I just wanted to share my Inside Llewyn Davis read that I like that I think is about to be proven wrong

Spoiler

I thought now on the eve of the The Tragedy of Macbeth trailer is a okay time to post this. I’ve always read Inside Llewyn Davis as being a love letter from each of the individual Coens to their brother. Joel and Ethan each telling the other how important a collaborator and partner they are. In the movie Llewyn is struggling as a solo act after an at least relatively successful run as a two person act. But now without his partner he is lost. Llewyn Davis is used to the flip side of the best of him being the best of his partner, Mike Timlin. But now the flip side to the best of him is the rest of him and he’s learning to face consequences for his bad attitude and arrogance. The bad parts of his personality that just weren’t so on display when he was part of a successful act. When Llewyn goes to record with Adam Driver and JT he is a total jerk and he disses their song cuz these guys are total hacks compared to his bro! I mean his old partner, Mike! He can still play music with people but he’s just gigging and there isn’t any joy for him here.

Then there is the scene with F. Murray Abraham. Before Llewyn performs for him they are in his office and F. tells him he wants to hear him play something and Llewyn asks, “Here?” And then F. Murray Abraham so patronizingly replies, “Not here.” And then they walk out into the performance space. And it’s so brutal and so embarrassing but you can imagine that if someone else was there too they all might have laughed instead of it just being awkward. Then Llewyn performs and after a good performance F. basically says that he is good but shouldn’t be a solo act. He says he could put Llewyn in a trio act and he asks Llewyn if he can harmonize and Llewyn says, “Yes. But no.” He can harmonize just not with anybody but who he can’t with. He’s just such a jerk and he knows it and he can’t work well with others like he could with his great collaborator.

Then the movie ends with Llewyn Davis at a coffee house performing a solo version of the song that him and Mike used to sing. And it goes well and it’s a good performance and he sings the lyric “fare thee well” a number of times. Max Casella recognizes it as the song him and mike played and tells him good job. Then Llewyn goes outside to get his ass kicked and BOB DYLAN goes on stage and starts performing a song where he sings the lyric “fare thee well” a number of times. And I think what the Coens were saying in this scene is that one of them individually doing their best might make something really great on their own but ultimately it would just exist in the shadow of what other different wunderkind geniuses can do on their own. I think the movie is not positing that Bob Dylan is much more talented than Llewyn Davis. But just that Bob is the guy who is gonna take the spot of curly headed folk singer singing “fare thee well” and he is going to become Bob Dylan. Llewyn Davis isn’t going to become Llewyn Davis. He was Timlin and Davis.

More simply I think the movie is the Coens saying that on their own they are each talented arrogant jerks who put their foot in their mouth too much and act high and mighty and that they are so lucky that they each have each other to make movies with otherwise they’d be miserable and they’d make other people miserable too.

Well anyways thats my Inside Llewyn Davis take that is about to become extinct once Joel makes an awesome movie on his own so yeah I just wanted to share that take for the last time :)

Posted Sep 21, 2021, 3:41 AM UTC · edited

6111
[deleted]•

[deleted]

35
EachBoth•

I read this analysis and immediately sighed this exact statement.

6
xxmikekxx•

#1 movie on my best of the 2010s list!

3
TychoCelchuuuIt's about the militarization of space•

and the cat is frances mcdormand

25
PqPpqpqp•

I laughed and then I thought about it and then I gasped

4
TheKal-El•

I don't think reads can be "proven wrong" necessarily. You know, unless they're just too far a walk for anyone to understand.

Be proud of your read, it's very interesting even if that's not exactly what I pulled from it. Secretly why I think Inside Llewyn Davis is the best movie if the 2010s, as well as the most depressing.

14
SilentBlueAvocado•

I definitely read it as a love letter to a creative partner as well.

9

I think this was David Ehrlich's take as well.

Another good reading is talking about authenticity. He scoffs at the lady singing her song, but isn't even wholly original too. There is an article online about it, but I won't link it because it's a persona non grata.

8
VermilionVillain•

I really like that analysis.

5
caroline_nein•

That's a great take <3

4
2008wallcalendarearth needs dads•

stop i don’t wanna get too emotional on r/blankies that’s embarrassing

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
YourMombadil•

I’d like to take this thread as an opportunity to share with you other lovers of da moviesh my own metatextual interpretation of Inside Llewyn Davis that pops up here and there in discussions but not nearly enough because I think it’s so clear - so clear, in fact, that I worry I’m stupid for pointing it out because maybe everyone just takes it as given and not worth mentioning?

Anyway, my take is based on this: it’s no accident that the Gate of Horn proprietor is played by the actor whose signature role is the definitive study of a mediocrity that is just talented enough to be tortured by understanding the depth of true genius. F. Murray Abraham’s fundamental dismissal “I don’t see a lot of money in this” is basically telling Llewyn that he’s Saliari, not Mozart. And then that exact dynamic is echoed when Llewyn hears Dylan and realizes how small he really is.

So the central theme is one of the Coens’ recurring themes of mediocrities destroyed by their own understanding of their own weaknesses - the closest mirror being Barton Fink, but a lot of their films touch on it obliquely if not specifically about artists. Is this obvious and everyone knows it goes without saying?

I appreciate your interpretation and there’s something to it in appreciating their partnership, and I need to rewatch with this idea in mind; it’s been a while. But, I will say that I never saw his former partnership as the key dramatic lynchpin that you describe, but just one aspect of his middlingness. It didn’t really make that big an impression on me as a plot point? But you may be right!

1