What if Legate Tekeny Ghemor had formed a Cardassian government-in-exile during the Dominion War?
I was rewatching DS9 S5E19 Ties of Blood and Water, and I was intrigued that Kira had made a detailed proposal for Ghemor to lead the Cardassian dissident movement at the head of a government-in-exile, prior to him revealing his ill health rendered that possibility impossible.
I was considering what might have happened if Ghemor wasn't ill. What might have changed for Cardassia if Dukat's Dominion client state had to deal with a rival government, led by a popular leader backed by the Federation and/or Bajor.
What official recognition would Ghemor have? Would parts of the Cardassian fleet defect earlier in the war? Would Ghemor have to agree to concessions with the Klingon Empire or others in return for diplomatic approval? Could the war have ended differently for Cardassia?
Posted Sep 19, 2021, 10:41 PM UTC · edited
Given how quickly the Federation recognizes and provides aid to Dumar later on, I think it's a safe bet he would've been recognized as the official leader of the Cardassia government in exile by the UFP. I envision a seat on Earth or even DS9 for the sitting government, similar to how the Free French under DeGaulle sat in London during much of WWII.
In all likelihood the Cardassian people would've seen Ghemor's government as even more of a puppet of the Federation than Dukat's government was for the Dominion though.
Some, perhaps, but I don't think many. Ghemor had already lived the dissident-in-exile life before, after he fled Cardassia at the end of "Second Skin" and was given political sanctuary by the Mathenite government - and the movement he was leading then eventually toppled the Central Command. Given the added risk of harboring a Cardassian dissident after Cardassia joined the Dominion and got its military mojo back, fleeing to a superpower this time instead of a minor power for shelter makes a lot of sense - smaller powers would be more wary of taking the risk of pissing off the Dominion, and would have been more likely to cave when Dukat called and demanded Ghemor's return. Kira stated that Ghemor was still popular and respected on Cardassia - even if it wasn't a majority of the population, he'd still have a following who'd listen to him and would be inspired to work against the Dukat/Dominion govt. by him.
It'd be different if he were simply some random Cardassian that the Federation gave an office and subspace comms to, but this guy was already known, respected, and would obviously be promoting the same democratic, non-violent ideals he'd already spent years working toward.
You have to consider the mindset of the typical Cardassian at this time though. Yes, his dissident movement eventually toppled Central Command. And that was almost immediately followed by a humiliating invasion by the Klingons. Regardless of the actual causes and effects, good luck trying to convince the average citizen that the loss of Central Command was a good thing.
And it wasn't even the first humiliation in living memory. First they fight what was to them a long and desperate war against a much stronger power... but that power saw that war as such a minor sideshow that they have the temerity to tell everyone in the galaxy that the military that's waging that war isn't even a military. Then they're forced to withdraw from Bajor, which then immediately finds a strategic asset of incredible value within the week when they hadn't in fifty years of occupation. Then came the Klingons. Given that sequence of events, anything that can restore a sense of pride is a powerful drug.
For the first year of the war, their new allies the Dominion had reversed that humiliation and hadn't yet done anything to impinge on the newly restored pride of the Cardassians. They're winning and winning hard, with just one setback of any significance on Terok Nor that was literally the result of divine intervention.
If Ghemor started a government-in-exile before there was a broad realization that the Dominion was simply going to continue the conga line of humiliation, he'd likely lose most of the followers who still respected him. The Romulans wouldn't let him set up shop as that'd violate the neutrality agreement. The Federation and Klingons might, but that'd be one of the easiest propaganda wins for the Dominion possible: brand him as an incompetent for opening the doors to Klingon invasion, and a traitor for seeking refuge with the very people the Cardassians were fighting against, the ones who had spent decades humiliating them.
Once again, pride is a powerful drug. There's a reason it's almost always considered the worst among the seven deadly sins, and often the origin of the others. It blinds people to reality because what they want to believe is so much nicer than admitting to a grievous mistake. So long as the Cardassian-Dominion "alliance" is winning, anything other than staying low would be counterproductive for Ghemor. Even when they started losing, too many people would be in denial for him to take action. It's only after the Dominion turned their guns on Cardassia that it would be possible for him to say "hey, let's give democracy and peace another chance".
Oh, I fully agree that the average Cardassian wouldn't have supported Ghemor - as you and others have noted, the average Cardassian strongly supported the new government under Dukat. I was arguing against the statement that he'd be viewed as a Federation puppet, as he'd be remaining consistent with the positions he's held for years, rather than as simply wrong about the proper way to make Cardassia great again.