r/DnD•
ChillFactory

In Forgotten Realms is there a Guide for the dead?

Misc

It looks like it could be Charon but I'm not sure if there is another entity that would be a more apt fit. Charon's responsibility seems to include a price, so does he greet all souls? What about those who do not pay?

Posted Sep 16, 2021, 6:48 PM UTC

1411
thomarCR 1/4•

It's a bit different for each pantheon. Usually you go straight to your own deity's domain and get welcomed by one of their celestial (or fiendish) servants, but Charon is a minor figure in the Greek pantheon, so he would probably guide anyone worshiping a deity in that pantheon. For example, if you worship the Norse pantheon and fall in glorious battle, you might get a valkyrie to guide your soul to the afterlife. The catch-all deity for wayward souls would be Kelemvor.

4
ChillFactoryOP•

Thank you! That's interesting, so its based on what you believed in life. Does that mean Kelemvor would cover those who didn't explicitly worship a specific deity?

Would if you happen to know if there's someone who "sorts" the souls that pass? So if you believed in Norse gods then the "sorter" hands you off to the Norse gods. If you believe in Tyr, then you get handed off to Tyr, etc.

3
fishnuggetDM•

So iirc with the forgotten realms it's a multi step process

  1. Go to the Fugue Plane (endless expanse where souls wander aimlessly)
  2. While wandering you may be convinced by a devil to reject your patron and get benefits in hell. This takes you to the nine hells where you become a devil
  3. Alternatively your soul may be stolen from the Fugue plane by demons wherein you become a demon
  4. Depending on how faithful you were after some amount of time a representative of your god will appear and take you to your afterlife (This could take centuries if you weren't very faithful)
  5. If you are not claimed you are judged by the lord of the dead (or wink out) (this is where kelemvor comes in)
  6. If you are judged to be Faithless or False (no deity/god belief or betrayed your faith's commitments) then Kelemvor would judge you and bind you to a task (False) or to the wall of the Faithless that surrounds the city of judgement wherein your soul is eventually ground into non-existence

Naturally there's some minutae once your individual soul leaves the Fugue plane (could become demonic larvae, or devil lemure, or you have to pass through Urogalan because you're a halfling, or meet with Naralis Analor to get there anyways) but generally speaking it's more or less how that goes. WOTC is currently trying to retcon the wall of the faithless out of the setting (removing it from PDF and new printings of the swords coast adventuring guide for example)

6
Phoenyx_Rose•

Why are they trying to remove it? That sounds like such a cool concept in a world where the gods are real

1
fishnuggetDM•

Iirc they were getting negative feedback about the concept of “believe it be tortured in a wall until your soul dissolves”

1
thomarCR 1/4•

Thank you! That's interesting, so its based on what you believed in life. Does that mean Kelemvor would cover those who didn't explicitly worship a specific deity?

Precisely. His main area of concern is False and Faithless mortals.

Would if you happen to know if there's someone who "sorts" the souls that pass? So if you believed in Norse gods then the "sorter" hands you off to the Norse gods. If you believe in Tyr, then you get handed off to Tyr, etc.

Whether or not you know doesn't matter, the gods are in charge of sorting souls. Whatever arrangement your chosen deity has with their pantheon is how it works.

2
PenguinDnD•

There are a number of chthonic deities in the FR. Plus each pantheon has their own take on what happens when you die.

However, it's your table and if you want Charon to be a guide for the recently departed you can.

1
C4st1gator•

In the dragon pantheon Chronepsis would guide you to the appropriate afterlife. The Watcher doesn't talk, but he's not big on punishment. His judgement process is closer to a sorting algorithm by alignment. Dracoliches get punished, however. They belong to Faluzure, who is so evil, Tiamat advises her chromatics to avoid dracolichdom.

1
mightierjakeBard•

Not the answer to your question, but the term in Greek mythology for gods like Charon, Thanatos and Hermes that guide people to the afterlife is "psychopomp", so perhaps you could use that term to narrow your search?

1
ChillFactoryOP•

My google fu seems to have failed me. That is indeed the right term, I tried looking around and found some homebrew stuff but nothing concrete. Very helpful to know the term though, thank you!

1
HWGA_Exandria•

Anubis is there. Nergal is there. Hades is there. Hel is there. (These are based off of actual mythological pantheons from Earth.)

Null, Jergal, Kelemvor, Dumathoin, Urogalan, Naralis Analor, or Kiaransalee are the D&D stand ins.

1