r/modnews•
kemitche

Moderators: Bans originate from the subreddit and other modmail tweaks

Hi mods,

I've pushed out a few tweaks to modmail. Please let me know if you encounter any issues.

The big one is that subreddit ban messages will now originate from the subreddit, not the moderator sending the ban. (The sender will still be noted in the moderation log).

The "message the moderators" link now has the PM "to" field filled in as "/r/<reddit>". The old, "#reddit" syntax will continue to work. Additionally, modmail now shows "/r/<reddit>" instead of "#<reddit>" above each message.

You may now reply to a message you send to a subreddit that you moderate.

Sending a PM to modmail should now have that message show up in your sent box.

For more info, see the [post on r/changelog](http://www.reddit.com/r/changelog/comments/pprrs/reddit_changes_minor_mail_tweaks_edition/)

Posted Feb 14, 2012, 10:43 PM UTC

286913
SQLwitch•

On behalf of the team at r/suicidewatch, I thank the FSM for you, and you for this:

subreddit ban messages will now originate from the subreddit, not the moderator sending the ban.

May His Noodly Appendage always guide you to the bugs faster than you can cook capellini.

(I'm a programmer myself; this is the blessing I would wish for.)

78
Dead_Rooster•

Do you guys get a lot trolls following you around after you ban them? I'd imagine you must get heaps of trolls.

13
SQLwitch•

Well, not heaps, but the ones we do get are awful. I think it takes a particularly twisted sort of psychopathology to make trolling suicidal people seem like fun.

47
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-11
ArchangelleArielle•

We've banned this asshole from SRS too.

-19
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-14
rabblerabble2000•

FACT: Brunt2 likes fapping to little girls.

Downvoting me doesn't change this FACT.

1
brunt2•

by banning them you encourage them to try harder and troll more. quit being retards. ps. downmodding me doesn't change this FACT

-14
herman_gill•

Thanks for all the good work you guys and gals do!

11
edubation•

YEAH

2
TG_Alibi•

I agree. This should have been the case all along. A very welcome and much needed change.

3
redtaboo•

I love you so much. Thank you! :)

51
kemitcheOP•

<3

37
ignatiusloyola•

Those are nice features. Thank you.

Any chance you can make it so that moderator removed submissions become locked? I am tired of taking flack for conversations that go on in removed submissions.

21
[deleted]•

Any chance you can make it so that moderator removed submissions become locked?

That would be absolutely amazing. For example when personal information is being discussed, it would be beneficial to lock the thread at the point of removal.

12
redtaboo•

<3

20
thebigdonkey•

<3

12
demented_pants•

<3

12
jaxspider•

Now Kiss.jpg

6
ugnaught•

subreddit ban messages will now originate from the subreddit, not the moderator

love it.

23
EagleFalconn•

You're a wonderful person. I'm going to abuse your wonderfulness and request another feature: The ability to initiate a modmail to a user so that other moderators can see the whole conversation and it doesn't have to happen in PM.

17
kemitcheOP•

That's an interesting use case. Unfortunately, making it work well will require a (much needed) overhaul to the messaging system.

10
EagleFalconn•

It's a feature that I'd like to have, but its not actually at the top of my feature request list. I put it in here because its related to modmail, but if there are other things you're working on already and my request is hard to implement....feel free to put it off for a while.

Thanks again for making these changes!!

8
kemitcheOP•

It's a worthwhile feature request :-) Just technically difficult (in comparison to this set of changes)

9
V2Blast•

You could ask the user to message the mods so that they're all included. (Maybe even include the link in your message...)

1

You may now reply to a message you send to a subreddit that you moderate.

Sending a PM to modmail should now have that message show up in your sent box.

Thanks, those have always been bothering me.

12
snang•

Quick suggestion...

Would it be a big deal to turn that "via r/subreddit" text into a link to the actual subreddit?

11
kemitcheOP•

I broke that. I'm fixing it :)

11
snang•

Right on. Didn't remember if it was a link before or not. Much appreciated.

5
LieutenantClone•

Yeah, it used to be a link and it was super handy, especially when you moderate several subreddits. :)

4
[deleted]•

Awesome. I was about to ask the same thing.

2
RedSquaree•

If I send two consecutive messages via modmail will they now show in the correct order? Instead of

  • Someone sends mods a msg
  • My last response
  • My 2nd last response
11
kemitcheOP•

This is probably unchanged, but certainly a bug in need of fixing.

9
ChingShih•

Thank you, we've needed these for a while.

Keep it up!

10
nix0n•

Man, I misread that and almost banned originate. :|

8
culturalelitist•

Okay, I just read a ban notification in my modmail and I have a suggestion for improvement. Even though it's in my messages, it keeps the subject line, "you've been banned." At first I thought I had been banned from my own subreddit (it was in /r/metamoderatorjerk, so I wouldn't have been surprised). Is there any chance you could make this clearer?

8
kemitcheOP•

As noted elsewhere (sorry, on my phone), I'm going to investigate alternatives to dumping those messages in modmail.

7
masgrada•

Keep the current system! It's a great deterrent for subreddits going on banning rampages.

Although, the subject line should be changed to something like, "[user] is banned from [subreddit]" so there is no ambiguity to anyone receiving the message.

8
RobotAnna•

It's making some subreddits that use heavy moderation for good reasons unnecessarily difficult to moderate, though. Even if you don't agree with others' moderating style, it's their right to moderate their subreddit as they see fit.

-7
masgrada•

I know you like to do that over at SRS, but it's not a right. Quite honestly, it's a pretty detestable mode of operation.

11
youcunthurt•

You are a real silly cunt, though I understand it is difficult getting over being raped. There have been numerous mods from subs with a lot of subscribers who have said this won't affect them at all. Just because a bunch of rape victims want to ban 95% of reddit to feel safe from sexual attacks, doesn't mean the rest of us have to play along.

-7
Maxion•

IMO that's only a "noted" issue on one subreddit where they like to ban people that don't even post in their own subreddit (I've certainly never posted there and I've been banned).

I think I speak for all other mods when I ask you to spend your limited time improving other moderator tools.

5
yellowmix•

Thank you. The safety of many people depended on this change.

7
db2•

Internet: Serious business, life or death apparently!

You might want to step back from the keyboard, maybe go outside for a few minutes.

0
V2Blast•

It's not yellowmix that treats the internet as serious business. It's the subscribers to many popular subreddits that love going on witch-hunts and harassing mods in real life.

3
db2•

You know, if that was an issue before it was always an option to create a dummy account just to moderate with.

1
V2Blast•

It was an issue before. And yes, some people had to resort to that before reddit made this change.

2
Zallarion•

But isn't it also important to know who banned you when it comes to a possible unfair ban/power abuse?

7
kemitcheOP•

Replies to a ban will now go to the entire modmail inbox instead of jus the sender; if there's concern of abuse, the other mods of a subreddit are in a position to address that.

22
smischmal•

Ah. Thank you then. At first I didn't like it, but noting that puts it in a whole new light.

3
NihiloZero•

Other mods might be able to address the abuse of a particular mod, but if that mod is the top mod they may not be able to actually do much of anything about it. I'm not saying this is a bad idea, what you are presenting here, but I want to be clear about its limitations.

2
kemitcheOP•

While true, this is no different than before. The difference is that the banned user has to focus their rage against the subreddit's entire mod team, rather than lambasting a single individual.

6
feelbetternow•

I did a test, and found that if the banned user replies to the ban message, the message does go to modmail; the problem is, if the banned user checks their "sent" folder, the banning mod's name is shown as the addressee for the message. If the point of this feature is to avoid harassment of the banning mod, this might be a problem.

1
kemitcheOP•

Thanks for the report. I'll get that fixed up.

1
shavera•

Huzzah! Huzzah! Huzzah!

6
Kubaker1•

[=I(:•B) r/Nerdist_Fans thanks you. May you take this chipmunk in a top hat with my gratitude.

5

You may now reply to a message you send to a subreddit that you moderate.

You have no idea how helpful this is. I constantly send my fellow mods in IAmA messages that I say "SHIT I WISH I DIDN'T SEND THAT!" and could never reply to tell them to ignore it. THANK YOU!

5
[deleted]•

Thanks for the hard work! One small note - need to change the text on the message page (still says "# + reddit")

5
kemitcheOP•

Thanks for the note! I'll address that.

2
mkosmo•

Awesome, thank you so much! The next best thing to this would be the ability to add a note to a ban to indicate why they were banned (with links or explanations, etc)

5
xandr96•

May I get a heart please?

4
kemitcheOP•

<4

It's one better than <3

9
mkosmo•

But only a 1/4 chance of being >3 (and that's if we're only dealing with unsigned non-zero numbers, dude)

3
kemitcheOP•

Still better than "<3"

2
skarface6•

lik dis if u cry everytim

-6
betelgeux•

Excellent work! This is why I hang out on reddit. Idea, feedback, implementation and clear communication done RIGHT.

3
legatic•

is there any way we could have an option to light up the modmail icon any time there's something in http://www.reddit.com/r/mod/about/modqueue ?

I know this would suck for bigger subreddits, but I mod a few smaller ones and sometimes forget to check the modqueue because I only get one or two links a month in there. I'd love an option to be notified any time something was in there, though it should probably be opt-in to give mods of bigger subreddits a break.

Thanks!

3
kemitcheOP•

Interesting suggestion. Probably worthy of its own r/ideasfortheadmins post ;-)

4
legatic•

Haha, too right you are sir. Thanks! Posted there.

1
mkosmo•

RSS feed for your spam queue is always a good option.

Spam queue: http://www.reddit.com/r/REDDITNAME/about/spam/.rss

Reports queue: http://www.reddit.com/r/REDDITNAME/about/reports/.rss

2
douglasr007•

There's a userscript that does this but I don't know the direct link to it. The name of it is "Reddit Spam Notifier"

2
db2•

http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/115576

Doesn't work as well as it should IMO. This should be a RES feature though.

2
Maxion•

That would only work for smaller subreddits. for almost all larger subreddits the mod symbol is already almost constantly lit.

1
legatic•

I mod a few smaller [subreddits] and sometimes forget to check the modqueue because I only get one or two links a month in there

it should probably be opt-in to give mods of bigger subreddits a break.

I agree with you, but it would be very useful for those of us who mod smaller subreddits. Also, if this feature is opt-in by default, its existence would have no effect on mods of bigger subreddits.

5
ladfrombrad•

I mod a few small /r/'s too and use RES's /r/dashboard with a widget for the modqueue. You need to enter this below (as in snip off the preceding bit of the url) for it to work.

[r/mod](/r/mod)/about/modqueue

Might be worth a try!

2
Maxion•

Having it opt-in would be cool, yes.

1