Is the "lonely landslide" mathematically plausible at all?

After Bartlet's reelection, which he won in a historic 11-point landslide, we come to learn that the House and Senate are won by... Republicans. Is that possible at all? I have my own slight problems with how easily Bartlet won against Ritchie, but I think the bigger issue is giving Bartlet 11 points and still somehow not taking the House or Senate. If Biden had beat Trump by 11 points, the Republicans would have so few seats they would barely get news coverage anymore.

And yeah, I get it's a parallel with Clinton's reelection in 1996, where the Dems lost net two Senate seats and only narrowly won the House popular vote, even though Clinton had 49% of the vote, losing the House by 20 seats, but how far they went with it is just implausible to me with Bartlet winning possibly 53%+ of the vote.

edit: the wiki says there was no independent vote at all and Bartlet won 55%, wow lol

Posted Oct 17, 2021, 6:02 PM UTC

126
PlayfulReveal191Bartlet for America•

Nixon won 1972 with over 60% of the vote (23.2% margin), however the Republican Party still lost the House, Senate, and majority of the governorships (the Democrats even won the popular vote for the House). This was due to the unpopularity of George McGovern himself, not the Democratic Party (Nixon was actually pretty liberal too). I feel in TWW Ritchie was unpopular yet the Republicans weren’t. Plus the landslide was a bit unrealistic anyway (It was a bad parallel to 1996 cause people forget Clinton got only 49% and only did so well cause Ross Perot got 8%.). But, you have to remember it’s a TV show.

18
Traum77•

Yeah it was a bit of a TV show stretch for sure but also reflective of a far less polarized American electorate. Split cards seemed much more common before 2000. Also Ritchie's apparent incompetence compared to a guy who'd delivered a super strong economy might have more moderates flocking to Bartlett even if they'd usually vote Republican. That's my headcanon anyway.

7
2016WinnerOP•

I don’t think Ritchie was even portrayed as unpopular. He was definitely seen as bumbling by independents and probably some Republicans but there shouldn’t have been too many defections. Also, keep in mind that Reagan didn’t get the house because of the Solid South voting in Democrats no matter who they voted for President, probably similar for Nixon too, but by the time we get to Bartlet the solid south is gone.

But yeah, it’s a TV show

4
[deleted]•

Reagan won 49 states in 1984 and the Democrats gained Senate seats.

6
RobinJ1994Deputy Deputy Chief of Staff•

Give 'split-ticket voting' a google. People have/use different reasonings for voting for different parties for President and then Congressman and Senator.

People may have loved President Bartlet: he was very popular, and when talking to that trauma therapist, he says something about X quarters of GDP growth. Just as President Clinton one said: "it's the economy, stupid."

However, people may have voted for a Republican congressman/Senator for other reasons, ie. President Bartlet is great and I'll vote for him, but this Republican congressman/senator fought for that extra funding/secured this or that etc, and they're ALSO great.

All boils down to federalism and the distribution of powers, as well as personalities. There are 50 states, so those 50 electorates use different reasons for voting tactfully, and have different experiences with politics and Washington.

2
Vershneim•

From the perspective of the writers, I think the Democrats' not controlling Congress was useful, in that it created more story opportunities for hard negotiations to pass legislation. From a realistic point of view, yeah, I feel like it's strange

1