Snack size drama: -3 damage per strike in a short slapfight over low Strength scores in r/DnD
reddit.com/r/DnD/comments/831t1f/what_are_the...Posted Nov 9, 2021, 2:54 AM UTC
Posted Nov 9, 2021, 2:54 AM UTC
10 str can deadlift like 200
OK I haven't played DnD for decades but this is not right.
10 is "Dwayne Johnson's buff brother" levels, not "went to the gym for a week" level. and mixed it up it with WoD systems. Yeah 10 is not impressive, my bad.
10 is average. Not strong and not weak. It doesn't have to be impressive, I'd be willing most guys my age can also lift 200 if necessary.
That's also max press, so not your daily or normal lifting. It's the most you could lift if you absolutely had to, like say you dropped your 500lb cruiser on the 210 during rushhour.
Um Actually, per the rules it's what you can lift all day every day no check required. But also a 10 strength would be a carrying capacity of 150 and a push/pull/lift of 300 with weight above 150 dropping your speed to 5'.
Unless they were using the variant encumbrance in which a 10 strength individual would first take a 10' speed penalty at 50lbs and a further speed drop and a bunch of disadvantages from 100 to 150lbs.
There's no explicit rules for surpassing these limits though it's implied that that's what strength checks are for. An Olympic lifter would be a special class that gives a whole bunch of bonus to that ability check to lift the weights they do.
If I need that much granulation in strength checks I just fall back to 2e tables which were much more concise on the subject with a sliding scale of weight.
I don't know that I could defeat a hawk so maybe I'm STR 4.
Hawks being tiny creatures, at least have at least +2 to ac from size, then add in their dexterity (17) gives them an ac of 15 minimum (actually 17 because of their +2 natural armor.
The average human with 10 strength would have a 20% chance of hitting them every time they're in range (provoking an attack of opportunity each time against the hawk because the average human is not trained in unarmed combat)
The human would have +0 to hit (10 strength has a modifier of +0, and as a commoner you would have no Base Attack Bonus to add to the attack) and the hawk would have +5. Since humans have, on average 1d8 hit points, and hawks share the same. A hawk will, far more often than not, kill any human that tries to take them down.
Edit: More maths
| # | Human | Hawk |
|---|---|---|
| AC | 10 | 17 |
| HP(1d8 + con) | 4.5 | 4.5 |
| Attack Bonus | +0 | +5 |
| Chance to hit | 20% | 80% |
| Average Damage per round | .2 | 1 |
| Average rounds of survival | 4.5 | 22.5 |
A hawk will, far more often than not, kill any human that tries to take them down.
That's fucking stupid, I could beat the shit out of a hawk
Not according to math. Even a house cat could take you down.
I took judo for 5 years, I have the improved grapple feat - I don't provoke an attack of opportunity when I try to grapple the hawk and also get a +2 bonus to grapple. The hawk has a size of tiny, while I as a Dutchman have a racial modifier that lets me qualify as large. A pinned hawk gets a dexterity modifier of -5 (that's MODIFIER, its dexterity will be 0 during the grapple), and attacking creatures that are pinned down gets you a further +4 bonus. Like I said, I could beat the shit out of a hawk.
Not if I'm in the dark
what edition are you pulling from? 5e MM lists hawks significantly weaker than what you have here. https://5e.tools/bestiary.html#hawk_mm
Also, if you pull the commoner from the 5e MM again for consistency, it would have +2 to hit 1d4 Club attack. https://5e.tools/bestiary.html#commoner_mm
3.5 because I know it better.
Although that does even it out a bit more.
80% chance to hit for 1 damage (needs to hit 4.5 times) for the hawk
40% chance to hit for all the damage (needs to hit one time) for the human.
5e does mean that the human will only get fucked up and not murdered.
Lol when people default to 3 or 3.5 you know they're easily as old as you are. My people...
About time they nerfed hawks!
I enjoy that I could follow all of that.
[removed]
I'm playing a 4 STR rogue and the worst thing that has happened to me was that I couldn't lift the lid off of a stone tomb on my own cause I rolled like a 3.... and it was meant to be team challenge either way.
my first DM told us that our lower stat had to be an 8 cause lower stats make characters more interesting and it really does. a -1 modifier is not the end of the world and people in that thread are overreacting,
How did you get a strength that low?!
If you roll for stats min possible is 3
1 1 2 on three 6 sided dice.
I always felt a low star is more of a crutch than a Boon for how interesting a character is. That being said if it works for you go off
TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK > Stopscopiesme.
Snapshots:
I am just a simple bot, not a moderator of this subreddit | bot subreddit | contact the maintainers
Nice, old drama to catch popcorn pissers and niche at that. So refreshing vs the recent ongoing shitshows.
Yeah, that's D&D. First time? Literally the point is wizards are not balanced.
Ding ding ding ding ding. We have ourselves the winner of D&D here. It's always been house rules trump game rules. The guy bitching about wizards is an idiot.
What's your point, person within Fireball range?
Talking a lot of shit for someone in fireball distance.
Real mouthy for a flammable fellow.
Laughs in Fire Gensai!
Not just wizard but spellcasters in general. The graph for scaling between martial sand caster in dnd has always been an x with martial scaling downward as levels increase and casters scaling upwards.
People love to complain about tabletop games. Once mentioned in a telegram group about a d&d game I had been running for mostly players new to tabletop games (1 player has some experience, 1 player has had 1 game before with me, and the other 3 have never played a tabletop games before). And someone legit went off on me that I should be running gurps as d&d is too limited.
Like I'm not gonna bring people who wanted to try d&d and unsure of everything for tabletop RPGs to gurps. Save other systems for when people get more familiar.
(I know gurps can be simple if you keep to the base stuff, but it's a lot easier to teach d&d as it's presence in pop culture makes people really receptive to want to learn stuff)
"Rule of Cool"