Lucky's performance at the major, his place in (and the way forward for) Astralis.

Lucky's performance here was hard to judge, in my opinion. On some maps, he looked like the only player in the server for Astralis (most notably vs NIP), but on many other maps he was nothing notable.

I just don't know what to make of it when he only looks decent by comparison when Astralis gets shat on, and looks mediocre when Astralis is winning. If Astralis gets fucked 1-16, 6-16, then he'll do okay considering the scoreline. You'll look at it and go "Huh, 0.8, not bad considering".On the other hand, look at the victories, especially the close ones. In victories overall he's rated just barely positive : 1.035. If you narrow it down to victories where the opponent got double digits, it goes down to just 0.946. As an AWPer, that is not good (see table at the bottom for all numbers).

What that implies, to me, is that he's not a difference maker. He's reliable, he hasn't fallen apart throughout some tough games (NIP, Entropiq, CPH Flames), and I credit him for it, but when Astralis wins, it's not because of Lucky, and when they lose, Lucky can't turn it around for them.
Maybe he can grow into that, but I would be hesitant to bank on that. Maybe Astralis can grow into a more Rifle based team (maybe with Konfig, who knows), akin to 2019 Liquid, where all that's needed from Lucky is for him to do his job, and it's on the rifles to take them through.

He'll never replace Device, but nobody could do that. I think he can become a serviceable part of the team, but the team will need to change for that. If you slot Lucky into device's role and everyone else plays as they did with device, they'll lose. There's no chance. If you have Lucky as your AWPer, maybe a bit more turret style, less mobile and demanding than the versatile seemingly omnipresent style Device was known for, then maybe you can use him as a pivot point for your riflers to open up the map, with Lucky controlling a rotation point.

I don't think Lucky was a mistake to sign. I don't think there's any AWPer they could have signed from the Danish scene that would not leave them with the daunting issue of not-being-Device. Especially with the roster still slightly in flux (Dupreeh and Magisk's contracts have not been extended yet, with ~two months to go, and rumours of Dupreeh moving to Sweden, and Konfig to Astralis abound), I'm not surprised the implementation is not perfectly worked out. I think Lucky can be part of a consistent top 10, perhaps even top 5, Astralis - when the dust settles.

​

VersusW/LScoreRating
VitalityL13-160.72
VitalityW16-140.92
VitalityL10-161.24
HeroicL7-160.55
NIPL1-160.86
FURIAW16-101.01
SpiritW16-120.97
SpiritW16-81.29
PaiNW19-160.92
PaiNW16-80.98
GODSENTW16-110.91
GODSENTW16-31.28
EntropiqL6-160.8
Copenhagen FlamesL6-160.81

Average rating overall : 0.947
Average Rating in defeat : 0.83
Average rating in victory : 1.035
Average rating in close victory (i.e. opponent got double digits) : 0.946

Posted Nov 2, 2021, 1:17 PM UTC

65
LipiG:NIP:•

imo he's not good enough if astralis wants to be a top 10 team

2
randomnamewhatevsOP:HowlPin:•

Not even top 10? I can understand scepticism about top 5, but we've seen other teams break top 10 without having a star AWPer.
(Most notably 2019) Liquid, G2 throughout this year has been in semi-finals quite often and consistent top 10, we've seen Mouz break into the top 10 despite Acor not being a star, Complexity at their peak was mainly running off BlameF and Konfig with Poizon being mostly a 'support' AWP, Furia is probably going to be back in the top 10 after this major and they don't really have anyone filling the AWP role...

Like, there's plenty of examples of it working, and I think that a rifling squad like Glaive + Xyp9x + Magisk + Konfig definitely has the power to lock it down without a star AWP.

3
tlouman:G2:•

The issue is that those teams have stars to rely on, astralis doesn't anymore with device gone, dupreeh is their entry so he will be very hit and miss at times because of his role. For a good top 10 team you need at least one star to constantly frag out and win the game for you and you need 1 or 2 people supporting him always for you to win. An awper being your star makes it much easier as they do not need as much support due to the nature of the awp and how much space it creates. When astralis lost dev1ce, they lost their star and their awper. Now you need all of your rifles online at all times for a mediocre awper to work. Look at G2, their star is niko who can just win them rounds and they still struggle, now look at heroic, they have a good awper in cadian, super aggressive at times, making space, they have a star in refrezh, good rifles in stavn, Teses and sjush, much well rounded and they look comfortable most of the time, even giving navi a run for their money. For astralis to be consistently top 10 they need lucky to be a very serviceable awper who can create space, they would need a star rifler, and a fired up glaive

1
randomnamewhatevsOP:HowlPin:•

You don't think Magisk and Konfig can be consistent stars? I think those two are both better than Refrezh, for example.

It'll require a bit of rejigging in the team, but I think it can work out. Remember - even within Astralis we've seen examples of occasions where device wasn't the star we know and love, and we saw Dupreeh and Magisk rise to bear the load. It's far from impossible.

Device was the best player on Astralis, absolutely, but to imply they have no stars beyond that is a bit excessive. When Astralis was the best team in the world, every single player earned a spot in the HLTV top 20. I wasn't a 2018 s1mple situation.

Magisk has been a top 20 player 4 out of the last 5 lists.
Dupreeh has been a top 20 player 7 out of the last 8.
They are not liabilities, they are some of the best riflers out there. I think they can absolutely be the star riflers needed to bring a team to the top 10 in Liquid style. If they end up bringing in Konfig for Dupreeh as is being rumoured - Konfig has been a highly impactful player over the years too, great entry - exactly what you'd need if you want a rifler to open up rounds.

It's very important here to also say what exactly top 10 means. Top 10 means doesn't mean you win everything. Top 10 doesn't mean you're unbeatable. Top 10 means you're making quarter and semi finals consistently, maybe winning less stacked tournaments occasionally. Hell, you don't even need to win. OG is a top 10 team. CPH Flames is already a top 10 team without even making play-offs, just off the challenger stage. That's the sort of level you're looking at.

I cannot imagine a world where, given time to adjust to rifle-based teamplay, Konfig/Dupreeh + Magisk + Gla1ve + Xyp9x + Lucky are not good enough to play at that level.

3
Tilbakestaende•

He’s not device, but he appears to actually be good enough for a top 5 team if he makes progress. He’s inexperience shows in the close games, but most of his bad performance are from games were astralis got destroyed and you just can’t expect the rookie in a game full of major winners to be the one to pull them through.

1