Season 2 Episode 11 is a Masterpiece in Television and Sci-Fi (Minor Spoilers)

SpoilerOther

For the longest time I saw Seth MacFarlane as a hit and miss comedy writer. This initially put me off The Orville during season 1 where the comedic aspects of the show were more pronounced. However, after rewatching season 1 and finally getting around to season 2 I can safely say my opinion on MacFarlane has entirely shifted.

This man has created one of the most enjoyable science fiction shows currently airing. I truly believe this show is what he should have been working on all along. His writing on the more dramatic, or philosophical episodes is absolutely stellar and rivals the absolute best episodes of Star Trek. As someone who has loved Trek from an early age it is a real joy to experience new adventures presented in a similar style.

This brings me to what was by far my favourite episode of the series so far. Season 2 Episode 11 "Lasting Impressions" was such an emotional journey, Scott Grimes performance was phenomenal and he really works well with the more serious roles as opposed to just being the comic relief as he was in early episodes. The themes of this episode really resonated with me as I am sure they did with many other people. The need to be remembered, a love you cannot have and the acceptance of that and the grander questions of what makes love real were all beautifully presented in this episode. There were many moments where I teared up, or smiled, I was really rooting for Malloy.

Just an amazing episode of the show and it really showcases just how great of a writer MacFarlane can be. What were your opinions of the episode? Am I alone in thinking this is the best episode.

Posted Sep 20, 2021, 8:24 PM UTC

16017
clauderbaugh•

I do think that this episode gets overshadowed by the epicness of the Identity space battle sequence. But minute for minute, it's one of my favorite episodes too. It reminds me of something STTNG would have done and reminds me of "The Inner Light" a bit because it goes beyond the sci-fi aspect and hits you in the feels.

44
IncompatibertI have laid an egg•

And let us also not forget the excellent B story.

Five. Hundred. Cigarettes.

37
banjo_hero•

I feel as if I've been standing my entire life and I just sat down

24
[deleted]•

i felt the same about MacFarlane but i decided to put my dislike of his comedy to one side and give it a try and realised i had not had as much fun with a sci fi show since Farscape...

29
dgl6y7•

I started watching farscape during lockdown. I watch like the first three or four episodes and I couldn't get into it. Does it get better?

Farscape and the Orville were two shows I was planning to check out. After a few episodes of farscape I started watching the Orville and loved it so I never went back.

2
clauderbaugh•

Farscape gets better. It was tough for me too at first because the characters were so radically alien (as opposed to just humanoid). It was a cheese factor that turned me off a bit, but stick with it. There are some quality episodes and I ended up getting wrapped up in the chemistry of Ben Browder and Claudia Black and their relationship that takes the show to the finale. Granted, it's not in my top 5 sci-fi or anything, but it's worth watching to check the box.

5
xeowPraise Saint Bortus•

Granted, it's not in my top 5 sci-fi or anything,

oooh. Now I want to know what your top 5 are. Just because I'm always looking for new stuff.

1
clauderbaugh•

Probably going to age myself here but for TV series:

1- STTNG

2- The Expanse

3 - Firefly

4 - Battlestar Galactica (reboot)

5 - Quantum Leap

3
turnipofficer•

I suppose his previous, huge gigantic works were needed for people to basically have faith in him to produce his own version of Star Trek.

2
QuercusSambucus•

Currently rewatching season 2, and it's incredible how many different character arcs they have running at once. Ja'loja is an entire episode with a ridiculous premise that's really just an excuse to spend an hour on a bunch of the characters' relationships. My wife is studying screenwriting and has really enjoyed picking this stuff apart.

Compare this to Discovery Season 2, which does a horrendous job setting up character arcs for minor characters, including killing off somebody whose name is barely mentioned before they are killed, in the first episode that's ever featured them.

15
bradleykent:mercer: We need no longer fear the banana•

Holy shit Discovery season 2 was a disaster.

I’ve suppressed my memory of it until now. That’s how bad it was.

4
QuercusSambucus•

Discovery seems like nobody has an overall plan for where things are going aside from the overall main A plot for the season, and each episode is written in isolation.

2
Doogan23•

I cannot agree with you more, and everytime I watch it this episode I cry my eyes out at this part....

Scott Grimes and Leighton Meester

13
Jerigord•

This episode caught me at a really hard time in life and put a lot of things in a new light. It's still at the back of my mind to this day and I think about it frequently. It's my favorite episode of the show, but I'm not sure I'll be able to watch it again any time soon. It's my own Jurassic Bark

10
amrmuhammad23•

For me that episode is my favorite of the show and i am not really exaggerating when i say it is one of my favorite episodes in any show i have watched.

6
slyfoxy12•

I will say the Orville have made the best use of the holosuite idea than any of the Trek series imo. I think it helps they can do the more adult material with it but still.

5
pingpongjingjong•

I agree. Not that episode in particular, but the whole season is terrific. It finds its rhythm. Mercer becomes a real captain. Fewer missteps, really engaging writing. Without a doubt some of the best SF going around.

1