r/dune•
Bossgrimm

Clarification

General Discussion

In light of recent posts, I thought I should point out that Dune, both the movies and the books, are not, in fact, Game of Thrones. I have done years of research on the matter and have come to the following conclusions: They are not written by the same author, they were not written in the same era, they are not the same type of fiction.

I the past few weeks, there have been many criticisms and questions as to why Dune is not like Game of Thrones. It is for the same reason that a bird is not a banana. Sure, they’re both complex and alive and you can eat them, but I don’t think the world would benefit from banana-flavored birds or flying bananas. They’re different. I may be alone in this, but just because something is not something else does not inherently make it good or bad. If you want Game of Thrones, go get it! Discuss at length how great it is with fellow enthusiasts and denounce other works that aren’t Game of Thrones with gusto! Just don’t do it on a subreddit marked “Dune.” Not that we are superior or anything, but such comments and arguments would be equally welcome and appropriate on a sub for baking scones or automobile repair.

Thank you.

Posted Sep 28, 2021, 12:07 AM UTC

288
Blue_ThreeGuild Navigator•

I feel like people are getting way too defensive over non-issues like this.

15

Flying Bananas.

Reminds me of the Bill Hicks and his anti war stance:

" imagine what we could do in solving world hunger if we redirected all that money to feeding the underprivileged, instead of building weapons": " kksssshp. Bill, I see a man in Ethiopia who is malnourished". "Roger, Roger. Sending him a rocket mounted banana now" Whoosh!

The Stealth Banana

10
cobalt358•

You're wrong about flying bananas

7
BossgrimmOPMentat•

The Tleilaxu have entered the chat.

14
WiserStudent557•

I have missed any posts you are referring to but I couldn’t agree more. Well said, bravo!

6
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hello! We're experiencing a significant increase in the number of posts about the new film. Any personal reviews, thoughts, questions, or general musings about Dune (2021) should be posted in our Dune (2021) Discussion Threads. For real-time discussion of the movie and everything else Dune-related, please consider joining our Discord server.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

GOT is feudal with fantasy. Characters name are very interesting. In Dune, Frank says it's a sci fi fantasy but actually is not. It's an intense political saga. The world building is great but never used in a fantasy way. He set up a universe and just leave it. The main thing which works in favour of dune is with passing of time, its story is becoming more n more relevant in today's political world. As far as writing is considered, Dune saga itself has many shortcomings in it.

-4
AnEvenNicerGuyFriend of Jamis•

Uuugggghhhhh. Just so relevant today

4