Peer-to-peer coverage?

General Discussion

Hi all,

I have some technical questions. I know they sound very critical but I love the project, I’m just not very good at formulating them :)..

Helium is sometimes denoted to be a “peer to peer lorawan network”. But I don’t see it being a peer to peer network, a hotspot just picks up data from close-by sensors and sends them through the gigabit ethernet connection most of us have. So essentially we’re creating long ranged public access points. The smart (and currently money bringing) concept is the proof of coverage (witnessing) protocol that triangulates (?) positions and rewards the expansion of the network.

Requiring an direct internet connection of the hotspot means that this network will never be able to cover remote areas well. You’d need to bring proper internet there first. Why isn’t it possible/desired to expand the network in a true peer-to-peer manner and allow e.g. solar-powered nodes you can plant in the middle of nowhere. They’d communicate with reachable peers, and so on and so forth until it hits a node that is directly connected to the internet. Coverage proof should still work the same, no need for internet there. Rewards can be scaled to the contribution for connectivity and forwarding work.

Is my understanding correct?

Thx&Cheers.

Posted Nov 6, 2021, 7:26 PM UTC

32
Chase1477•

Many of us have solar cellular rigs. I don’t think there hasn’t been a place inside U.S that can’t get coverage. Even Alaska has decent network.

1
mikesoso20•

I had the same question. It could be a network adoption strategy and then they turn on peer to peer later?

1