Just finished the manga, my reaction

SpoilerAGK Manga

Posted Oct 25, 2021, 4:58 PM UTC

528
addygilOP•

As the title states, I finished the manga. all in all, it was definitely a step up from the anime in almost all regards, but I actually really enjoyed the tragedy of the anime. I also fucking despise Tsunderes, and Run was a good boy who deserved better. I loved wild hunt being a good foil for Jaegers, but the highlight for me was definitely chapters 50-56. We got to see Syura and Lubbock's intelligence in a way that didn't feel ridiculous, and Budo was a fucking badass.

​

apologies for my shitty editing

13
Boromir1821•

but I actually enjoyed the tragedy of the anime. I also fucking despise Tsunderes, and Run was a good boy who deserved better.

Yea i am with you on this one run definitely deserved better and mine only got the happy ending because she was author's favorite character or so i heard another highlight for me was the relationship between wave and kurome by far the best love story of the series as for who tastumi should have ended up with i prefer akame. And yea the anime did a much better job potraying the tragedy of night raid mainly due to the music especially the last voice over before the credits on episode 24 man that scene is amazing

7
addygilOP•

100% on Kurome and Wave. I got so fucking pissed at Tatsumi when he stopped Wave from interfering, and while I completely understand where Tatsumi was coming from, I felt Wave's hatred flowing through me.

1
CavaliereNero_•

I don't understand how you can prefer the anime, considering that the manga is completely superior.

That said, judging by your comments, you just seem to me to be an Esdeath fan who prefers the anime just because in the anime Esdeath dies happy embrac Tatsumi corpse, while in the manga Tatsumi and Mine end up together and Esdeath dies alone. Which frankly seems to me to be a ridiculous motivation.

If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me.

0†
addygilOP•

I don't actually prefer the anime, merely the anime ending. The setup for the series led me to believe that it would be a tragedy, and while the journey of the anime was much, much worse than the manga, the ending itself was much better in my opinion. The characters I didn't like all died, and the title character was the only protagonist that truly "lived" (Najenda is convinced she is going to kick the bucket any minute) through the ending.

The bit where Akame killed tyrant sentience took me out of the series, as the tyrant came from Incursio, and it is said that Murasame doesn't work on biological taigus, but somehow worked on the dragon's sentience, but not the draconic body itself. If Mine had survived but Tatsumi didn't, I think that would have also been a good enough ending. I didn't feel like they had a lot of chemistry, but the only relationship I felt any real chemistry from was Wave x Kurome. Esdeath and Tatsumi wouldn't work out.

All that said, Esdeath dying contently with Tatsumi in her arm was certainly a plus, it certainly isn't a deciding factor. As strange as this sounds, I feel like Esdeath didn't do a whole lot, and dying with Tatsumi gives her more to have done. Most of her impact was offscreen as it were. She kills a lot of people, but nobody we care about. The worst blow she deals to the audience is killing the automaton. I apologize if this seems at all hostile, it is not, I just enjoy discussing things I enjoy.

2
CavaliereNero_•

The setup for the series led me to believe that it would be a tragedy, and while the journey of the anime was much, much worse than the manga, the ending itself was much better in my opinion. The characters I didn't like all died, and the title character was the only protagonist that truly "lived" (Najenda is convinced she is going to kick the bucket any minute) through the ending.

I personally disagree, but in retrospect preferring a more bitter ending or a sweeter ending is more a matter of taste than anything else, and frankly it doesn't make much sense to discuss it.

The bit where Akame killed tyrant sentience took me out of the series, as the tyrant came from Incursio, and it is said that Murasame doesn't work on biological taigus, but somehow worked on the dragon's sentience, but not the draconic body itself.

Tyrant was a living creature, not a biological teigu.

If Mine had survived but Tatsumi didn't, I think that would have also been a good enough ending.

I disagree, Tatsumi deserves a happy ending much more than Wave and Kurome, if there was really need to kill someone, it would have been much fairer and it would have made much more sense to kill Kurome or Wave (or maybe both). But even here it is a matter of taste

I didn't feel like they had a lot of chemistry, but the only relationship I felt any real chemistry from was Wave x Kurome.

You are right to say that they had less chemistry but it is equally true that the relationship of Mine and Tatsumi have much more sense than that of Wave and Kurome.

All that said, Esdeath dying contently with Tatsumi in her arm was certainly a plus, it certainly isn't a deciding factor.

Personally I hated that scene, for two reasons, the first is that Esdeath deserved to die alone, and the second is that Esdeath proves once again her total indifference to what Tatsumi wanted and desired (infact Tatsumi would surely have preferred to be buried in his village next to Sayo and ieyasu rather than end up in a thousand pieces with a woman he had never loved and who had never respected him)

I apologize if this seems at all hostile, it is not, I just enjoy discussing things I enjoy.

Don't worry, I also like to discuss (even animatedly) the things I like.

4
addygilOP•

I completely understand where you come from on the subject of Wave and Kurome, and respect your distaste for Esdeath's death in the anime. Upon reflection, I do how dying alone does suit Esdeath's character.

I am having a lot of difficulty wrapping my head around Tyrant. I have tried several times to type out what exactly I don't get, but I can't quite figure out how to put it down :/

The most important question, is how the hell does wave have a microphone in this scene?!?

2
Boromir1821•

Tyrant is essentially a plot device , a dragon that theoratically breaks the world due to his bonkers abilities and most importantly his unbreakable will to archive his goal (sounds like someone we know does it)

The most important question, is how the hell does wave have a microphone in this scene?!?

Its anime

1