How to help my brother who is not motivated and has anger issues without him thinking I'm his enemy

For context, all the children of my father are more or less abused since young, but one of my brothers (V) got it worse than all of us.

V used to travel around and do holiday work like picking fruits and working as casual staff in various places in different countries. But since few years ago he decided to settle in a place which rely on our mum's visa, he's dependent and he was brainwashed by my father to hate my mum. My parents are separated btw. V used to work on and off, and due to his mental health and the lack of ability to perform team working skills, he can't find a stable job and now he's just staying at home (2years)and play games all the time.

I play games myself and I don't blame games. But the problem is he's also causing trouble on and off due to his behaviour, he'll leave the dishes out, not cleaning after himself, when my mum asked him to simply do the basic chores like cleaning the dish that he used, he will not co-operate and will do more damage than before, like purposely throw stuff around and my mum has to clean it up.

Due to the pandemic, I've been stuck on another country and not able to help physically. My mum has some conditions that needed surgery and she's been in pain for many months now, with my brother acting like this, I want to find a good gentle way to not anger him but motivate him to at least pick himself up and ease my mum's burden. Since he might get hysterical if I say the wrong thing. We've had a lots of conversation with him and he can always find an excuse for his actions like to the point that he blames my mum for bringing him to this world.

My mum is at the point where she said once the visa is over, she'll kick my brother out. But my brother's initial anger about my mum is because she did that before and she half-assed it. I worry that he will revenge on her if she do it again. I hope he can at least try to find a thing that he can do to at least make himself happy, since 24/7 staying at home is prolly why his mental health is going downhill on the first place.

Tldr: How to motivate my brother with mental health and anger issues without making him feel offended. Advice is much appreciated.

Posted Oct 17, 2021, 12:36 PM UTC

78
frizzykidRapid editor here•

How old is your brother? Mental illness is very complicated, and your brother probably needs some sort of counseling. If he doesn't want it though you can't force him and really nothing you say will help.

Id start by addressing the concerns you have about your brothers behavior and how it frightens you and your mom and you think it's time he starts to see a specialist to help him control his behavior before he does something that he will really regret.

If he doesn't want help, there isn't much you can do. People need to want to be helped and to make a difference to seek it or for treatment to even be effective. Your mom has to cut him off if that's the case. Abusive behavior rarely starts out physical person to person. It starts off yelling, and then hitting walls and breaking things, and then you throw things and they hit people, or you raise a fist or slap. It's not something that will get better on its own, that's for sure.

3
Ceirios_o7OP•

Thank you. I understand that, he's 27 this year and normally when we try to address his issues to motivate him to be more productive to help himself and he will say things like, I'm dyslexic, so I'm dumb, I didn't finish highschool, so I can't do anything. And we explained that that doesn't make him dumb and listed out things that he can do without a high school qualifications and suggest apprenticeship. At the end he normally will say, mum is the one who brought him to this world so she had to take responsibility.

He can get a bit sensitive about his condition and often results in increased aggressive behaviour when he took it wrongly. I will try to slide this in gently, but at the moment we're finding a way to break it to him slowly. I just worry that once my mum kick him out, he'll get even worse.

1
Greyspire•

If not having a high school diploma is an issue maybe he could get a GED? Not sure if he is here in the US or not, but depending on the country there could be a program like that?

2
Ceirios_o7OP•

That's a good idea, I'll look it up and see if it's available and if I could suggest that to him. Sigh, just hope he won't find any excuse to say that it's useless so he doesn't wanna go. Thanks a ton!

1
Not-Patrick•

I'm really sorry you're dealing with this. If only there were some magical thing you could say to get through to him.

Honestly, there's not really anything you can do for him, unfortunately. Trauma and mental illness do not exempt him from being a decent and rational person. Or at the very least making a minimum effort to be one, which it doesn't seem like he is.

Your only hope is that your mom actually does kick him out. While it's not that you want to see your brother struggle or suffer, he's definitely not going to help himself in an environment where he's not made to.

Sometimes people have to get to the point of having nothing left before they realize they have to make changes. That may look like getting emotional and behavioral therapy for unresolved trauma and anger issues, learning organizational and disciplinary skills, and learning to become independent.

Either way, as long as he's living at home, he's got it made out for him with no reason to change.

2
Ceirios_o7OP•

Thank you for taking your time to reply. That first sentence is so true, I really wish I can just magically improve his situation.

But if he gets kick out, what if he ask for help, if I don't help him, what if he take a wrong turn? When I was younger, I used to worry that he'll get into jail because of his anger issues, coz he's pretty destructive when he's driven by emotions. He broke my mum's house door, her PC, her furniture, etc.

If the talk didn't work out well, should we give him the last warning that he will be kicked out and he can't contact us? If that's the case, can we support him financially with giving him some money one time when we shut him out for him to at least find an accommodation? I'm also worried that he might get himself into illegal activities. x.x

1
Greyspire•

This is not a simple thing as everyone has said. But you did mention that your brother likes to play games, does he like to critique them as well? Maybe you could have a conversation about starting a blog reviewing games, if he is good at it he will get a following if not maybe its a distraction that reduces conflict in the home. Or if he really sucks it becomes even more conflict, but what I am getting at is conversations about potential work that do not sound like work revolving around his interests. It may bring in money, may lead to a job which would increase his self worth/esteem. Or it could lead to more anger, perhaps talking in depth to a therapist yourself might give you a better understanding of the root motivations etc.. Good luck!

2
Ceirios_o7OP•

Really appreciate that you've taken the time to reply. He's like, decent at games, but not great, I've actually mentioned that if he'd like to do something that's related to games, or even casual streaming. But he said he's not well educated, and ppl will laugh at him, he's just not motivated to do anything for himself, I don't think his education limits him, it's really him putting himself in a box.

Also, I've heard him talking to ppl in games and it usually cringes me out coz he has negative points in communication, he will say things that he thought it's smart but actually just sounds snobbish or just not related. He doesn't do it on bad intention, but more like he thought it's a cool way to present himself. He also have lots of self righteousness when he speaks. That's why he can't last long in any of his jobs.

Thanks so much for the advice, I'll suggest the blog review and if he's worried about his writing skills, I might suggest him to go video form. Really hope he will at least try, I think he's afraid to fail that's why he doesn't want to try, since all the jobs he looked for are like waiters or farm jobs that require minimum qualifications. I will try again to look for things that might interest him.

1