Anarcho-capitalism does not oppose governance, it opposes democracy.

Philosophy

Anarcho-capitalism is not actually anarchy, because it doesn’t actually oppose governance.

It is fine with private entities taking sovereignty over all of the land in the country. It is fine with such private entities imposing whatever rules they want onto inhabitants, and using force on rule breakers, because they’re “trespassers” when they do something they aren’t allowed to on someone else’s land. It is fine with such private entities taxing inhabitants, so long as those taxes are called “rent”. It is fine with such private entities consolidating and monopolizing their sovereignty over all of the land in the country.

Most importantly, Anarcho-capitalism is fine with any number of individuals having to live their entire lives under the governance of such private entities. Because if none of these private entities deemed those people to be worthy of sacrificing and transferring land sovereignty, those people just didn’t earn freedom from a fair free market system.

In other words, Anarcho-capitalism is ok with a limited number of individuals having governmental authority across the entirety of the US. The only governance it truly opposes is democracy. Consider how capitalists view an equal distribution of wealth. This is how Anarcho-capitalism views an equal distribution of political representation and sovereignty.

Anarcho-capitalism believes it would be more efficient to let capitalism determine who “deserves” to make laws and govern the masses, in the same way that we currently use capitalism to determine who “deserves” to make company policies and manage employees.

In short, anarcho-capitalism is an authoritarian form of statehood and governance, trying to hide behind technically not being our modern conception of what a government is.

We are a community which claims to advocate the virtues of personal liberty. It is shameful that we debate whether an ideology which justifies child labor, indentured servitude, and the removal of civil rights could be more libertarian than ideologies which justify public schools and food stamps, because “taxation is theft.”

Posted Sep 18, 2021, 7:17 PM UTC

13117
hypersonicpotatoescustom gray•

I don't think you understand anarchism nor do you understand free markets. Good try.

9
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

I understand anarchism well enough to know that anarcho-capitalism is just hiding behind it.

And if you don’t understand how inelastic supply can create natural monopolies of things like land, then you’re the one who doesn’t understand free markets.

-1†
thomasthemassyMises Caucus / Dave Smith 2024•

Damn that inelastic demand for food and shelter sure can't be handled on a free market...oh wait...

0†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Lets see, land, food and shelter. One of these things is not like the other…

5
thomasthemassyMises Caucus / Dave Smith 2024•

What is shelter built on? What is food grown in?

0†
hypersonicpotatoescustom gray•

It's really hard to have a monopoly without also having a monopoly on force. For example, while I purportedly own my home I still have to ask for permission to do a great many things to it. I have to pay a tax to continue to have the luxury of "owning" my property, if I fail to do so the people with a monopoly on force and land will come for me. Sounds like we are already living in a way that makes you concerned.

0†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

And a tenant of anarcho-calitalism is landowners having a monopoly on force within their territory. The ideology is certainly not pacifistic in terms of dealing with trespassers…

10
bhknbStatism is a Religion•

That would be wrong and you will not find any Libertarian anarchist making such an argument.

-1
AXSwiftvoluntaryist•

You're knocking these strawmen down as fast as you're putting them up! Great job, you've decimated over 200 years of thorough political theory in less than 2,000 words, they'll never recover!

9
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Just wait until I denounce monarchy, there’s thousands of years of political theory behind that one!

9
Anen-o-mevoluntaryist•

Gottem!

1
karmalizing•

How do you get lavacrete? Can you just buy it, or do you need to mix your own? Found your old post about it, and have been reading about 3d printing houses..

1
Anen-o-mevoluntaryist•

It's hard to obtain currently. I was able to get some flyash samples for testing.

Once we begin using it in bulk we will offer small batches for people to purchase and play with.

1
imaginefrogswithgunscustom red•

Thomas Hobbes been real quiet since this one dropped

1
AXSwiftvoluntaryist•

Can't wait! I'm sure you'll avoid all arguments they made and instead put forward your own beliefs upon what the monarchy is. It'll be devastating!

-2†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Damn you’re actually rolling with this analogy… I’m proud of you for being honest, at least.

5
imaginefrogswithgunscustom red•

I mean I don’t know what to tell you man, if an ideology can be dismantled in under 2,000 words maybe it just… isn’t very good?

I don’t really care what the theory says or what excuses an ancap can pull out about how akshually all the corporations have to follow the Norm Aggregation Principal and will benevolently do so, I prefer empirics over broad pseudo-intellectual platitudes. What the empirics show is that in every single example of the absence of a state, ostensibly private actors have filled the same role and become sovereign, just as OP describes. They haven’t been Cyberpunk sci fi dystopias because most didn’t happen in the modern era and the ones that did have happened in under-developed areas like Somalia where that’s not exactly feasible, but that’s pretty much what the same situation would look like in a developed, modern nation.

3
jmastaock•

East India Company lmao

1
Squalleke123•

I don’t really care what the theory says or what excuses an ancap can pull out about how akshually all the corporations have to follow the Norm Aggregation Principal and will benevolently do so

IMHO it's enough to state that it's better than what we have now: Them violating the NAP and then getting government bailouts whenever that violation doesn't prove profitable.

-1
imaginefrogswithgunscustom red•

Except if a corporation assumes sovereign power, it doesn’t have to lobby for a bailout, it can just directly extract the money from the people living under it by levying its own taxes. Anarcho capitalism just cuts out the middle man and does nothing else.

3
Squalleke123•

Except if a corporation assumes sovereign power,

There's only one way they could do that and it's with the explicit consent of a large majority of the population (larger than currently necessary for a government to do so).

And even then it would be a lot harder as they wouldn't have the monopoly on violence unless people explicitly give them that monopoly.

0
thomasthemassyMises Caucus / Dave Smith 2024•

Anarcho-capitalists don't recognize political authority as legitimate. That includes when private entities use political means, which I assume you mean when you say 'governance'.

I think you need to define 'governance' properly because it's not clear what you mean. If you mean political authority that would be incorrect, for example you cannot imprison or kill people in your house. The only power you have over people on your property who wish to not follow your rules is to eject them from your property. You cannot imprison, or kill, or tax, or conscript, or do anything else that political authority provides.

It's a bit of a meme that 'ancaps just want private government'. It might seem like that if you have no idea what anarcho-capitalism is or the theory behind it, but it's on you to actually be informed.

3
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

OK, so what if the US government just charged American citizens rent to live here. What if they gave criminals the option of doing a prison sentence to retain their citizenship, but if not they would just get deported?

My point is that land sovereignty is governance one way or another.

2
thomasthemassyMises Caucus / Dave Smith 2024•

The USA government doesn't have a legitimate claim to the territory the same way the Mafia doesn't have a legitimate claim to NYC.

And land sovereignty != governance. I already said why.

-2†
Jericho01Anarcho-Bidenism•

How do you decide who has a legitimate claim to land?

6
thomasthemassyMises Caucus / Dave Smith 2024•
2
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Ok so let’s say that someone has a “legitimate” land sovereignty, whatever that means.

Could they give someone the choice to voluntarily remain in a voluntary prison, to avoid being deported?

If someone didn’t agree to voluntary imprisonment, but also refused to leave, would that be trespassing? What degree of force would be permitted against trespassers?

3
thomasthemassyMises Caucus / Dave Smith 2024•

A voluntary prison is an oxymoron.

If you're wanted for a crime, try leaving the USA and see what happens.

2
hersheys40•

Read about public choice theory so you can stop romantizing democracy.

2†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

I appreciate your honesty about Anarcho-capitalism being founded upon skepticism of democracy. If only your comrades could drop the euphemisms, they would sound a lot like this.

3
hersheys40•

Democracy is just a form of conflict resolution, it has nothing to do with specific ideologies or political systems.

2
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

This statement implies that conflict resolution has nothing to do with political systems.

With all due respect, I consider the idea that democracy is political to be self evident, and not worth discussing. We can agree to disagree.

1
bhknbStatism is a Religion•

Democracy is a religion like any other system of political authority.

0
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

And I could say anarchocapitalism is a religion. I’ve heard antivaxxers say science is a religion, and Christians say atheism is a religion.

Now that we’ve stretched that word into meaninglessness, would you care to make an actual point?

1
bhknbStatism is a Religion•

Ok, what do ancaps hold faith in that is non-existent?

Political authority doesn't exist. There is no legitimate source or measurable force for one person to violently control others or in which their words carry a moral obligation to obey. Democracy is just a ritual by which you imbue someone with this invisible moral force and call it "legal". Thus, your belied, your faith, in the moralizing power of democracy is akin to a religion.

1
WanderingVirginia•

Anarcho capitalism is an oxymoronic propaganda term; there is no authoritarian branding of asset (aka Capital) that does not qualify as the rulership that anarchists find anathamic.

1
Squalleke123•

And here's why you're wrong:

In absence of a state how do people interact in the economy? The answer is pretty simple: through voluntary interactions.

What do you need in order to be able to have voluntary interactions? The right to bodily autonomy and the right to property. Without these you cannot exchange anything. And if you only have one of the two you'll be limited to only involuntary interactions.

If you accept these two statements you've in essence described anarchocapitalism. It's merely the idea that voluntary interaction is the natural way to structure an economy AND the realization that in order to be able to exchange goods and services you need ownership of those goods and services.

1
[deleted]•

Anarcho-Capitalism believes that in a pluralistic free market society, there will occasionally be entities which will try to gain monopoly. But without a state it will not be able to enforce a monopoly for very long.

As for what is meant by anarchy there are a lot of different possibile interpretations. There is no point in discussing the classical term in any great length. But the word from Greek means without an Archon, which refers to a period of instability and chaos when Athens failed to elect an Archon and the city fell into civil war and lawlessness.

The term in modern times has been readapted to mean something different. But the strongest and best known is that of the utopian Libertarian Socialistic school of thought. Which is a form of non-government.

Like you correctly point out, anarcho-capitalism does allow private actors to furfil the need of services which today is controlled by the state.

Because anarcho-capitalism is not utopian. It assumes that there will be human conflict, and a continued need for the services controlled by the government. But it believes that competition will drive away bad actors, as well as provide people with an alternative. As the market stabilizes, hopefully there will be more perfect competition power and compulsion will be decentralized, and distributed among many providers. Which in turn would make reputation paramount. Creating a system where ethical leaders would rise to the top, and where unethical people would behave ethically.

Even if you don't agree to these ideas, you have to recognize the immense importance of anarcho-capitalism in theorizing about what it might be possible to organize in a free market system, and remove from state control.

1
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Anarcho-Capitalism believes that in a pluralistic free market society, there will occasionally be entities which will try to gain monopoly. But without a state it will not be able to enforce a monopoly for very long.

I'm sure that some anarcho-capitalists believe this, which I would consider to be misguided. But ideological justifications aside, as a political structure, anarchocapitalism is not anti-monopolistic. If a monopoly were to arise, even if it was unexpected, it would not run counter to any anarchocapitalist principles.

As the market stabilizes, hopefully there will be more perfect competition power and compulsion will be decentralized, and distributed among many providers.

Pure monopoly was simply a far end of the spectrum. There could be multiple private entities which have sovereignty over land. This would certainly be better than pure monopoly. But unless the barrier to entry in the land market was so low that everyone could gain sovereignty over a meaningful amount of land, there would inevitably be involuntary governance.

And competition over commodities with inelastic supply, such as land, tends to cause high barriers of entry.

Creating a system where ethical leaders would rise to the top, and where unethical people would behave ethically.

I understand that this is the idea behind Anarcho-capitalism. As I said, Anarcho-capitalism deems capitalism to be a better method of determining leadership than democracy. I am opposed to this notion.

Even if you don't agree to these ideas, you have to recognize the immense importance of anarcho-capitalism in theorizing about what it might be possible to organize in a free market system, and remove from state control.

I am not opposed to the theoretical conceptualization of Anarcho-capitalism. In fact, I created this post for the sake of doing just that.

2
[deleted]•

But ideological justifications aside, as a political structure, anarchocapitalism is not anti-monopolistic. If a monopoly were to arise, even if it was unexpected, it would not run counter to any anarchocapitalist principles.

I assume you mean sovereignty in the sense of a polity which makes laws. But in an Anarcho-Capitalist society private companies would have the job of making "laws" which would really be contracts, independent courts would be the ones to judge cases and interpret these contracts.

We can imagine such a system where we would buy an insurance contract, where a security company would provide security personnel to enforce this contract. If you were unhappy with this contract, you could look for alternative providers. So there would be no sovereignty. Everyone would have different laws which were specified in their security contract.

Land ownership is a different thing. Say that a single person were to buy the whole world. He couldn't then evict the rest of mankind, because it could impossibly have been the intent during sale that it would be possible to evict everyone living there. It would have to be sold under the premise that the inhabitants would have the right to use and live on the land.

By what means would this single land owner be able to enforce any rules on people unless he also owned the security companies, the insurance companies and courts. He would also have to purchase every single security contract. Meanwhile he would be powerless to stop anyone from making their own security companies, insurance companies, and courts. People would be free to draw up new contracts.

Such a contract would also probably contain a clause to render the contract void in such a scenario.

So I don't see the problem that you do.

1
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

But in an Anarcho-Capitalist society private companies would have the job of making "laws" which would really be contracts.

This doesn't contradict the meat of my argument:

Anarcho-capitalism believes it would be more efficient to let capitalism determine who “deserves” to make laws and govern the masses, in the same way that we currently use capitalism to determine who “deserves” to make company policies and manage employees.

​

Land ownership is a different thing. Say that a single person were to buy the whole world. He couldn't then evict the rest of mankind.

You're being too binary about this. It obviously wouldn't be one person buying the whole word at once. Compounding wealth inequality would lead to the consolidation of most land among a minority handful of private entities. These private entities would then be free to conspire with one another to further their mutual interests.

So not one person owning the world, but 10 companies owning 90% of the land in California.

By what means would this single land owner be able to enforce any rules on people unless he also owned the security companies, the insurance companies and courts. He would also have to purchase every single security contract. Meanwhile he would be powerless to stop anyone from making their own security companies, insurance companies, and courts. People would be free to draw up new contracts.

This is like saying that a warlord cannot take over without enlisting every single soldier, and in the meantime, he would be powerless to stop people from becoming soldiers.

And the idea of people just making their own private courts to challenge other private courts makes no sense. If two different courts disagree, which ruling is enforced? Does everybody individually just decide which court they personally believe is valid, then sick their private security companies on one another?

1
[deleted]•

Sovereign entities are the only ones that are important. They’re called “individuals” and they own everything already.

Anarchy is about dispelling the myth of political authority - the belief that some people have the right to coerce others and everybody else has a duty to obey.

1
Anen-o-mevoluntaryist•

r/enddemocracy

I would say ancap is anarchy because governance can be stateless, and that's the definition of anarchy.

1
RandomPlayerCSGOAnarcho Capitalist•

They are not ok with private companies acting like the government, they are ok with private companies acting as administration so we can do what according to statists only the government can do, private security in Anarcho capitalism would only protect people's life and property, no company would be able to create new laws and force them on other people, the only way to make a new law would be a private contract within a group of Individuals, and only those who signed the contract would be forced to follow that law.

1
Vast_Anarchy•

You have to compete for rent unlike taxes, you should try renting something out and see if that changes your mind.

1
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Inelastic supply decreases competition though, by vastly increasing barriers to entry, and making it easier for monopolistic conglomerates to retain their leverage. This is why the rental markets are so poor in areas with zoning restrictions.

The difference is that while governmental zoning makes housing inelastic, land is inherently inelastic.

2
ninjaluvrLibertarian Party•

Anarcho-capitalism is not actually anarchy, because it doesn’t actually oppose governance.

Anarcho socialism and Anarcho communism also don't oppose "governance".

You simply don't understand anarchism.

anarcho-capitalism is an authoritarian form of statehood

False, Anarcho capitalism rejects the state and statehood.

0†
WanderingVirginia•

There is no rejection of the state if your founding ideology is literally and specifically authoritarian branding of asset (Capital). Branding and condoning assets is essential rulership, anarchos literally means no rulers. But whatever, keep jerking your oxymoronic propaganda off and telling the world you believe authoritarians own what Privateering makes possible. This is a libertarian space,you may choose to be a sycophant if you are for some reason so compelled.

1
Squalleke123•

AnCap is (by far) the least authoritarian ideology to be honest. When properly applied no one is able to exert force on anyone else without facing the consequences of violating the NAP

1
ninjaluvrLibertarian Party•

Anarcho capitalist completely reject the state. Anarcho capitalist completely reject a monopoly on rulers. Certainly anarchos believe they can lock their doors at night.

0
WanderingVirginia•

Anarchists reject the state. The notion of the monopoly of violence is fundamentally opposed to the literal ideology of 'opposed to rulers.'

Anarcho capitalism is so called the ideology of no rulers who are capitalist. Capitalism is the authoritarian branding and regulation of assets, a particularly effective means of rulership over economy. This is oxymoronic and antithetical to anarchos ideology.

0†
ninjaluvrLibertarian Party•

Not at all. Anarcho capitalists like Rothbard simply advocate for free markets and no rulers.

-1
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Anarcho-capitalism uses the word “state” as a dog whistle for democracy. It poses no genuine or authentic opposition to actual statehood.

Anarchy is fundamentally opposed to hierarchal governance, and the consolidation of land sovereignty which begets hierarchical governance. Anarcho-capitalism is not.

0†
ninjaluvrLibertarian Party•

Anarchy, in practice is not all opposed to hierarchy in governance.

Anarcho capitalist use the word state just like all anarchists do.

2
pingpongplaya69420Propertarian•

You’re more than free to create an ancom society in ancap society. If you’re as smart as you think you are, you’d understand hierachies happen regardless. Parent and child, student and pupil, husband and pregnant wife. Nature isn’t about equality but ancoms are big fucking morons

0†
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

You’re more than free to create an ancom society in ancap society.

Yeah, and Black people were more than free to let White people use the colored fountain in the 1950's, so I guess Black people voluntary participated in segregation...

If the people with the most money would benefit the least from ancom sub-societies, and the people with the most money have the most influence in the free market, then wouldn't the free market forces allocate land away from ancom sub-societies?

I'm not an Anarcho-communist for the record, I'm a Georgist.

2
Squalleke123•

spot on!

Especially that first bit.

1
neosatus•

You're very ignorant OP. Not worth wasting time on ya.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
ShmodeciousOPGeorgist Libertarian•

Without a state it's impossible for a company to monopolize, without a government that can regulate the market its impossible for monopolies to exist

Oh, it is impossible for inelastic supply to lead to natural monopolization?

You should publish whatever brought you to this conclusion. If there's any substance, you will become a world famous economist, for singlehandedly disproving doctorate level economics professors across the country.

Anarcho-capitalism is not opposed to public or community schools, and its not opposed to communes. people can still have a "tax sistem" if they want

Yes, and segregation was not opposed to desegregation. Black people could let White people use the "colored" fountain. They could still have a desegregated fountain if they wanted...

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
amirjanyan•

Your mistake is thinking that "representative democracy" is actually a form of government that gives ordinary people any power. But it is easy to see that in it people have only vanishingly small influence on anything. They only get to pick one of a couple of bundles of policies, they can't negotiate with other people to reach a compromise and as a result they never get what they want.

In a real democracy people should be able to vote on each issue separately, should be able to delegate votes on different topics to different people they trust, and most importantly should be able negotiate with other people to support one issue in exchange for support of another. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_democracy

When we get a system that allows people to truly control their vote, it will open a free marketplace for votes, and people will naturally organize into separate jurisdictions creating anarcho-capitalist society not because ideological beliefs, but because it is the result of compromise between people who have tools to communicate.

believes it would be more efficient to let capitalism determine who “deserves” to make laws and govern the masses

Capitalism doesn't determine who deserves anything, people do. When you make something useful other people vote for you to get some reward, and when you buy a product in effect you vote that people who have made that product have done a great job so you allow them to get some of the useful things that you have produced.

-1
scody15Anarcho Capitalist•

Nah.

-1