Gravel bike feeling sluggish?

Bike

I recently bought a Giant Revolt Advanced 3 and I have to admit I've been a bit underwhelmed by it. I've been dreaming about getting a carbon bike forever and I found that it is just so much less snappy and quick than my aluminum trek road bike from 2012. It's even heavier than the old road bike. Despite running tubeless and trying lower pressures, it doesn't really float over anything that I couldn't have ridden on my road bike with 23mm tires at 80psi. A big root that protruded up above the trail sent me over the handlebars the other day and it isn't really capable on the trails around the Boston area. For better or for worse, we don't really have endless miles of dirt roads, where I think this would be more suited. Kind of wishing I had saved my money and bought a cheap hard-tail mountain bike. I am running the stock 38mm tires, so I know that I could go up to 45mm to make it a little more capable, but I'm worried that that would just add to it's lack of pep. Thoughts?

UPDATE Edit: I returned the bike. Getting a bike with less tire clearance like 35-38mm and more aggressive geometry. For those of us without miles of dirt roads around us, even an entry level endurance road bike is going to feel more exciting than this gravel bike because the wheels are heavy. It’s just better bang for your buck. You could drop tons and get carbon rims etc but for reasonable pricing anything that can fit 35mm tires can do short stretches of anything you can do on 40-45mm while making your road miles more fun.

Update 2: I ended up finding an entry level hardtail on Craigslist for $350. 42mm tires. So much fun! So much more capable off road and does not feel sluggish getting to the trails near me. The cost of a carbon gravel bike feels absurd by comparison but I recognize that they are different machines. I test rode a bunch of endurance road bikes but honestly they all felt pretty comparable to my 2012 aluminum road bike on tarmac so it definitely did not make sense financially. Not to fuel the N+1 fire, I found that I got the best of all worlds at a much lower cost owning 2 bikes rather than owning an expensive enough gravel bike to be super snappy on the road. Of course starting from scratch, a nice bike with a wheel set swap would have done the trick too potentially and opened up cyclocross more which is my one area of slight weakness.

Posted Oct 22, 2021, 12:30 PM UTC · edited

644
Loading comments…