DNS Servers are iCloud Relay Servers? Should you be alarmed? given Apple Intrusion on Privacy?

Discussion

I noticed alot of DNS uses apple iCloud Private Relay Servers and given the controversy of apples new iCloud scanning of your files should you be concerned that popular DNS servers are based on iCloud Private Relay Servers? or is that different?

You can repeat what I am talking about here by setting your dns to 9.9.9.9 and doing a dnsleaktest https://dnsleaktest.com/

https://aws1.discourse-cdn.com/cloudflare/original/3X/8/c/8ca03eb98b2fcd63ce5ff8052679480a00cb090e.png

Posted Sep 20, 2021, 8:27 PM UTC · edited

510
Spaylia•

What do you mean a lot of DNS uses iCloud Private Relay? What DNS? Where did you see this?

15
TestSoundsOP•

when you do a DNSLeakTest with say quad9 the servers will be ISP iCloud Private Relay. https://aws1.discourse-cdn.com/cloudflare/original/3X/8/c/8ca03eb98b2fcd63ce5ff8052679480a00cb090e.png

1
Spaylia•

It's not that "a lot of DNS" uses iCloud Private Relay, it's just that you use iCloud Private Relay so your DNS are changed from Quad9 to Apple's

2
TestSoundsOP•

wouldnt it be more correct to say that quad9 uses iCloud Private Relay? because I put in 9.9.9.9 which is Quad9 dns into my setup and the dnsleaktest returns iCloud Private Relay, if i put proton dns I get proton DNS return not iCloud. Also i just used Quad9 as a example I tired other dns and same thing happened, sure its not all of them but more than a few.

1
pm-me-your-nenen•

You got it backward. iCloud private relay is a two-hop system, the first hop is Apple's own server, the second hop is the nearest servers owned by CDNs such as Cloudflare, Akamai, and Fastly. This second hop is what nameservers see when resolving address, including DNS leak test services. Those services in turn just mark those servers as iCloud private relay, even though obviously Cloudflare, Akamai and Fastly also use the server for their own use and their customers.

4
[deleted]•

I trust the privacy aspect of PR but not the security. I stopped using it after they unknowingly were leaking IP through WebRTC.

2
adequate_redditor•

Are you referring to something like this: https://community.cloudflare.com/t/icloud-private-relay/301450

The post doesn't have a definitive answer unfortunately but maybe there are others.

Private Relay uses partners to route traffic, such as CloudFlare and others, but their own traffic should not be impacted by iCloud Private Relay so I am a bit confused by this.

1
TestSoundsOP•

Yes that is what i am referring to.

1