How does r/Antitheism feel about a creating a List of Religious Pedophiles on Wikipedia?
Posted Feb 20, 2012, 12:10 AM UTC
Posted Feb 20, 2012, 12:10 AM UTC
You'll need verifiable sources for it to be wikipedia material ... as far as I know, there is no conclusive evidence that the catholic church has done any such thing, only probable evidence, which is not enough for wikipedia.
It wouldn't just be in the Catholic church... There are many religious 'leaders' that have molested and sexually assaulted children. You wouldn't have to even say they were convicted, you could simply state that allegations have been made, and provide the evidence that there were indeed allegations and/or arrests.
As someone accused (and aquitted) of a crime (theft) I never committed, you are an asshole.
Imagine if this had happened in my case, a "concerned parent" posting a list of everyone accused of theft in the local area. My name would be worth less than shit after that.
The mere accusation of that type of behaviour can ruin a person, even if they are innocent, and you want to create a hit-list for the kneejerk "THINK OF THE CHILDREN" crowd?
no, this is a terrible idea and you should be ashamed of yourself.
Um, I am sorry that you read that the wrong way. You should maybe take a deep breath an calm down and let me clarify what I meant.
All of this information is public knowledge. Anyone can access this information already. If you are citing sources on wiki, more than likely it is a well publicized case that has already been in the news. At the very least there already has to be a record somewhere of this information.
I don't know what state you live in or who you are, but chances are if I knew your information (just your name and the state you live in, which I assume everyone you know already knows) I could pull up your court information with little effort. Also, depending on where you live details of your arrest might have been published in your local newspaper. Sorry... but there are already lists of people accused of theft in your local area, is your name shit yet?
This isn't creating a "hit-list" it is providing an accumulated source of information from information that is already readily available. The wikipage wouldn't just be a list of names, it would be about the topic in general, include names, and relevant case information.
oh bullshit,
it's collecting public information and saying "HEY EVERYONE, LOOK AT THESE PERVERTS!".
Could someone explain to me why, I don't really get it. What is the purpose of creating a list specifically with religious pedophiles?
Wouldn't it make more sense to create a list of quotes from holy scripts and so on, that approves of pedophilia?
To me - this reeks of cheap smear campaign. Something that religious nuts would put together about atheists and anti-theists. "Look! they have no morals and are lost, they are pedophiles and devil worshippers! look at this list with atheist pedophile scumbags!"
Also, does wikipedia allow such lists (perhaps if they are historical figures)?
That's understandable.
It doesn't necessarily have to be theists only. Any religious/cult/agnostic/atheist figurehead that's been found to have molested children. Like the post above, the hard part would be teasing apart innocuous sexual offenses. However, there's no shortage of rape and sexual abuse of children by the religious in the news.
There's been a mention on Wiki about making a category for American rapists so it might be possible, again verifying it being the hardest part.
As for scripture quotes.. maybe WikiQuote but it's pretty flooded with nonsense.
I think Wikipedia is not the place to do it.
Putting such a list on any Wiki is a bad idea because if the public can edit it then villains' names will vanish and the names of innocents will be slandered.
Let's say I put Monsignor Leonard Nienaber on that list, citing news sources saying that while he was regularly molesting children the church administration knew about it and did nothing. I might check back every once in a while to make sure his name stayed on the list but there are a few thousand other people from his old parish who might delete his name because they don't want to see their church lose face. One of them might think to look in the page history and find out that it's me putting the sick old prick back on the list and they might think it would be funny to put my name on the list instead.
I don't think I'd like that.
Besides, on Wikipedia, a "List of N" page is for links to individual entries for each N. If you're not planning on making a Wikipedia entry for each pedophile, then there's really no reason for a "List of" entry on Wikipedia.
That's a fair concern, backlash by having your name slandered for ensuring accuracy. Though, once there are frequent changes (i.e. editing wars) to wiki articles they would lock the article due to the obvious vandalism it would receive.
You can make a list that doesn't necessarily have to reference their own article, just mention the name and the reference to a legitimate article on them. For example.
That's a fair concern, backlash by having your name slandered for ensuring accuracy.
My main concern is that there is no way to ensure accuracy on a Wiki.
Though, once there are frequent changes (i.e. editing wars) to wiki articles they would lock the article due to the obvious vandalism it would receive.
Doesn't that defeat the purpose of creating this page on Wikipedia in the first place?
If you want a page which will be accurate and which you'll be able to update, then just make the page on your own site and ask people to submit additions by e-mail.
I'll help. I think it would be great.
I don't think this would accomplish much. All it does is show that there are bad people of all types, and of all faiths. This won't surprise or convince anyone. We already have tons of this kind of material, and it is just met with 'just because some of the people are bad, does not mean that the Word is flawed."
Even if we could show conclusive proof that there is a huge conspiracy to harbor and protect pedophiles in the Catholic church, unless the Pope were implicated, it would not prove anything other than that there are some bad apples in every basket.
Well...
"In the 1970s, paedophilia was theorised as something fully in conformity with man and even with children,” the Pope said.
Doesn't seem damning to me. He wasn't giving out religious doctrine, just talking about some theories. And even if I am wrong, it was the first thing to pop into my head, so a defensive theist could easily claim it.
It is true. And it's still true. The most important intellectuals and philosophers of the 20th century defended pedophilia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_Morality_and_the_Law).
Now pedophilia is just the new homosexuality. People are indoctrinated to believe its "bad" and all that. But it is a normal and healthy sexual orientation.
Excuse me but how exactly does being a pedophile make you "bad"?
Would you say that having a different sexual orientation makes you bad?
There are bad people of all sexual orientations, including pedophiles. That doesnt mean that being a pedophile makes you "bad" or that a pedophile is a bad person. There are bad gays, bad heterosexuals and bad pedophiles. But being gay, heterosexual or pedophile is not bad in itself.
It doesn't, but through abstinence, which the Catholic church loves, seems to breed the bad ones.
[deleted]
Not a bad idea. And it think it is appropriate that you post a picture of Joey the Rat to highlight the point. He was in charge of the group that in the old days used to be called the Inquisition (now under a different name about defending the faith, I think). He led the policy effort to not publicize the pedophile rapist clergy, sometimes by transferring them and rarely by easing them out of the Church. You could say that the Church handled it the same way that any corporation would have handled it--self-protection as the prime directive. No special mea culpa because they are only servants of god and the faithful.
Why a list of religious pedophiles and not a list of religious gays? Or religious heterosexuals? Or religious black people?
This is outright discrimination based on sexual orientation. There is nothing wrong about being a pedophile. Even I am an atheist, I recognize there is nothing wrong about being a pedophile and religious.
Why dont we add gay religious people? Or a list about heterosexual priests? Pedophiles have exactly the same rights as anyone. This is discrimination based on sexual orientation.
There is nothing wrong about being pedophile, gay or lesbian. There is absolutely nothing to be ashamed of if you have a different sexual orientation.
People who arent straight shouldnt live in fear and shame for being different, for having a different sexual orientation.
If you promote the discrimination of people who have a different sexual orientation, you are a monster who contribute to make the world a worse place.
So I ask you again, why dont you think that this is discrimination based on sexual orientation and if we should also make lists about gay priests or religious lesbians or heterosexual cardinals.
Why a list of religious pedophiles and not a list of religious gays? Or religious heterosexuals? Or religious black people?
This is outright discrimination based on sexual orientation. There is nothing wrong about being a pedophile. Even I am an atheist, I recognize there is nothing wrong about being a pedophile and religious.
Sorry, a better title for this thread should have read as 'List of Religious Pedophile Rapists' but that isn't all encompassing.
Why dont we add gay religious people? Or a list about heterosexual priests? Pedophiles have exactly the same rights as anyone. This is discrimination based on sexual orientation.
Pedophilia is a sexual preference not a sexual orientation
If you promote the discrimination of people who have a different sexual orientation, you are a monster who contribute to make the world a worse place.
No, but I think it's about time there's some consistent exposure concerning all these priests found for child molestation rather than having it forgotten about after you finish reading an article about it.
So I ask you again, why dont you think that this is discrimination based on sexual orientation and if we should also make lists about gay priests or religious lesbians or heterosexual cardinals.
It bothers me that it's such a legitimate issue but it's being swept under the rug because it's such a taboo topic and people do not wish to admit that it's extensive. Suicide is pretty taboo too but unlike suicide bombers, the amount of religious child rape victims isn't going down every year..
I think this is an understandable, and natural idea. However, it goes to violate the same basic rights as it does in regular society.
Plenty of people have been caught changing in their car, or peeing in public, and are then arrested for a sexual offense. Plenty more people are accused of sexual assault, or rape, and never actually committed these crimes. Even if they are released, with no charges pressed, the arrest is on their record, and can ruin their life, forever, never having done anything wrong. This is an example of de jure law holding too much potential harm to be really viable.
Come on, you can't be serious about being in public being a sexual offense (in the US?). I mean I know there are some weird fetishes out there but there's nothing sexual about pissing against a tree.
It's extremely common. I live in the California Bay Area, and there are a lot of guys who change into/out of wetsuits in their cars, if someone sees them, sex offender registry. Same with pissing in public. In addendum, if a child is in any way involved (Let's say a kid sees you changing, or you pee near a school), it can be brought up to a felony charge, and result in prison.
Whoa I just can't wrap my head around that. There's no way a kid is going to be damaged because they saw a person change their clothes or pee. If anything, this unhealthy obsession the US (government) seems to have with anything nude and keeping it away from the kids at the expense of everyone's freedom is more damaging. Just... Fuck
(from the Netherlands btw, for context. Here you get a minor fine for peeing outside, and we have nudist beaches.)
There are some places it's legal to be nude. In Santa Cruz, everyone can be topless. I think in San Francisco, you can be naked, but you can't have an erection (heresay, I've never tried it), and I know of a single nude beach north of Santa Cruz county. It's weird, and it is wholly unhealthy, because it keeps the U.S. shackled in this puritanical state of mind. You know what else is illegal? Weed. But everyone knows that - here's one that is less popular: It is against federal U.S. law to sell the milk from an animal you own. Because it hasn't gone through FDA approval, it's illegal. Beyond that, it's a felony to GIVE the milk away. And the best part - you can't even drink it yourself. If you have a goat, in the U.S., and you milk it, and drink the milk, you can go to prison.
Do you have an extra bedroom I can stay in?