Albums from other bands similar to Train of Thought?

Question

Hi everybody, this is my first post in this community. I'm looking for albums with a sound and feel similar to Train of Thought, with its particular blend of straight-forward heaviness, progressive riffs, and great instrumentalization.

I know all the discography of DT, that's why I ask for albums from different bands. The recommendations I've got so far include Pantera's Cowboy's From Hell and Metallica's Black Album, which are great but they don't quite scratch the itch I have. What should I listen to next?

Posted Sep 19, 2021, 11:44 AM UTC

6241
Canolio•

Virus by Haken is particularly punchy. Prosthetic, Carousel, Messiah Complex are all absolute bangers.

40
Frainaman•

And to that I'll also add Vector which is Virus' prequel. Same blend of progressiveness and heavyness.

21
Canolio•

Tbh if you're a Dream Theater fan and looking for some new music. Haken should be the first place that anyone looks haha

26
Frainaman•

Couldn't have said something more right.

12
Destructo_Spin90•

I feel Vector is a bit more "train of thought-y" than Virus. That being said, I didn't really like the sequel and nowadays when coming back to it I find myself only listening to Messiah Complex.

11
wangatangs•

Virus was such a good listen. I remember some time ago, I tried to give The Mountain a listen. Musically it was fine but it was too complex (maybe I'm getting too old). Then The Virus came out and the songs were shorter but still heavy and had very technical and tight instrumentals.

5
Kaladin7878•

Haken in general is an excellent band, though not all of their work is similar to ToT in particular.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

33
wangatangs•

I'll add Paradise Lost from Symphony X too. Walls of Babylon from that album is 100% riff city. A lot of good stuff from the album in general. Starting with their 2002 album The Odyssey is when they adopted their modern prog metal sound so their stuff starting from that is a guaranteed win.

16
Reddit-Book-Bot•

Beep. Boop. I'm a robot. Here's a copy of

###Paradise Lost

Was I a good bot? | info | More Books

-2†
WhileExcellent1679•

Dude the Myrath - Tales of Sands is an Amazing find for me! Thanks a Lot!

7
Lydanian•

It’s a banging album. They also supported Symphony X a few years ago, which was just insane.

5
surgeon_michael•

Thats funny. ToT and Iconoclast are 2 of my top 5 albums ever. Not recognized as the bands best efforts but those are my favorite. Makes sense.

3
ijella•

I especially love the Divine wings of tragedy it's a fantastic album recommend of sins and shadows, out of the ashes, and the title track

2
wangatangs•

The Accolade is amazing too!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
LaForgesBeard•

You'd probably enjoy Between the Buried and Me's entire discography. Start with Colors 1 or Parallax 2.

In a slightly different vein Mastodon's Leviathan or Blood Mountain albums might be what you're looking for too.

16
Durga2112•

Try Opeth's "Blackwater Park". Opeth aren't as "flashy" as DT, but they always have a great balance between heavy as fuck riffing, beautiful melodic sections, and classic sounding prog rock - often in the same song. The vocals (at least on their older albums) also switch between death growls and clean vocals, again often in the same song. The entire album is quite incredible, but if you just want a taste before diving in, I would suggest listening to the song "Bleak" - if you like what you hear, listen to the rest of the album. But if you've got an hour to spare, there are worse things you could do than just listen to the entire album.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

Listen to the Ark album Burn the Sun. You'll hear Train of Thought, literally.

13
anywhereiroa•

The intro of Noose is literally This Dying Soul. Also, thank you for making me discover a great band! Too bad they only have one album. Wiki says they have two but I could only find it on YT.

Edit: Apparently Ark's album was released 2 years before ToT, and 1 year before SDoiT, so technically they made it first lol

2
[deleted]•

Yep, Ark predates Train of Thought. I did say that you'd literally hear the album when listening to Ark. It was me alluding to DT just taking the riff.

2
Destructo_Spin90•

Haken - Vector. Simply a nonstop onslaught of progressive metal with great heavy riffs, drumming and keyboard playing.

11
Eferver•

It’s hard to find something exactly like Train of Thought. If you lean more toward the heavier side, I’d suggest Between The Buried And Me or Jinjer. If you want more melodic but still heavy and proggy, Voyager is a great band.

6
BrainJar•

Circus Maximus, either 1st Chapter or Isolate. Both are heavy and have groove.

6
RaiseTheKnife•

Opus Arise by Lost in Thought

4

Great rec, thanks, hadn’t heard them before.

1
RaiseTheKnife•

One of my favorite albums ever. It's a shame more people haven't heard them

2
Thecoolguitardude•

Maybe try Symphony X if you haven't already? They're kind of like if Dream Theater went full on neoclassical power metal. Their albums Paradise Lost and Iconoclast are both pretty heavy. Their earlier stuff is proggier, the later stuff focusses more on the heaviness.

If you're okay with growls, I also recommend Between The Buried and Me and Persefone. BTBAM has some stellar music that combines so many different styles into one incredible mix of extreme proggy goodness.

Persefone isn't nearly as experimental in their style as BTBAM, but their combination of melodic and technical death metal with DT style progressive metal is really something to behold. The guitar work and especially the keyboards are really amazing.

Both bands have a nice balance of harsh and clean vocals, but you will probably need to be okay with the growls if you want to check them out as they are a big part of their sound.

3
rushman870•

Underworld is an excellent album as well.

5
yotam5434•

Haven't heard train of thought for a long time so what's your favorite song on it I'll listen and come back to you

3
SwankysSwing•

Check out This Godless Endeavor - Nevermore

I also agree with the Symphony X comments.

3
Worge105•

This Godless Endeavor - Nevermore Vector - Haken Iconoclast - Symphony X

3
Octavarium64•

Check out Redemption. One of the heaviest Prog-Metal bands in the scene that doesn’t use any screamed vocals.

Threshold is also highly recommended. The albums Hypothetical or Dead Reckoning would be good starting points for Metal fans.

3
ValkorTahoe•

City and alien 👽 from strapping young lad are exactly what you want

2
tdrusk•

For me, Through The Eyes of the Dead - Malice scratches the itch. It’s more melodic death metal but they use harmonic minor a lot so it sounds like in the Name of god.

Also Ra - Genocide sounds like ToT a lot.

Finally, not the same realm, but ghost has some similarities.

Static X - Shadow Zone is basically a more static x’s version of As I Am.

Sorry I can’t Be more helpful, monitoring this thread because I love this album but nothing really comes close.

Forgot to add: mastodon - emperor of sand up there

One more: the haarp machine - disclosure

2
rushman870•

You would probably really enjoy Blackwater Park by Opeth. There’s some more mellow sections, but the album as a whole is a masterpiece.

2
DontTreadOnMe96•

Self-titled and Black Gives Way to Blue by Alice in Chains. There are no keyboards but both albums are dark and crushingly heavy, you're gonna love these two.

2
jpmoney•

Check out Soilwork, specifically Stabbing the Drama, The Living Infinite, and The Ride Majestic. The musicality reminds me of ToT for sure, though a bit faster overall.

There are some harsh-ish vocals, but its not too much.

2
UsernameTyper•

Jack the Joker - In the Rabbit Hole. You won't regret it.

2