Harmonic function as a product of chord quality or scale degree?
Still fairly new to music theory so forgive me if this is a stupid question, but when I’m thinking about harmonic function (tonic, subdominant and dominant functions), should that be as a result of the chord’s scale degree or its quality?
I’ve always heard functional harmony described by using triads as examples (tonic, mediant and submediant chords as having tonic ‘function’, super and subdominant chords as having ‘subdominant’ function, and dominant and leading tone chords as having ‘dominant’ function).
But, in the key of C, if I were to build a 7sus4 chord on the third scale degree (E7sus4), should I treat that chord in my head as a dominant-functioning chord with a root note of E or as a normal tonic-functioning chord with a bit of spice?
I hope my question is clear and not too poorly worded
Posted Oct 24, 2021, 2:27 PM UTC
Can’t tell its function without context. What happens after the E?
Okay that’s good to know. So it’s a bit more of a multifaceted question than just ‘this is the chord in this key, therefore it should be doing this exact thing’?
Right function means “what is it doing?” Without context, it’s not doing anything.
[deleted]
Switch to a visual metaphor:
Let's say I've got a paint brush and some yellow paint. I paint one yellow dot on my canvas. What's the yellow dot doing?
Well, if it's on a white canvas, maybe not much — the yellow is hard to see.
If it's on a black canvas, that same dot really jumps out because of the high contrast.
If you put the yellow dot right next to a blue dot and squint or step far enough away, together they'll look green. Or next to a red dot they might look orange.
Or if it's next to a slightly darker yellow dot it may be part of a gradient.
So we can't really say anything about the yellow dot without taking its background and the things next to it into consideration too.
"Should" is a matter of "what chord we expect to follow". I.e., a matter of "common practice", familiar kinds of chord change.
In key of C major, E7sus4 (E-A-B-D) is diatonic, so its function - what might follow that chord - is ambiguous. Maybe the missing 3rd is G natural? Why wouldnt it be?
In that case it's just an extended iii chord. Maybe even a kind of embellishment of the tonic (functionally speaking). Nice, but not really very "spicy".
As such, we might expect an Am to follow, but there would be no strong tendency to expect that. Almost anything could follow it. We wouldn't necessarily analyze it as "V/vi" (AFAIK).
But if it was E or E7 - or you followed E7sus4 with E7 - then Am would be anticipated much more strongly. That's because the G# reveals it as a secondary dominant: V/vi, V of the vi chord. When we hear an E major in key of C, we're used to hearing Am (or sometimes A7) coming next. Hence the functional analysis. (NB: it's the chromatic major 3rd that matters. Not the 7th (D) which is diatonic and optional.)
That still doesn't mean Am must follow. The "rule" is only a "common practice". In fact, it's probably almost as common in modern music for E to go to F, in what is (debatably) a "deceptive cadence". (It works because F shares two notes with Am.)