Anarcho-capitalism does not oppose governance, it opposes democracy.
Anarcho-capitalism is not actually anarchy, because it doesn’t actually oppose governance.
It is fine with private entities taking sovereignty over all of the land in the country. It is fine with such private entities imposing whatever rules they want onto inhabitants, and using force on rule breakers, because they’re “trespassers” when they do something they aren’t allowed to on someone else’s land. It is fine with such private entities taxing inhabitants, so long as those taxes are called “rent”. It is fine with such private entities consolidating and monopolizing their sovereignty over all of the land in the country.
Most importantly, Anarcho-capitalism is fine with any number of individuals having to live their entire lives under the governance of such private entities. Because if none of these private entities deemed those people to be worthy of sacrificing and transferring land sovereignty, those people just didn’t earn freedom from a fair free market system.
In other words, Anarcho-capitalism is ok with a limited number of individuals having governmental authority across the entirety of the US. The only governance it truly opposes is democracy. Consider how capitalists view an equal distribution of wealth. This is how Anarcho-capitalism views an equal distribution of political representation and sovereignty.
Anarcho-capitalism believes it would be more efficient to let capitalism determine who “deserves” to make laws and govern the masses, in the same way that we currently use capitalism to determine who “deserves” to make company policies and manage employees.
In short, anarcho-capitalism is an authoritarian form of statehood and governance, trying to hide behind technically not being our modern conception of what a government is.
We are a community which claims to advocate the virtues of personal liberty. It is shameful that we debate whether an ideology which justifies child labor, indentured servitude, and the removal of civil rights could be more libertarian than ideologies which justify public schools and food stamps, because “taxation is theft.”
Posted Sep 18, 2021, 7:17 PM UTC
I don't think you understand anarchism nor do you understand free markets. Good try.
I understand anarchism well enough to know that anarcho-capitalism is just hiding behind it.
And if you don’t understand how inelastic supply can create natural monopolies of things like land, then you’re the one who doesn’t understand free markets.
Damn that inelastic demand for food and shelter sure can't be handled on a free market...oh wait...
Lets see, land, food and shelter. One of these things is not like the other…
What is shelter built on? What is food grown in?
It's really hard to have a monopoly without also having a monopoly on force. For example, while I purportedly own my home I still have to ask for permission to do a great many things to it. I have to pay a tax to continue to have the luxury of "owning" my property, if I fail to do so the people with a monopoly on force and land will come for me. Sounds like we are already living in a way that makes you concerned.
And a tenant of anarcho-calitalism is landowners having a monopoly on force within their territory. The ideology is certainly not pacifistic in terms of dealing with trespassers…
That would be wrong and you will not find any Libertarian anarchist making such an argument.