MIL is very pushy, and husband expects me to handle it, need advice

New User 👋

I'm not a regular poster here but need some advice in this particular instance.

My MIL is a nice person, but as she gets older, she's getting... loopy. And so, so PUSHY. She tells me she's going to do things, she doesn't ask. I'm facing two specific situations with her that I need help with. First, she wants to host Christmas this year for the family, fine by me. But she's telling me "I'm going to borrow your Xmas decorations and Xmas tree". Not asking. Telling me! Second, she keeps making jokes about moving in with us after her husband dies. "Oh, when X dies, I'll just move in with you!" She says it like a joke, but I know it's more of a hint. They have zero savings and spend all their money so yes she will be homeless when her husband dies, and she expects us to take her in if that happens. She's already moving all her craft stuff into my basement, because I do the craft as well, and on Friday she wanted to come and "organize the craft area". I told her to text me first, I might be gone. "Oh, I won't need you there," she replied. That morning she texted "on my way". Not even asking me to come over. Just "on my way".

My husband won't help me with her. He gets mad at me for not standing up to her. I've told him I need help. I'm naturally introverted and a pushover, and I struggle with this. He's firm about not letting MIL move in with us, but he won't talk to her about it or tell her straight up, which worries me. He gets upset that I didn't text her first to say "don't come over" when she wants to organize the craft space, and says I should have been proactive.

So basically I need advice on how to deal with her pushiness. My husband is reluctant to say anything because she's literally our only help with our autistic toddler, which is a lot of work. My family lives far away. I don't want her to borrow my damn christmas stuff. I want to decorate my own house. But even if I tell her that, she always finds a way to brush it off, or she "jokes" her way out of it and does what she wants anyway. This has been a problem since my son was born 2 years ago, Help ):

Posted Oct 10, 2021, 4:36 PM UTC

31183
Off-With-Her-Head•

If you're passively accepting her intrusions, your husband can't help later. You need to practice gently but firmly pushing back sentences. The best are short and to the point

"We need our tree and decorations here, but I'll set a few things aside for your party."

"The craft room is too much for our house. Let's start packing the items up for you to take home."

Then send DH to her house with the stuff.

"Please don't drop by unless you've spoken to me first, to be clear if it's a good time for us."

The most important thing is to not "explain" or give excuses. Those are how intrusive people argue with you. Just find your own words to block her suggestions. As an adult, you can do this.

Managing back people who try to take over your house & life need to be redirected, firmly.

69
Laquila•

Ah yes, the "loopy" sweet old lady act, used to disguise what is basically deliberate boundary-stomping. Makes like she doesn't hear or understand, or "forgets", while she bulldozes over your personal space, wants, needs, and life. It's disrespectful and you should not put up with it, just because she birthed your husband.

Your husband is wrong, btw. She is HIS mother and HE should be the one telling her to back off. He's probably afraid to or she's just always stomped over his boundaries and he thinks that's normal. Since he's told you he won't deal with her, go ahead and do it yourself. Start saying NO, a lot. "No, that doesn't work for me." If she pretends she didn't hear or that she forgot, repeat it. Or "Sorry, but I need MY space. That's just the way I am."

Lock the doors, don't answer your phone and do not lend her your Christmas decorations. I'd even box up her craft stuff and drop it off at her home. How dare she have done that? Just because she does the craft too is not an excuse to do that. She cooks too, I expect. Does she get to take over your kitchen too?

Stand up for yourself. If your husband complains about you doing this, marriage counselling is in order. He should not be prioritizing what his mother wants over you.

39
AngryRaccoon01•
  • Change the locks.
  • Don’t answer the door if it’s inconvenient.
  • When she says, “the craft space” tell her, “I’m content with my craft room the way it is right now.”
  • Practice scripts for her usual boundary stomps. If she says she’s going to borrow your decorations, say, “You need a new plan. Those are going up at my place.” If she says she’s moving in with you, say, “Yikes. Can you imagine? I can barely share a house with my husband and kids!”

She’s pushy because it works, and she knows you’re too anxious to push back. That should make you angry. She’s taking advantage of you. Use that anger to help you stand up for yourself. Because it sounds like your husband won’t be bothered. Talk to a counselor about strategies.

And as a mom of a profoundly autistic child, I’m telling you, you need to source some other resources to help with your toddler. Things are only going to get tougher, and it’s important to have resources in place. Is there government funding for respite care and behavioral aides where you live? Anything through community groups, churches, schools or non-profits. I fell into the trap of relying on my MIL for help and didn’t source out more skilled help. First of all, as she ages, she’s less able to help, and secondly, it put me in a “you owe me” spot so I felt I had less power and authority in my own life. I wish I hadn’t.

38
Cat_ProxyOP•

We have therapists and nursery school but we desperately need evening or weekend respite, which is what my MIL does - she watches him sometimes so we can have a break or go out. I'm trying to find a babysitter/nanny for a few hours a week but it's a... process.... to say the least. Contacting all our resources for recommendations, which is not getting me much for results. Was hoping to find someone experienced with special needs or pursuing a degree related to it.

8
AngryRaccoon01•

I understand entirely.

5
TheKidsAreAsleep•

Yes. This. A thousand times.

I have two on the spectrum and it just kills me that I didn’t know what all services were available early on.

5
Reliant20•

I am so annoyed for you! You have two things to tackle: your husband and your MIL. Yes, he's failing as a partner in not stepping up, but I still think you need to learn to step up too. It's a good general rule that each spouse handles their own family, but it's not workable in every interaction.

I think you need to get comfortable talking to her. If she really is "very nice", she shouldn't blow up at being told she has to respect boundaries more. If she's holding your childcare hostage, then she's a jerk who definitely shouldn't be allowed to impact your life negatively. Practice saying no in the moment, and not explaining or acting like you're submitting your boundaries for her approval:

"Sorry, we're going to need our Christmas decorations. Nope, sorry. Gotta go, bye."

"No, sorry, I want to be there when a room in my house is reorganized. Nope. We already talked about how you have to let us know first. We're going out now, but I'll talk to you and set up a time later."

If she shows up anyway, then have a serious talk with her about how her treatment of your house and possessions isn't working for you, and tell your husband his ass better be there for it.

Obviously, these moments have passed, but it's not too late to address these issues. I suggest text messages: "Hi, MIL. You mentioned taking our decorations and tree. Just wanted to let you know now that's not going to work. It means a lot to us to have house decorated for the Christmas season, and it would take a lot away from that time for us not to have that. Letting you know now so you can make other arrangements."

The craft room thing should be handled similarly. Remind her that she ignored what you said, and it's not going to work for you to have her show up and rearrange rooms in your house, and that your space is limited and she needs to take some of that stuff back to her house.

These things don't have to be handled unkindly, though if she pushes back, it's confirming she's really not concerned with what works for you, and basically telling her to cut the crap once and for all would be justified.

When she mentions moving in with you "as a joke", treat it like a joke when you reply, "Yeah, not happening, lol. I married DH, not his relatives, lol."

It's also time to have a talk with your husband. Maybe something like: "I will work on speaking up more, but you have to stop leaving me to deal with this alone. Your mom's becoming a real problem, and I'm not the only adult in this house and marriage. I need you to work with me here."

Sorry for such a ridiculously long response!

EDIT: typos

31
Trixie1267•

It was an excellent response

7
lonelysilverrain•

First warn your husband he may not like how you handle talking to his mother. And if that's the case, too bad for him. He had the chance to take this on himself and won't do it. Of course this is probably exactly what he prefers, that you're the bad guy.

Now on to MIL. First off, tree and decorations are NO and NO. Who the hell "borrows" someone else's Xmas tree and decorations. She's grownup, she can buy her own and I'm sure she has plenty of decorations of her own. If not, offer to go with her and help buy some. But does not get the tree (unless you and DH buy a new one) and she definitely does not get YOUR decorations.

Second, she appears to have a key to your home. Change the locks. If she texts she's coming over, tell her you're not home. And leave the house. Let her find out for herself that her access is now denied. When she complains, let her know that this is your home and YOU decide who has access and when. Her constant stomping of your boundaries has changed her from a welcome guest to an unwelcome one. From now on, she ASKS to come into your home, she does not tell you when she is coming. If you don't set boundaries and enforce them, you'll be dealing with this forever. If she just shows up and you answer the door, tell her this is not a good time, then close the door in her face.

Last, you need to sit down with DH and plan for what you will do about his mother after his father is gone. Whether you set up some kind of funds now so that you'll be able to keep her somewhere or he deals with other family members to figure out what to do with her, you both need to be on the same page from the get go.

I know you're introverted and this is not your style but believe me, people like your MIL see you as the perfect opportunity to get away with whatever they want. You have to buckle down, give yourself a pep talk, and as Nancy Reagan used to say, "Just say No". Don't give explanations or reasons, No is a complete answer and all you have to give. You give her a reason and she'll tell you why it doesn't matter. Tell her No and tell her end of discussion. She'll end up complaining to DH about how mean you are to her and he'll probably laugh at her and tell her she deserves it. If not and he comes to you about it, remind him you warned him. But it's up to you to put your foot down. Ideally it would be better to refer everything to him but there comes a time to put on your adult pants and enforce your will. Now is the time. The longer this goes on the worse it will be.

28
BaffledMum•

Your husband is right--you need to be more proactive. And you need to say "No" a lot more.

"No, you're not borrowing my Christmas stuff." Give her a, "are you nuts?" look as you do so.

"No, you can't reorganize MY craft area. In fact, it's really too crowded for me to work--you better take your stuff away. I'll box it for you."

"No, you can't come over when I'm not here." Don't let her in if you don't want her in, and if she's got a key, take it away or change the locks.

Don't let her do things. It's hard to stand in front of a pushy person, but that's the only way she'll stop.

As for the moving in later stuff, your husband should address that. Give him a deadline, and if he doesn't address it, tell her yourself.

27
nonstop2nowhere•

"That doesn't work for us."

"I'm not available for that, you'll have to make other arrangements."

"That will not be happening."

"If you want to make plans for my home, personal property, time, or future, MIL, I'm going to need you to ask first and be willing to engage in an adult conversation about it."

"My items are not available for your personal use without prior notice and confirmation, MIL."

"I'm willing to have a conversation about it, but no, you don't get to just tell me what you're doing with my stuff/time/home/etc."

Have a few statements that you can practice and be ready to pull out as needed. Don't be unkind, but don't worry about being blunt and straightforward with her - let her know exactly what she needs to do differently and what isn't going to happen (even though she expects it to). It's going to feel a little weird and wrong because it's new, but it'll get easier.

(My MIL told us that she would be throwing her diabetes care out the window and moving to our home when she got too sick to take care of herself because we're nurses. She did the same "haha isn't that funny" tone...while eating poorly in front of us. We let her know "That's never going to happen, and you're going to be getting exactly what care FIL wants to provide for you, so you ought to keep yourself as healthy as possible for as long as possible." She has taken our advice and stopped some of the dietary BS because she knows that when we tell her how it is we mean it.)

There are a lot of good books and things on boundary setting in the Resources link. Best wishes!

27
annswertwin•

Use your words. Being an introvert doesn’t equate to being a push over. My daughter is an introvert and nobody messes with her quiet ass. People treat you as badly as you let them . Keep it simple and In real time. She tells you something , you say no and don’t give reasons. Don’t give her room to poke holes in your no. Just no over and over.

26

Then handle it. Bring her craft stuff back to her house. She is already trying to move in. Tell her "No you will not borrow my Christmas decorations. I am using them." Do nothing other than bring a side dish for Christmas dinner. Her son can help her. As far as moving in. Tell her "That is not happening" when she says something about moving in. Suggest she ask other relatives. Tell DH if she moves in you move out. If he doesn't like the way you handle her he can step up. " No" is a complete sentence.

25
VadaReno•

It is his mother so he need to talk to her. He also needs to setup an appointment and go with his parents with a financial planner.

23

"No." It's a complete sentence. "No, you can't have my decorations." "No, you can't live with us."

The answer is No.

"Why?" "It doesn't work for us" "I don't want to"

23
cloistered_around•

Both sets of our parents started "joking" about living in our basement after retirement, and after greyrocking as best I could by the 6th time they joked about it I said with a laugh "no one is living in our basement but the mice!"

It also came across as a joke. But they got the point because they haven't mentioned it since. So I suggest tactics like that: polite jokes, confusion, etc.

"I'm going to borrow your Christmas tree" I'm confused, are you getting us a new tree or something? (let her answer, keep playing dumb and ask if she cleared this borrow with DH because it's the first you've heard about it)

"On my way" (don't answer the door because you already let her know you might not be home. So just don't "be home" when she gets there.)

There's no way to stop being a pushover than baby steps. Each confrontation go a tiny bit out of your comfort zone, and you'll be surprised in a few months/years how good you got at defending yourself along the way as your comfort zone expands.

23
medicalbillsrus•

Sit her down. Text her if it's easier.

  1. MIL. I will be using my decorations for Christmas so you will need to make other arrangements.
  2. I am not comfortable with anyone being in my house when I am not there. Please contact me at least 24 hours in advance to arrange to work in my basement.
  3. You keep joking about moving in with us, and that's not going to happen. Again, make other arrangements. I appreciate all you do for my child, and you will always be his grandmother, and I appreciate you, but we are adults and we need our own space and life. Thank you for understanding.

Remember. You CAN say no to her. Practice in the mirror. "No. That won't work for us." Repeat it as often as you need to do so. Good luck!!!

23
GoddessofWind•

If she's showing an escalating pattern of irrational behavior as she gets older that should always prompt concern over the state of her cognitive processes. A downward spiral can indicate that her mental capacity if being affected by something and if it is then prompt diagnosis can slow the decline so you should be pushing back on your dh to get her a check up.

She is his mother, not yours, and it is not your job to manage her because he doesn't want to. He needs to accept his responsibility and do something, firstly get her checked by her Dr. If that comes back clean then he needs to sort out her pushiness himself instead of trying to get you to do it so that he can have a nice easy life.

For your part, you need to learn to tell her no.

"No MIL you will not be taking my tree and decorations, they are mine for my house. If you want a tree and decorations then please buy your own." if she jokes you say "I said NO mil, and I mean NO mil. You are not taking my decorations and that is final. " If she jokes again you leave.

"No MIL, you are not moving in with me and dh when your dh dies, please stop trying to make plans that involve us, we are not your retirement plan."

"No MIL, you are not coming over right now it's not convenient for us, please respect our home and only come when you are invited or it has been arranged between us" - if she has a key to your home then take it back if she's inferring that she will just come in without you there.

I suggest you box up all her craft stuff and give it back to her, she can't do the craft if all her stuff is in your basement now can she, so is she actually doing the craft or is it an excuse to get her stuff into your home?

Keep saying no, keep backing up the no and if she doesn't listen, leave. If she comes to take your decorations she is told no and that she needs to leave because she is being rude. If her helping you with your toddler is dependent upon her running your life and owning all your stuff then you need to find an alternative solution that does not involve her help, help that comes with string is not helpful.

22
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

21
kellyfromfig•

Great advice here! Sounds like OP has a lot going on, and it’s time to bring in whatever extra support she can, like state resources for the autistic child, and financial planning for the in-laws, as well as some marriage coaching to get the spouse on board with what’s going on. OP is going to have to overcome their non-confrontational style to protect her family

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Parking-Ad-1952•

“Sorry MIL Christmas is a season. It is not a day. I will be using my Christmas decorations to decorate my home.”

When she hints about moving in. Straight up laugh in her face.

Your DH should be dealing with his mother. She is not your job and he shouldn’t be dumping her in your lap. Does your husband think that managing your parents is his job?

21

Sorry- she is not getting loopy. She is a master manipulator and is establishing her way to get 100% what she wants and to make you her servant.

She has already figured out that:

husband is reluctant to say anything because she's literally our only help with our autistic toddler, which is a lot of work

The only way to stop this BS is to team up with your husband (which will probably take therapy so you can function as a team)

for now?

  • NO to Christmas- you need to decorate YOUR house for your son!!

  • re-key your locks- she has no rights to access your home

  • she gets ALL her craft stuff back to her house. Dump it in the front yard if she whines and won't let you bring it in.

  • tell her straight up- put it in writing- that she is NOT going to live with you. Lots of resources available to seniors for financial planning, so she'd best get to looking NOW.

  • I agree with another poster- start sourcing help for your child outside of her. She is going to use this as a trap and will start doing things to interfere with what you are choosing or flaking out on helping. Don't let her get your child upset so she can use him as a pawn in her game.

20
IZC0MMAND0•

Send your MIL a text or email. Whichever is her preferred form of written communication.

MIL, you mentioned borrowing my Christmas tree and decorations and I was pretty sure you were joking, but after thinking about it, it occurred to me you are serious. I am decorating my house with my tree and decorations, so I just wanted to make sure it was a joke and not a request. next time she tells you something, respond back in the moment. Sorry not available

Your DH is making it clear he supports you but he doesn't want to be the bad guy. You are going to have to dust off your "No"

"I'm going to bring over xyz and store it in your basement ". No Do not explain why. Just say no. Repeat no if necessary. Smile and change the subject.

She texts "I'm on my way over to reorganize your craft room." Do you need help loading your crafts into your car? possibly add good idea, it's getting cluttered, I'll help you pack your supplies up to take back to your place The next thing she wants to store at your home, no matter how she words it, tell her no as if it was a request. Example "I'm going to store this bedroom set in your basement" no or *no, we don't want our house filled with clutter" *no, we don't have room"

"you don't need to be there". Yes, I do.

" I'm going to move in with you when FIL passes away" Oh no. Seriously MIL, have you thought about saving or getting enough life insurance so that you can afford a place to live?

Someone better head that thinking off before they blow all their money. They can start reining in their spending now. Your DH should tell her no the next time, but if you have to tell her, be sure she knows this is a joint decision. He can be gutless but you don't have to cover for him.

You are going to have to speak up and let her know this isn't an option. She's hinting now because she is testing the waters. She hasn't had the guts to outright ask. Every time she hints and you don't shoot it down, she gets more secure in thinking this will happen. If you think she will be upset or hurt by your telling her no right now, imagine how she'll feel after the funeral when she's making plans to move in. You both absolutely are doing her a disservice by allowing her to think this is an option.

This is a time to know that she's going to have to save money while she can. Downsize to a smaller more affordable home. Get more life insurance. Make better financial choices. Even if your husband has to look into someplace affordable for them to live. I don't know if they own a home or not. What their finances are. Maybe they could buy a duplex or two family home in an area where there is no problem finding renters. Condos are generally more affordable, but you have to watch Association fees. Manufactured homes are very affordable, but if you have to rent a lot that can be pricey. Some areas allow manufactured homes/park models on your own land. If your DH is firm on his no, he really ought to broach the subject and run some options that don't include either of them living with you. Better to think now, research now, rather than wait and nothing is available.

He should have this chat with his dad if he's in poor health or up there in years. Dad, you and mom should get settled into a one story smaller home that either one of you an handle on your own if something happens to the other one of you.

20
Anjapayge•

This is a DH issue. My DH tried this on me and boy if I am forced to handle it, I can really piss his mom off which upsets his dad which causes DH bigger issues. Or if I totally drop the ball, DH is forced to confront his mom without any support from me and he doesn’t much care for it. Though of course I am able to do this because MIL doesn’t help us in any way. Maybe DH feels like he owes her for helping.

20
bran6442•

Put up your decorations early. " Ha ha, it was really funny you joking about using my decorations for your home, wouldn't that be weird, right, kind of like wearing someone else's clothes! You are always joking about things like that, I can never take you seriously!"

20