r/exjw•
ProbablyPimo

Successful lawsuit payouts?

HELP

Do we know of any CSA lawsuits that the WT had to pay out, or are verdicts kept confidential? I would like to have receipts of plaintiffs winning CSA cases, if possible, for when I explain why I'm leaving.

Posted Oct 14, 2021, 4:35 PM UTC

915
Truthdoesntchange•

It’s incredibly rare for a plantiff to have a successful lawsuit in this type of situation. Even if the plant of wins, the defendant will appeal and, during that process, they will reach a settlement for an undisclosed amount. Most of the time, it doesn’t even get to that point, as a confidential settlement is agreed upon prior to an Initial verdict.

To be honest, the amount of money watchtower has paid out really shouldn’t matter. At most, it could be a reason to explain why you want to stop donating.

But if you are explaining why you are leaving, the fact that abuse happens and is not immediately reported to the police 100% of the time (even if the laws allow religions to cover it up) is sufficient. Purely on moral grounds, decent people do not want to be part of an organization that covers up child sex abuse. If anyone disagrees with you on that, the problem is with their moral compass.

9
ProbablyPimoOP•

My angle was going to be that the lawsuits can't be fake if the bOrg settled.

4
Truthdoesntchange•

Not sure what you mean by “fake.” Lawsuits are a matter of public record. They are real. The outcome of the lawsuits doesn’t change anything.

If you are referring to whether the allegations in the lawsuits are true, that also doesn’t matter. Settling a lawsuit is not an admission of guilt. Plenty of “innocent” people/corporations settle lawsuits all the time since it’s cheaper/more expedient than going to court.

7
SkepticInAllThingsPIMS - S for Skeptical. OK being half in & half out•

True dat!

5
DLWOIM•

Splane covered that in his talk. Of course to a non or exJW his reasoning is awful, but to a PIMI it makes perfect sense. They settle out of court to avoid going to trial and making a big stink that will drag gods name through the mud. Surely that’s a noble and righteous use of donated funds /s. Plus he provided biblical prededent. All I’m saying is, your argument will most likely fall on deaf ears.

6
ProbablyPimoOP•

I know it will, but I still have to try.

2
DLWOIM•

I know the feeling. Im still trying to wake up someone who seems to be getting more indoctrinated every time I talk to them. I always tell myself im not gonna say anything but we’ve been trained our whole lives to want to share the truth with people.

5
T_JJ_26127•

The Candace Conti trial was one of the biggest ones that they lost and had to pay millions. YouTube or Google “Candace Conti VS JW” also there is a great article too on the Atlantic’s website called “a secret database of child abuse”

6
ProbablyPimoOP•

Thank you! I will definitely be using The Atlantic article.

3
I_Am_Anakin•

From what I've heard when a settlement is reached you have to sign a non disclosure agreement to get the money.

5
ProbablyPimoOP•

Yeah, that's what I thought. Just wanted to exhaust all my options first.

2
I_Am_Anakin•

This article gives some numbers and what they were after appeals. This is the Candice Conti case.

https://revealnews.org/article/california-court-guts-child-abuse-ruling-against-jehovahs-witnesses/

3
ProbablyPimoOP•

Thank you!

1
SkepticInAllThingsPIMS - S for Skeptical. OK being half in & half out•

True dat!

1
rupunzelsawake•

You could also come from the angle that the organisation mimics the Catholics by claiming clergy penitent privilege. You could say that the org even went to court to have its right to clergy penitent privilege upheld. They won in the Montana Supreme Court. More recently though they lost in the US Supreme court. (Yay!!) I would not want to he associated with an organisation that will fight, tooth and nail , to harbour pedophiles from the consequences of their crimes and to not protect vulnerable children. And while they fight to have the clergy exception to reporting CSA they allow the rank and file jws to believe that they "endeavour to report" all CSA allegations to the authorities!!. The truth is that they make every effort NOT to report.

3