and go up to 520-something with faction gear. However their maximum available GS at these level ranges is much much higher (600 at 60). So the game was assuming they had terrible gear when in fact they had pretty average gear, so the scaling would either not kick in or punish them.

What I had wondered and been concerned about is if the game negatively knocks players that put Con in but this doesn't in any way seem to be the case given how successful Con builds are (i.e. if the game was scaling off relative level-HP expectations but it seems to be GS) so this shouldn't be an issue. People have also voiced concerns about whether or not the game punishes them for higher weapon levels or for having more gear perks but I don't think there's any evidence to support this and it's just low-hanging fruit.

Things like weapon level, gear perks (both higher quality & more in general), additional attributes from jewelry, food buffs, potions etc are already going to be significant advantages.

I am quite concerned about how they'll handle the 45-60 scaling however, as the first few waves of players aren't going to be able to maintain 'expected GS' because it's simply not how the game works. Later on people will be able to buy/twink as the market saturates so maybe the fix is that they temporarily lower 'expected GS' at these levels then increase it to the normal expected values ~1 month in when the trading post is saturated with at-level gear for 45-59 players.

5
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thanks a lot! You raise a very interesting point. Under more "fair" scaling conditions, that part will definitely be hard to solve. Technically, they could take the player level almost entirely out of the equation and balance between gear scores (and att points) only, but that would mean that there would be very little benefit in getting high end gear at level 60. The topic will definitely remain a double-edged sword because of what you pointed out.

2
Iuslez•

As you go up starting...around 40-45? Your GS compared to maximum GS starts to drop off a lot, to the point where players are 470-480 by the time they hit 60 and go up to 520-something with faction gear. However their maximum available GS at these level ranges is much much higher (600 at 60).

That's interesting, I never got that high level. Why is gearscore dropping at that range ? You'd expect as leveling get slower that you actually have time to get more level-appropriate gear, whereas in the low levels you outlevel you gear before being able to collect full sets.

Scaling could be a bit more subtle and use tiers of GS instead of max GS: what the game should consider as "equal" in the calculation is the GS of same tiers, like a full level 25 rare GS is equivalent to a full level 45 rare GS, full uncommon vs full oncommon, rare vs rare, and so on (I actually assumed this is how it worked because it is obviously the only way to make it balanced)

1
KarstXT•

Why is gearscore dropping at that range ?

I would guess gear watermarking and players not knowing about it is part of it. That and they likely wanted to increase the gear grind artificially. It's kind of an awful system, I hate when games do this and I'm not surprised its causing issues elsewhere.

Scaling could be a bit more subtle and use tiers of GS instead of max GS: what the game should consider as "equal" in the calculation is the GS of same tiers, like a full level 25 rare GS is equivalent to a full level 45 rare GS, full uncommon vs full oncommon, rare vs rare, and so on (I actually assumed this is how it worked because it is obviously the only way to make it balanced)

This is just as bad as watermarking tbh. Currently a higher GS green is better than a lower blue - and honestly that's fine because the extreme majority of gear perks are awful and just fluff (I mean there are more perks that can roll on armor that you can't use than you can use due to weapon perks rolling on them). I think the system is fine, it's just watermarking is bad and should be removed - it will be anyways as trading post gets filled with cheap high GS items people can just walk & up buy.

1
avelleo:white: Thanks for Adding 10% Luck while Flagged•

they gone be mad at this one lol

4
Arikash•

One question, and you address this a little bit, but during the first round of experiments you found that with the lvl 15 hatchet, and no strength difference all enemies hit you for ~176 dmg, not matter what, which is roughly 5% of your health.

When you swung at them, you found an increase in base damage, was that increase scaled to their health as well? Like were you hitting the level 36 player for 5% of their health, and the level 15 player for 5% of their health, or did the % drop as your opponent increased in level?

4
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Ohh, very interesting question! I unfortunately didn't measure that. I could eyeball it based on my own health data now, but the problem is that I don't have clean data without gear equipped. My initial impression would be that it doesn't quite match. Going back through my old recordings, my health (with gear) at level 16 was 1366. When not running full PvP gear, my health at 37 was 4500 with a similar attribute distribution. So we should be looking at at least doubled health or more between 15 to 36. Since the damage only went from 206 to 261, I don't think it matched the health scaling.

3
Axxtasy•

Great content man. Very well done.

3
DukeSlothOP:white: Content Creator•

Thank you!

2
wildjaw:yellow: Wolfpack•

In the closed Beta it wasn't even ground - higher levels still had an advantage. But I do agree. Make it more even.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
aypalmerart•

i think around 30% should be the highest amount, fir scaling, basically a level 15 vs a 60 should probably be about a 30% advantage, personal opinion though

1†
ZyraX•

A level 60 in what gear? Because level 15 should stand nearly zero chance against a level 60 with best items in the game, otherwise it will feel pointless to even progress in this game. Why waste time and hundreds of hours for gearing if level 15 is only 30% weaker. What should be 500 vs 600 gs advantage on lvl 60 be then?

-3†
aypalmerart•

serious question, what is improved by having pvp fights that are 100% unwinnable?

​

what the point of such an encounter?

8
cptdino•

This.

Why would I level and grind for over 1k hours so a guy with 10 hours level 15 to hit almost the same or more just cause I have way more stats, gear and hp?

Makes literally no sense. Not even MOBAs do this, whenever you're 2 levels behind you're done. Farm and try to reach him or lose every fight unless with a 3-4 man gank.

I got no clue where this "fair fight" concept comes from.

-5
aypalmerart•

mobas, the whole game is designed that leveling is the point of the game, if you are low level, you lost the game.

mobas start each match with no difference, you can buy whatever champ and instantly compete.

and, you aren't grinding for 1k hours for power over another player, if the game isn't rewarding you for it. If you play for 1k hours, it will be because you enjoy the game.

7
cptdino•

Now tell me, what MMORPGs point is?

And starting both at equal level... You both started at the same time, the difference is one has legendary items, 30-50 levels above and countless expeditions, exploration and skills above the other cause one started days, weeks or even months before the other.

1
spcrowe•

True man, I guess u won't feel so bad either when the guy with 2000 hours comes along and makes u his bitch.

3
cptdino•

If he has more items and level sure I won't care dude. it's a freaking MMORPG where items, theory crafting and skill all come to play.

0
achoo84•

Should we ad scaling for out numbered fights?

​

Its an mmo I feel theres too much emphasis on this right now. Open world is not just 1v1.

If people really want equal fights there should be a lvl 15 arena to scratch that itch. Have lvls and items normalized there.

I'm really glad this video came out to point the finger at the gear and not the levels.

If you were to craft at the start for your gear you would be lvl 30 in lvl 20 gear compare that to a lvl 25 in pvp gear. So now scale that lvl 30 down and even though he has lvls you made it even easier for the lvl 25 to kill the lvl 30 than it would have been if you didn't scale.

​

There are too many variables to make this the issue that it is.

on top of that are you going to put a curve to this scaling? Or are legendary going to be insignificantly better than pvp set?

-6
aypalmerart•

multiple opponents is not a huge wall, you just need more people, being useless against most of your opponents can't be fixed without a large amount of hours, during those hours, your gameplay is bad,

even if you gather more people, you are mostly useless in the fight.

3
achoo84•

How is that any different than a more geared player? Just get more players Kite them while the other ranges them

0
DemodiX•

It's different because it involves more people, bruh

2
achoo84•

The similarities are that you adapt to the situation with the tools available in the game design.

2
aypalmerart•

the open beta makes it so 4 under leveled dudes cannot kill someone sufficiently higher.

but aside from that gathering people is something everyone has access to from the first time they can pvp. Being effectively unkillable essentially negates the gameplay of lower level players, who probably are interested in pvp, not getting killed by unbeatable game mechanics

1
achoo84•

What level discrepancy did you see that happen at?

Beyond what was shown in this video obviously.

Multiple players killing you has the same result as a high lvl player killing you.

My gear was garbage on the last day of beta. I had no problems feeling useful in pvp because range and positioning.

1