Adding Cereal post-fermentation?

I've seen a few posts here about using cereal in brewing. I've been surprised that everyone seems to add them into the mash process. I know that in my area, I've seen several brewers release cereal beers, and they usually say 'aged on captain crunch' or whatever.

Does anyone have experience doing this? I want to brew my next beer over apple jacks, but I have no idea what quantity to use for a 5g batch

Edit: Thank you everyone for your feedback, it's been a serious help. I think I'm changing plan to add a small bit of apple brandy and a cinnamon stick or two post-fermentation. It's by far the most off-recipe I've gone, so please wish me luck. I'll post a follow up here later in case anyone's interested

Posted Sep 23, 2021, 4:23 PM UTC · edited

213
Perfect_Line8384•

Why not just add the component flavors of applejacks? I can guarantee you the commercial breweries are doing the same thing. Using actual cereal is mostly for social media pictures of someone dumping it into the beer or mash.

5
chino_brewsKiwi Approved•

I've been surprised that everyone seems to add them into the mash process.

Adding starchy adjuncts to finished beer is asking for instability (beer changes in an unwanted way, including by microbial contamination). I doubt any high quality brewers would do that. We have/had brewers around here who don't/didn't care about quality and were driven by the dollar too.

The thing about pastry beers (and cereal beers fall in this category), is that the actual thing (apple jacks, twinkies, black forest cake, whatever) is the wrong thing to get a beer that tastes like the thing. Sure, you might add the thing to be able to say you did. But the apple jack flavor is not going to come through no matter how much apple jacks you use (any reasonable proportion). So it's actually a challenging thing to design a great pastry beer. You have to find the right combination of malts, water chemistry, mash schedule, yeast, fermentation schedule, and flavor extracts. There are probably more factors too. If it's possjble, it may take many, many iterations to make a beer that gets someone who sips it to say, "Hey that's tastes like Apple Jacks cereal!"

3
liquidgold83Advanced•

For apple jacks you're gonna need 100 boxes.

2
Sea-Sherbet-117•

I have not used cereal other than flaked corn and oats and always in the mash to convert the starches to sugars. I would not add cereal post fermentation in fear of contamination and making someone sick.

2
Perfect_Line8384•

Could toss em in the oven for a bit to protect the beer.

I can’t imagine a scenario where someone gets sick though.

2
Sea-Sherbet-117•

I am wondering about bits of cereal rotting in the keg along with general contamination from poor sanitation. It does not sound appealing to me if it does not make me sick.

2
Perfect_Line8384•

Yeah it does sound like a mess, but not totally different than trub and stuff. Being soaked in an acidic and alcoholic solution would prevent all the nasty stuff.

Bits of fruit and other adjuncts dont rot in beer.

2
Sea-Sherbet-117•

Anything you put in pre-fermentation would be fine with me. I just would not add fruit, cereal, or anything else post fermentation other than hops. I honestly do not know if it is common for stuff to be added post fermentation. It seems to go against what I learned about brewing sanitation unless you can heat the adjunct enough to kill the bugs.

1
chino_brewsKiwi Approved•

It's not that Apple Jacks will introduce contamination to a finished beer. Brewers add stuff to finished beer all the time.

The issue is that no beer is microbiologically sterile. If you add starch to beer, some cells of wild or cross-contaminating yeast that can metabolize starch and are already in there will thrive in the beer and spoil the beer or even lead to overcarbonation.

2
[deleted]•

From my understanding there is nothing that can survive in Beer that can make you sick.

My source was definitely not a doctor.

2