Asian skincare haul [Haul] [Sun Care]
![Asian skincare haul [Haul] [Sun Care]](https://i.redd.it/k534pxcgsfp71.jpg)
Posted Sep 24, 2021, 11:29 AM UTC
![Asian skincare haul [Haul] [Sun Care]](https://i.redd.it/k534pxcgsfp71.jpg)
Posted Sep 24, 2021, 11:29 AM UTC
I love the Super Moisturize Essence GOLD!
How is it different from the Milk or the regular Essence?
I've tried both the milk & regular essence as well. The Milk more of a runny texture, and it dries to a (more) satin finish than the other two. I couldn't use the milk anymore after I started using Tretinoin, since the Milk formula clung to my dry patches, and also I'm more of a medium/tan complexion and it left a slight white cast on me.
The GOLD is very similar to the regular essence, but I would say the gold is slightly more moisturizing. They are both more of a lotion texture that doesn't run. Both leave a shiny/dewey but not greasy finish on me. But the reason I like the gold version better is because it doesn't sting/irritate my eyes like the regular version. If the regular version didn't sting, I could probably use both versions interchangeably, since the texture and finishes are so similar, and both don't leave a white cast.
Thanks for this explanation! I may try the gold; I have yet to find any sunscreen that doesn't sting my eyes, but some are worse than others. Worth giving it a try, anyway!
[deleted]
Please review melano CC 😳😳
People on r/tretinoin love it. I've used it a bit, and I like the texture (very thin and spreads easily) and smell (citrusy), but honestly haven't been consistent enough to give a review on its effectiveness. It does not seem to irritate my super sensitive skin, though, so that's good.
Oh okay thanks :D
i use the entire tube didn't do anything for my pigmentation but a lot of people say its worked for them!
Yaa many mixed reviews isee
I would never figure out this is fragranced it really does not smell at all like a fragranced product. It is very “oily” when you start spreading it but there are no oils, it just sinks in after one or two minutes. Did not irritate my skin at all.
I’ve been using the Skin Aqua Essence Gold and I love everything about it except that it makes my face very shiny. I often put translucent powder on top after I’ve given it some time to set. I just tried the Suncut Gel and I like it so far but it also leaves me very shiny. I’m really hoping to find one that is 45 SPF or higher, PA ++++, no fragrance, minimal or no white cast, matte or natural finish, around $15 or less for about 100ml, and not shiny. I don’t know if this exists but I’ll keep searching.
The Suncut Essence (rather than the gel) might fit the bill for you. OP bought the essence and it's honestly my HG for oily skin. Natural finish, 110 ml bottle, doesn't pill, alcohol-y but not drying.
Thanks! I’ll have to try that one next
Idk your skin type, but I have combo-oily skin and for most of my sunscreens I find I don’t have to use moisturizer underneath. That’s probably why I find this to be more of a satin finish and not shiny. I just load up on hydrating serums underneath, but if I didn’t do that it’d probably be more of a matte finish
Thank you for the tips. I also have combination skin. I’ve tried not using moisturizer but I still get the shininess. It’s not dewy or overly moisturizing. It’s different somehow. Like it just leaves a really shiny look. It’s not sticky. It doesn’t even really look oily. It’s more like my face has been shellacked 😂
I’m curious where you ordered all this from and if you had any problems with vat and taxes? The melano cc is really great. The sun cut sunscreen is my second favourite after their blue one(the protect gel)
Ih
I ordered from Yesstyle and Amazon Japan.
I didn’t have any issues. I just paid less than 5 euros as post taxes from Yesstyle.
I live in Japan and I’ve tried most of the major sunscreens and super moisture essence (white bottle second from left) is my fave so far
That kose suncut essence is my HG
Have you by chance tried the Scinic essence? Curious about the finish , if it's too shiny or doesn't dry down
Hi! I tried it today. Yes unfortunately it is more suitable for normal to dry skin. It sit a bit heavy on my combination skin. It is a bit too moisturizing.
Hi, Oh thank you!! Ugh that's a pity, with that filter combination and being water resistant, it would've been great for summer if it wasn't so over. Also wanted to ask, the Skin Aqua Essence GOLD, is the shine really that bad? And do you use powder over it? I assume it (and the Kose) be much lighter and would dry down better than the Scinic since it has alcohol.
The kose suncut would have been perfect if it had Tinosorb M.
The skin Aqua essence gold is not that shiny. And it course it depends what you have used under it. I don’t use powder. Yes the ones with alcohol usually dry faster but there is no guarantee that they will not be shiny. The skin Aqua milk is less shiny than these but does not contain alcohol.
I tried this yesterday, it took about 10 mins to dry down. It did fully set for me but I live in a dry climate, not sure it would if there was humidity in the air. The finish was satin, looked natural on me. Unfortunately, it broke me out within hours then I woke up to even more breakouts. I have pale skin & there was an ever so slight white cast. My skin type is extremely acne prone, dehydrated & dry.
Ooh sorry bout the breakouts. Definitely sounds like i might have problems with it setting cos I live in a hot and humid place but I already ordered it so I hope it works somehow. And the cast. I have Fitzpatrick V skin tone but I do plan on using the sunscreen indoors only since it's not waterproof (according to some users, the review by Dr Pi says it is but idk). I appreciate the review, thanks.
Hi everyone and welcome to SkincareAddiction!
Need skincare guides? Check out our wiki!
Everyone is welcome in this community; remember to be kind and assume good faith :)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Hi op, can you please do a comparison of the kose suncut essence and the skin aqua gold essence here in terms of feel, finish and application? Also which do you prefer?
The skin aqua gold essence is a light cream type of texture that spreads easily and is not too heavy or greasy. The kose suncut essence is more of like a cream gel that sort of breaks and becomes more watery when you start spreading it. They both leave a slightly dewy finish but nothing unacceptable, perhaps the suncut being slightly less shiny. I cannot give more detailed description as I have used the both few times. They both end up irritating my eyes slightly so I don’t really love using them but they are good sunscreens. I would say the kose us more pleasant to use but the skin aqua contains Tinosorb M which is a great filter.
Thanks! Which do prefer out of this lot so far? And what's your actual favorite sunscreen?
From the ones shown in the photo, by far the Skin Aqua UV super moisture milk.
Unfortunately, I cannot say I have one particular favourite sunscreen. All of them offer certain things but have disadvantages. What I mean is that one sunscreen may offer a very elegant finish but may sting the eyes and another sunscreen may offer extremely high protection but give a very white finish. Therefore I have a few sunscreens I like to use under specific circumstances. Please keep in mind that my eyes are extremely sensitive and therefore 9 out of 10 sunscreens, I cannot use because they bother my eyes. I also like to apply it right around my eyes to keep this area as well preserved as possible. This eliminates almost all sunscreens for me.
1. Anessa perfect milk: I like this as I trust Shiseido to be an extremely well researched brand that has created a sunscreen that is very resistant and provides good protection against tanning with a relatively elegant finish. It has multiple organic and inorganic filters that should provide some protection against visible light. I don’t find this to be eye-friendly though and also after reapplying it starts creating issues with white cast and white residue on facial hair. I use that as an extra layer over other sunscreens on sensitive areas, or for elegance because one layer dries relatively matte and has a perfecting finish.
2. Skin Aqua UV super moisture milk: This is a sunscreen that could be close to excellent. It is fragrance free and very suitable for sensitive skin, without alcohol, it contains great filters, it is water resistant, it does not bother my eyes, it dries almost matte. However my first problem is that it seems to have a relatively low percentage of active ingredients therefore I wonder how can it provide great protection. It relies heavily on Zinc Oxide, however it does not give a white cast therefore I wonder how good of a protection it offers and also the other UVA filter it contains, seems to be very low on the list, close to 1%. Therefore I have some trust issues with it. Worse than that, two women who have tested sunscreens under a UV camera showed that it can have a patchy application. So as we wear sunscreen to get that feeling of safety, knowing that I might have a patchy application without knowing it makes me feel unsafe. So I use it for the office. What makes me still use it is that it is created by a pharmaceutical company who has funds for research and also it is on the market over 3 years so I guess if people had issues with it, they would have reformulated it by now.
3. Suncut prodefense toughness milk: This is almost an exact copy of the anessa (same packaging color, same type of fragrance, same claims, etc. I mean it is pretty obvious they wanted to make an anessa dupe) and it has better filters (no octocrylene which does not have the best reputation) and I love it because although it has slightly more of a white cast, it seems to be very resistant and it does not bother my eyes almost at all (I have worn it 4 or 5 times around my eyes and I was mostly fine) plus it is not too shiny. It is very hard to remove and it seems to form an even layer and also it contains either a lot of Zinc Oxide or a of larger particle size because it is whitening which makes me feel like it should have a high protection against tanning. My concern with this one (because it could not of course be perfect either) is that ratzilla thinks very low of it. She believes it is not resistant at all (I really wonder why she thinks that because I had real trouble removing it) and that it dries her skin out and generally she thinks suncut sunscreens are no good.
4. Biore UV athlizm essence: This is a LOVELY consistency, it has a lovely fragrance, applies like a dream, claims to be resistant, does not bother my eyes at all and dries fast to a slightly shiny finish. This does not have any filters protecting from visible light and the filter percentages are very low making me question the protection it provides. I would not like to use it under the sun. I usually will apply this as a base layer and go on top with one of the milks on the nose, cheeks and forehead for extra insurance. It is great every day sunscreen. I love using it.
5. La Roche Posay Invisible Fluid: This is the famous PPD 46 sunscreen that could also be close to excellent. It provides (on paper) extremely high protection, it is extremely resistant to water and friction, it does not sting the eyes and it is very easy for me to get. However it contains Avobenzone instead of Uvinul A Plus creating some question about its photostability although I trust Loreal to know what they are doing and also it does not contain anything to filter visible light. Many people have started reporting tanning with it so I am not sure how well it protects in the near visible and visible light part of the spectrum. I can use it with ease under the sun, on the beach, because no matter how much I apply it will only be very shiny but it will not bother my eyes nor will I look like a ghost, it will not go anywhere when swimming, but it is questionable how well it protects from long UVA and visible light. What I have done is to also get the tinted version and apply some on top of the invisible one, to block visible light but this is another burden as it can rub of on stuff and leave orange/brown marks on clothes, etc. I am not used to make up so that bothers me.
In short, sunscreens that block visible light are not easy to use and the ones that are easy to use do not provide extreme protection against tanning… That’s that…
Thanks for the breakdown!
The skin aqua milk would be so perfect if it had great uva protection. I did read somewhere that the white cast (shows up slightly on my dark skin) isn't very obvious cos the zinc oxide is encapsulated though I don't know if that's how that truly works. I also don't use it outside. I've been using the LRP invisible fluid Garnier dupe but looking for alternatives.
Have you tried using a sunscreen stick for your eyes? My brother has sensitive eyes and uses a stick for his eye area and even when it's hot, the sunscreen doesn't run into his eyes and sting.
I heard Asian sunscreens can cause cancer. Is this true? I’m in the US and love skin aqua but I’m worried to use it regularly because of these claims
What is your source for this claim? It is a very overarching claim that sounds a lot like xenophobic fear mongering.
No this is not true.
I decided to purchase three Asian sunscreens with Tinosorb M. The reason is that this filter is (arguably) the best UV filter available worldwide, but it can leave a white cast when used in larger percentages (as is the case with most European sunscreens) and I knew that the two Japanese sunscreens of my haul have Tinosorb M at around 1% so this could allow definitely a first layer without white cast for my relatively fair skin and then I could reapply to build a stronger protection if needed. Also, the Korean sunscreen of my haul seems to have an INCI list that correlates with the claimed protection as opposed to some others that have been the cause of a controversy.
In addition, I ordered my beloved Skin aqua milk that is always a joy to apply as it leaves a semi matte finish on the skin and is strongly water resistant.I also ordered the Suncut essence because I was told that it is eye friendly as opposed to thegel and milk of the same line.
Also, I decided to try the cult favorite Melano CC as my perfect pre sunscreen step for some potent antioxidant protection.
Products shown:
Skin Aqua – UV super moisture milk
UV filters: Zinc Oxide, Octinoxate, Uvinul A Plus
Skin Aqua – UV super moisture essence
UV filters: Octinoxate, Tinosorb M, Tinosorb S, Uvinul A Plus
Skin Aqua UV super moisture essence gold
UV filters: Octinoxate, Tinosorb S, Uvinul A Plus, Tinosorb M
Rohto - Melano CC Vitamin C Essence
Notable Ingredients: Ascorbic Acid, Tocopheryl acetate, Dipotassium Glycyrrhizate,O-Cymen-5-Ol, Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate
Suncut – UV perfect essence
UV filters: Octinoxate, Parsol SLX, Uvinul A Plus, Tinosorb S
Scinic - Enjoy Super Mild sun essence
UV filters: Uvinul A Plus, Tinosorb S, Parsol SLX, Tinosorb M, Uvinul T 150, DiethylhexylButamido Triazone
I didn't have good experience with this. It's very slimy texture on my skin, like it sits on top of the skin, instead of absorbing...? Kinda reminded me of COSRX Snail Mucin essence as well but with different texture.
Btw, great haul! Looking forward for your reviews!
It feels very slimey when first applied (like The Ordinary formulations with almost 100%
propanediol) but it gets fully absorbed by my skin after 1 or 2 minutes. I don’t use too much though (not more than 10 drops).
The regular skin aqua essence seems to have more tinosorb m than the essence gold and they're both water and sweat resistant so I'm not sure what edge the gold has over the regular. Looking forward to your reviews. I currently have the Scinic essence and skin aqua milk in my cart. The milk gives me some concern re: uva1 protection though.
The percentages are as follows (for what they are worth):
Skin Aqua UV super moisture essence: Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate 7.38927%, Methylene Bis-Benzotriazolyl Tetramethylbutylphenol 1.006%, Bis-Ethylhexyloxyphenol Methoxyphenyl Triazine 0.8%, Diethylamino Hydroxybenzoyl Hexyl Benzoate 0.7%
Skin Aqua UV super moisture essence GOLD: Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate 8.044635%, Bis-Ethylhexyloxyphenol Methoxyphenyl Triazine 1.5%, Diethylamino Hydroxybenzoyl Hexyl Benzoate 1.05%, Methylene Bis-Benzotriazolyl Tetramethylbutylphenol 1 %
The essence gold has a higher UVA percentage of filters plus a more resistant formulation as far as I understand from their descriptions.
The milk also concerns me but it is a formula I love to use, so it is the “the best sunscreen is the one you use” formulation for me. I will use it when I don’t want to have issues such as dryness from too much powder, eye stinging, white cast, extreme shine, etc.
Oh thanks. Oh yeah the gold is definitely better. I was going by the position of Tinosorb M on the inci list on ratzilla.
Essence gold is said to also be humidity resistant…not gonna lie though, they sound pretty similar