How to prepare daughter for topics of beauty, self worth, body image, etc.?
I recently had a troubling discussion with a female family member about girl body image.
She suggested that from a very young age I (dad) need to be complimenting my daughter (currently 9 month old) about her beauty. The goal being that she grows up with a positive body image, and is confident about her looks as she approaches puberty/adulthood. (as an aside, this conversation branched into some weird territory where she said it was rooted in the female version of the Oedipus complex. I need to be complimenting my daughter for her looks in order to compensate for the fact that I am rejecting her sexually, in favor of her mother).
My gut response is that I should be praising her for basically _anything other than_ beauty/body image, and only addressing that topic if she specifically asks me. Teaching her that beauty is the source of her value is not good in the long run. This ties into limiting her access to media that glorifies beauty (tv commercials, instagram, beauty magazine, etc.).
Now obviously I can't stop my daughter from experiencing the world, specifically American culture since that's where we're at. It seems like I should be fighting against the prevailing notions of American beauty standards though, rather than placing her within those standards.
Anyways, any thoughts on how to raise a girl in modern American culture without giving her some weird complex that beauty is her source of self worth?
Posted Oct 4, 2021, 1:23 PM UTC
Family member, huh? What do you know about her father? Could you ask her how she was raised in this regard?
I suspect she's trying to solve a very legitimate problem in a way that doesn't totally work.
Self-image and self-worth have a complicated relationship, but for me - and I only have a 1-year-old son so what do I know - the bottom line is you can and should be happy, or at least accepting, about the way you look.
I don't think she's right to tie your daughter's self-worth completely to her self-image, even if she has a great self-image. But I also don't think it would be helpful to completely separate your daughter's happiness from her self-image. We can take pride in physical features that distinguish us and make us individual and unique. We can also take pride in the ways we dress and adorn ourselves to show our identity and personality.
If she chooses to wear a certain outfit or do something with her hair, put on makeup or jewelry, I think you can support her personal choices in those things. I would be very careful not to blindly support harmful standards of beauty - like if she comes in wearing something that a celebrity is popularizing, and asks you if it looks good, you could say you support her choice and her identity, but you may want to ask some questions about why she's wearing it - whether it's something she wants to do that makes her happy, or something she feels social pressure to wear or else she won't fit in.
It's extremely important to support your kid and build her confidence. I think you and your family member can agree on that.